Black Mirror / Series 4 / Episode 1

USS Callister

A beloved 1960s-style space show turns out to be one man's private game, and his crew never asked to be in it.

  • Released Dec 29, 2017 · Netflix
  • Directed by Toby Haynes
  • Written by William Bridges and Charlie Brooker
  • Starring Jesse Plemons and Cristin Milioti
Still from Black Mirror, "USS Callister"
Still from Black Mirror, "USS Callister"
Image via TMDB · 1 of 3
Black Mirror, "USS Callister" (Netflix, 2017). Image via TMDB.

More from the episode

The story in 5 beats

  1. Space Fleet

    Captain Daly and his loyal crew defeat the villain Valdack. Everyone on the bridge cheers their captain.

  2. The real Daly

    At work, Daly is ignored by his staff and pushed around by his co-founder, Walton. He goes home alone.

  3. The new crew member

    New programmer Nanette Cole wakes up on the bridge. She's a copy, made from DNA on a coffee cup she threw away.

  4. The heistSpoiler · tap to reveal

    The crew plots an escape through the game's next update, and needs the real Nanette's help to do it.

  5. The wormholeSpoiler · tap to reveal

    They fly into the update and out of Daly's reach. In the real world, he's stuck in his own headset.

Why it still matters

It opens like a loving parody of Star Trek: square jaws, bright colors, a captain who saves the day and gets the girl. Then you meet the captain in real life. Robert Daly is the brilliant, ignored co-founder of a game company, and at night he logs into a private version of its game where his coworkers serve on his ship. They aren't avatars. He has built digital copies of them from their DNA, fully aware and unable to leave, and he punishes them when they don't play along.

It's Black Mirror's most entertaining episode and one of its darkest ideas at once. The crew's escape plan plays like a heist, Cristin Milioti is terrific as the new hire who refuses to accept the rules, and Jesse Plemons, who studied with a vocal coach to get the Shatner cadence right, makes Daly pathetic and frightening in the same breath. It won four Emmys, including Outstanding Television Movie.

Spoilers from here on. The escape is a lot more fun if you don't know how it works.

How they get out

Daly's game is cut off from the internet, but its next update will pull everything through a wormhole to the public game, where his godlike controls don't work. While Nanette distracts Daly on a planet, the crew uses his scanner to reach her real self, blackmailing her with her own private photos into ordering a pizza to his apartment, stealing his DNA samples and setting it all up. Walton, the copy of the co-founder Daly hates most, sacrifices himself to fix the engines. The ship goes through, and the update locks Daly out with no way to leave the game. The crew wakes up in the public version of Infinity, free and in charge of their own ship. Brooker has said Daly starves, since he'd hung a "Do Not Disturb" sign on his door.

The Question Underneath

What do people do when they're sure no one will ever find out?

Daly is meek at work and a tyrant in his private game, and the episode suggests both are him. The game simply removes the cost. What makes it more than a revenge story is how the crew respond: they aren't saved by a hero. They save themselves by working together, and they get out by being cleverer than the man who thought he owned them.

Challenge the DNA

Did Daly get what he deserved?

Did Daly get what he deserved?
Or skip ahead to our reading

Yes, though it's a hard thing to cheer. The episode lets you enjoy the escape and then quietly shows you the man left behind.

Behind the scenes

  • The idea of a "Black Mirror version of a space epic" started while the team was filming "Playtest" in series three. Co-writer William Bridges, a big Star Trek fan, added most of the Trek touches and borrowed from Galaxy Quest. Brooker said the episode isn't an attack on Star Trek, a show he called wildly ahead of its time.
  • Other influences include The Twilight Zone's "It's a Good Life," about a boy whose whole town has to obey him.
  • They couldn't copy Star Trek sets for legal reasons, so they designed their own in the same spirit, and kept most scenes on the bridge or in corridors. Filming took 20 days at Twickenham Studios, plus about three days on Lanzarote in the Canary Islands for the alien planet.
  • The neoprene costumes were chosen to give the women a Barbie look and Daly a Ken-doll one.
  • Aaron Paul has a voice cameo at the end as Gamer691, a nod to Breaking Bad, where Plemons played opposite him. Kirsten Dunst, Plemons's fiancée, asked to appear in the background of an office scene.

The thread

Where Space Fleet came from, who else has been trapped in someone else's fantasy, and where the crew went next.

Came before

Shares DNA with

"I Have No Mouth, and I Must Scream"Harlan Ellison · short story · 1967 · prisoners of a godlike machine

Left its mark on

DNA strand

Technology Outpaces Ethics

Here the technology is a toy, and the ethics problem is the man holding it. Daly isn't a supervillain; he's a lonely, resentful employee who discovers he can be a god somewhere nobody's watching. The episode asks what we owe a copy of a person, and it answers loudly: everything we'd owe the person.

Every great sci-fi story is built from a handful of strands like this one. Each strand page explains how it works and traces it across shows, books and films.

Also in this strand:"Be Right Back""The Measure of a Man"Explore this strand →

If this one stayed with you

Where to go next, and why.

Watch · Film

Galaxy Quest (1999)

The warm version of the same joke: actors from a cancelled space show discover the aliens watching it think it was real. One of the writers' stated influences.

Watch · Black Mirror Special

"White Christmas" (2014)

Copies of people's minds put to work as household servants. If the clones were the part that got under your skin, this is where Brooker first went there.

Watch · Twilight Zone S3

"It's a Good Life" (1961)

A six-year-old with the power to wish people into the cornfield, and a town that smiles because it has to. Daly's grandfather.

Watch · Star Trek S2

"Mirror, Mirror" (1967)

The real Star Trek going dark: the same crew on a ship where loyalty is enforced by fear. It's a fun double bill with this one.

Your next episode

Three directions to go from here, all on Sci-Fi DNA.

Still from Black Mirror, "Nosedive"

More of this feeling

Nosedive

Black Mirror

More Black Mirror that's funny until it isn't.

Still from Star Trek: The Next Generation, "The Measure of a Man"

Same question, different answer

The Measure of a Man

Star Trek: The Next Generation

Do digital people get rights? Star Trek put that question on trial in 1989.

Still from Star Trek: The Next Generation, "Darmok"

Something completely different

Darmok

Star Trek: The Next Generation

A starship captain who listens. The opposite of Robert Daly.

On the trails Funny, then not (stop 5 of 5) and Double feature: is a copy a person? (stop 2 of 2).

Sources