Black Mirror / Series 3 / Episode 1

Nosedive

Everyone rates everyone, one to five stars, all day long. Lacie needs a 4.5 for a nicer apartment, and a wedding should get her there.

  • Released Oct 21, 2016 · Netflix
  • Directed by Joe Wright
  • Story by Charlie Brooker
  • Teleplay by Michael Schur and Rashida Jones
  • Starring Bryce Dallas Howard
Still from Black Mirror, "Nosedive"
Still from Black Mirror, "Nosedive"
Image via TMDB · 1 of 4
Black Mirror, "Nosedive" (Netflix, 2016). Image via TMDB.

More from the episode

The story in 5 beats

  1. 4.2

    Lacie rates and is rated all day. She needs a 4.5 for a discount at Pelican Cove, a luxury development.

  2. The invitation

    Naomi, a 4.8, asks Lacie to give the maid-of-honor speech. The guests are all 4.7 or higher.

  3. The travel day

    A cancelled flight, a scene at the airport, a penalty, a rental car that won't charge. Her number keeps dropping.

  4. SusanSpoiler · tap to reveal

    A trucker rated 1.4 gives her a ride. Susan used to be a 4.6, until her husband was refused cancer treatment because his score was too low.

  5. The speechSpoiler · tap to reveal

    Lacie crashes the wedding and gives a speech nobody wanted. She ends up in a cell, and finally free to say what she thinks.

Why it still matters

In Lacie Pound's world, every interaction ends with a star rating, and your average decides your rent, your flights, even your medical care. Lacie is a 4.2. She is relentlessly pleasant to everyone, and it still isn't enough. When her childhood friend Naomi, a 4.8, asks her to be maid of honor at a wedding full of high-rated guests, it looks like the boost she's been waiting for. Then one bad day of small humiliations starts the slide the title promises.

It's the episode where Black Mirror found out it could be funny. The script came from two American comedy writers, Michael Schur and Rashida Jones, and director Joe Wright painted everything in sickly pastels so the world looks like a frosted cake. Bryce Dallas Howard makes Lacie's desperate smile unbearable to watch and impossible to look away from. Critics later compared it to China's social credit pilots and to real rating apps; Brooker said he hadn't expected that.

Spoilers from here on. The ending lands better if you haven't heard about it.

Rock bottom

Naomi tells Lacie not to come, since a low-rated guest would drag down her own score. Lacie sneaks in anyway, and her speech turns from sweet to savage: she reveals Naomi's worst secrets from their teens in front of everyone. Security drags her away and the guests downvote her below one star. In jail, her eye implant is removed, and she ends up trading furious, joyful insults with the man in the opposite cell. It's the first honest conversation she's had all episode.

The Question Underneath

How much of your kindness would survive if nobody was keeping score?

Lacie's world rewards the look of kindness so well that the real thing has nowhere to live. Every smile is an investment. When she finally loses everything the ratings measured, she's rude, loud and free for the first time. Politeness is fine; the trouble is a system that can't tell being nice from performing it.

Challenge the DNA

Is Lacie's ending a disaster or a release?

Is Lacie's ending a disaster or a release?
Or skip ahead to our reading

A release. Her score is gone and she's in a cell, and she's never looked happier than when she's swearing at the man across the hall.

Behind the scenes

  • Brooker's first version, pitched to American studios after series one, was a comedy in the style of Brewster's Millions: a high-rated person trying to tank their score within 24 hours. Nobody bought it.
  • Schur wrote the first half of the script, up to Lacie setting out in the rental car, and Jones wrote the second half; then they merged them. Early drafts borrowed from Planes, Trains and Automobiles, and the first ending had Lacie's breakdown go viral and make her famous.
  • Director of photography Seamus McGarvey shot it in 4K at Netflix's request. The pastel world was designed by Joel Collins and James Foster, and it won them a Royal Television Society award.
  • It was filmed over four weeks in Knysna, a coastal town in South Africa. Max Richter wrote the score, including the little rating sounds.
  • Bryce Dallas Howard gained 30 pounds for the role. Wright had auditioned her for Atonement a decade earlier.

The thread

What came before the rating app, what shares its sugary dread, and how close the real world got.

Came before

Shares DNA with

Community, "App Development and Condiments"2014 · a campus rating app; Brooker said he hadn't seen it

Left its mark on

Black Mirror: NosediveAsmodee · board game · 2018 · rate your friends at the table

DNA strand

Technology Outpaces Ethics

The rating app in "Nosedive" doesn't do anything evil. It just counts, and everyone else does the rest. So the episode still stings: the technology is barely science fiction, and the cruelty is all social. It's at its sharpest when it's funniest, with Lacie forcing a smile while her number drops.

Every great sci-fi story is built from a handful of strands like this one. Each strand page explains how it works and traces it across shows, books and films.

Also in this strand:"Eye of the Beholder""The Monsters Are Due on Maple Street"Explore this strand →

If this one stayed with you

Where to go next, and why.

Watch · Twilight Zone S2

"Eye of the Beholder" (1960)

A state that decides what normal looks like, 56 years earlier and in black and white. If the pressure to fit in was what got to you, start here.

Watch · TV

The Good Place (2016)

Michael Schur's own sitcom, also about a system that scores every action. Much kinder, and just as interested in what being good actually means.

Read · Novel

The Circle — Dave Eggers

A young woman joins a tech company that wants everyone transparent, all the time. The office version of Lacie's world.

Watch · Black Mirror S1

"Fifteen Million Merits" (2011)

An earlier, angrier Black Mirror about people living for points and approval. Watch both to see how much the show's tone shifted.

Your next episode

Three directions to go from here, all on Sci-Fi DNA.

Still from Black Mirror, "USS Callister"

More of this feeling

USS Callister

Black Mirror

More Black Mirror that plays as comedy and lands as a warning.

Still from The Twilight Zone, "Eye of the Beholder"

Same question, different answer

Eye of the Beholder

The Twilight Zone

Who decides what counts as acceptable? The Twilight Zone asked in 1960.

Still from Star Trek: The Next Generation, "Darmok"

Something completely different

Darmok

Star Trek: The Next Generation

Two strangers who can't understand each other, and actually try.

On the trail Sci-fi without spaceships (stop 4 of 5).

Sources