Black Mirror / Series 4 / Episode 2

Arkangel

After losing her little girl for a few terrifying minutes, a single mother signs up for an implant that lets her see what her daughter sees, and blur out anything upsetting.

  • Released Dec 29, 2017 · Netflix
  • Directed by Jodie Foster
  • Written by Charlie Brooker
  • Starring Rosemarie DeWitt and Brenna Harding
Still from Black Mirror, "Arkangel"
Still from Black Mirror, "Arkangel"
Image via TMDB · 1 of 3
Black Mirror, "Arkangel" (Netflix, 2017). Image via TMDB.

More from the episode

The story in 5 beats

  1. Lost at the playground

    Three-year-old Sara wanders off after a cat. Marie finds her, but the panic doesn't leave, and she signs Sara up for a free trial of Arkangel.

  2. The blur

    The implant blurs anything frightening Sara sees, from the neighbor's dog to a drop of blood. She grows up gentle and curious, and missing something.

  3. The tablet goes in a drawer

    After Sara hurts herself just to see what blood looks like, Marie switches off the filter and puts the tablet away. Sara grows up mostly unwatched.

  4. Switched back onSpoiler · tap to reveal

    Teenage Sara lies about where she's going with Trick. Marie takes the tablet out of the drawer, and sees far too much.

  5. The pillSpoiler · tap to reveal

    Marie secretly slips something into Sara's morning smoothie. When Sara finds out, it ends in violence, and she leaves.

Why it still matters

Most Black Mirror gadgets are sold to us. This one is sold to parents, which makes it harder to dismiss. Executive producer Annabel Jones said the idea started with the ID microchips put in pets, which were then being talked about for children, and Charlie Brooker drew on how protective he felt once he had kids of his own. Arkangel lets Marie track her daughter, watch through her eyes and switch on a filter that pixelates anything distressing. Every one of those features sounds reasonable on the day you buy it.

Jodie Foster directed, and she kept it small and quiet: a working-class mother and daughter, a kitchen table, a tablet in a drawer. Foster said it felt "like a Bergman movie" to her, and that mother and daughter are, "in a weird way," the same person. She drew on being raised by a single mother herself and pushed for Marie to be darker than the script first had her. Watch Rosemarie DeWitt's face whenever Marie picks up that tablet. The episode never tells you whether she's right to.

Spoilers from here on. The ending turns on what the tablet can't fix.

What the tablet costs

Once Marie starts watching again, she can't stop. She sees Sara sleep with Trick and take cocaine, and she tracks Trick down and tells him to stay away from her daughter. Then Arkangel tells her Sara is pregnant, and Marie crushes an emergency contraceptive pill into Sara's morning smoothie. The school nurse tells Sara what she took. Sara finds the tablet, and when Marie comes home, Sara beats her with it until the screen breaks. She walks out to the road and climbs into a stranger's truck.

The last image takes you back to the first: Marie, bloodied, stumbles into the street calling for Sara, exactly as she did when Sara was three. The device was sold to stop that moment from ever happening again, and it ends by causing it. Critics praised Foster and DeWitt but found the story and its moral simple. Planned Parenthood objected to the nurse describing the pill as "terminating your pregnancy," which confuses contraception with abortion.

Behind the scenes

  • Annabel Jones said the starting point was pet ID microchips, then being considered for children, and the team wanted "a really good idea of how that could go terribly wrong."
  • Foster controlled casting and much of the crew. She cast her friend Rosemarie DeWitt as Marie.
  • Brenna Harding got the part of teenage Sara after performing a monologue as the character at her audition. The younger Saras were chosen to look like her.
  • It was shot over three weeks in November 2016 in Hamilton, Ontario, which Foster chose to stand in for blue-collar America.
  • Foster also helped Brooker with the edit in London.
  • The Pretenders' "I'm a Mother" plays over the end credits.
  • Location manager Malcolm McCulloch was nominated for a Location Managers Guild award for the episode.

The thread

The real chip it started from, the earlier episodes about seeing through someone's eyes, and the stories that share its worry.

Came before

Pet ID microchipsreal technology · the implant Jones says sparked the idea

Shares DNA with

The GiverLois Lowry · novel · 1993 · a community that spares its children every painful thing

DNA strand

Technology Outpaces Ethics

Arkangel does exactly what it promises. The trouble is that nobody asked what a child loses by never seeing a barking dog or a drop of blood, or what a parent becomes once she can check. The ethics arrive about fifteen years after the product.

Every great sci-fi story is built from a handful of strands like this one. Each strand page explains how it works and traces it across shows, books and films.

Also in this strand:"The Entire History of You""Crocodile"Explore this strand →

If this one stayed with you

Where to go next, and why.

Watch · Black Mirror

"The Entire History of You"

If the tablet in the drawer bothered you, this is the earlier version: an implant that lets you replay what you saw, and a marriage that can't leave it alone.

Read · Novel

The Giver: Lois Lowry

A whole society built on Marie's instinct to keep pain away from children, seen through the eyes of a boy who starts to notice what's missing.

Watch · Film

The Truman Show (1998)

Another person whose whole life is watched by someone who thinks he's protecting them. Funnier, and kinder, but asking the same question.

Sources