
More from the episode
The story in 5 beats
- V9-Gamma
A colonist has given up and died. Benteen rallies the rest, keeps the radio watch and promises them Earth.
- The meteor storm
Sheltering in the cave, Benteen tells young Jo-Jo what Earth looks like. The noise outside is not the ship.
- Galaxy 6
Colonel Sloane lands and gives them three days to pack. The colonists play baseball and ask about Earth.
- Plans of their own
Benteen wants a land grant so the colony stays together under him. The colonists have already picked their states.
A population of oneSpoiler · tap to reveal
Everyone votes to go. Benteen refuses, hides in the cave, and runs out too late as the ship lifts off.
Why it still matters
In 1991, by the episode's calendar, 113 settlers left Earth on the Pilgrim I looking for a place without war. They found V9-Gamma, a desert planet where two suns never let up and survival is the only industry. Three decades on, William Benteen, who was fifteen when they set out, holds the colony together with rules, faith and bedtime stories about green hills back home. When word comes that a ship is on its way, he has everything he's been promising them, along with a problem he hasn't noticed yet.
This is one of the few hour-long episodes that earns the hour. Serling uses the extra time to watch a decent man's authority drain away scene by scene, and James Whitmore plays Benteen with such conviction that you understand both why the colonists followed him and why they're ready to stop. Tim O'Connor's Colonel Sloane is his quiet opposite, a man trying hard not to take anything from him.
Look out for the set dressing too. The rescue ship and the crew's uniforms came from MGM's Forbidden Planet, which is why the visitors look sleeker than anything else on the show. The Twilight Zone Vortex calls it perhaps the finest offering of the fourth season, and it's the one to show anyone who thinks the hour-long episodes are all padding.
Once a god
Sloane puts it to a vote. Every hand goes up for Earth except Benteen's. He insists that Earth is violent and that his people won't survive without him, attacks the ship with a pipe and has to be held back, then announces that he's staying. On departure day he hides in the cave while Sloane searches for him. Only after the ship takes off does he remember what Earth looked like, and he runs into the open shouting for it to come back, too late.
Serling's closing line is one of his sharpest: William Benteen, once a god, now a population of one. What makes it sting is that Benteen was right about almost everything for thirty years. He kept them alive. The only thing he got wrong was the day it ended, and he'd sooner lose Earth than lose being needed.
Behind the scenes
- The ship and the crew's uniforms were leftover props from MGM's Forbidden Planet (1956). Footage of the ship landing and taking off was reused from the season's earlier "Death Ship."
- The high final shot wasn't in the plan. Near the end of filming Buzz Kulik asked for a view from far above the set, and cinematographer George T. Clemens climbed up to test it and found the shacks had no roofs. As Clemens told Marc Scott Zicree, the crew had to cover them with canvas overnight.
- Set photos were taken on the Culver City lot on February 27, 1963.
- It was the last episode produced for season four, though not the last to air, and Buzz Kulik's last for the series.
- Serling wrote it while worn down by the hour-long season and teaching at Antioch College in Yellow Springs, Ohio.
- The score is stock music, opening with a cue from Bernard Herrmann's music for "Eye of the Beholder."
- It was later adapted for The Twilight Zone Radio Dramas with Barry Bostwick as Benteen.
The thread
Serling's lonely outposts and frightened communities, a famous MGM spaceship, and the leader who can't let go.
Came before
Shares DNA with
Left its mark on
DNA strand
The State Knows Best
Benteen is the kindest version of the man who knows what's best for everyone: he really did save them. The episode lets you watch protection curdle into ownership, and asks what a leader is for once the emergency is over.
Every great sci-fi story is built from a handful of strands like this one. Each strand page explains how it works and traces it across shows, books and films.
If this one stayed with you
Where to go next, and why.
Watch · The Twilight Zone S5
"The Old Man in the Cave"
Another isolated community, another authority they've learned to obey without question. Watch it as a companion piece and argue about which leader you'd rather have.
Watch · Star Trek S1
"This Side of Paradise"
Colonists on a distant planet who don't want to leave, and an Enterprise crew trying to get them home. The same tug of war from the other end.
Read · Novel
The Mosquito Coast by Paul Theroux
Allie Fox is Benteen with a workshop: brilliant, devoted, and unable to hear anyone say they'd like to go home.
Sources
- “On Thursday We Leave for Home,” Wikipedia
- “On Thursday We Leave for Home,” The Twilight Zone Vortex, 2020
- “How The Twilight Zone Pulled Off an Iconic Ending "Overnight",” SYFY Wire
- “The Twilight Zone, Season 4, Episode Sixteen: On Thursday We Leave for Home,” Great Books Guy, 2022
- Oktay Ege Kozak, “Every Episode of The Twilight Zone, Ranked from Worst to Best,” Paste, 2023
- “The Twilight Zone, Season 4 episode guide,” TVmaze

