The Twilight Zone / Season 5 / Episode 7

The Old Man in the Cave

Ten years after the bombs, a small town survives by doing what the old man in the cave tells it. Then the army arrives and asks to meet him.

  • First aired Nov 8, 1963 · CBS
  • Directed by Alan Crosland Jr.
  • Teleplay by Rod Serling, from the story by Henry Slesar
  • Starring John Anderson and James Coburn
Still from The Twilight Zone, "The Old Man in the Cave"
Still from The Twilight Zone, "The Old Man in the Cave"
Image via TMDB · 1 of 2
The Twilight Zone, "The Old Man in the Cave" (CBS, 1963). Image via TMDB.

More from the episode

The story in 5 beats

  1. The canned food

    Survivors find a stash of tins. Nobody touches them until the old man in the cave says they're clean.

  2. The verdict

    Goldsmith comes back from the cave with bad news: the food is contaminated and has to be destroyed.

  3. Major French

    Soldiers arrive claiming to be organizing the survivors. French wants to know who really runs this town.

  4. The door opensSpoiler · tap to reveal

    French turns the town against Goldsmith, and the cave is forced open. The old man is a computer.

  5. FreedomSpoiler · tap to reveal

    The crowd smashes the machine and eats the food. By morning only Goldsmith is alive.

Why it still matters

It's 1974, a decade after a nuclear war, and a scrap of a town has found a cache of canned food. Nobody eats. They wait for Goldsmith, their leader, to come back from the cave in the hills with the old man's verdict on whether it's safe. The last time they ignored the old man, about which fields to plant, the harvest failed. So they're hungry, and they're patient, and they're starting to resent it.

Rod Serling adapted the story from Henry Slesar, a mystery writer who was also on the staff of the soap The Edge of Night, and it's one of the season's angriest half hours. John Anderson, in his fourth and last Twilight Zone, plays Goldsmith as a tired man holding a fragile system together with faith. James Coburn, years before his Oscar, is Major French, who rolls into town with three soldiers, a lot of charm and a plan. The A.V. Club's Emily St. James wrote that the performance shows exactly why Coburn would become so beloved.

Watch it as a cousin of "The Monsters Are Due on Maple Street": another town, another stranger who knows which buttons to press. TV Obsessive's Will Johnson called it a spiritual sequel to that episode, and said this one gets much darker.

Spoilers from here on. Who, or what, has been in the cave all along, and what happens when they stop listening to it.

What's behind the door

French breaks Goldsmith's hold by doing the one thing the old man forbade: he hands out the contaminated food and drink, and everyone but Goldsmith takes it. Shunned and threatened, Goldsmith finally opens the cave. The oracle is a computer, a big box of blinking lights. French gets the townspeople to smash it and celebrates their freedom from its tyranny, but the machine was right: with nobody left to tell them what's safe, the whole town dies, French and his men included, and Goldsmith walks out alone.

St. James read it as a story about humanity needing to trust in something like a god to survive, and compared Goldsmith to the prophet Jeremiah. It works just as well the other way round: a town that was happy to obey an old man is outraged to find it was obeying a machine, though the advice never changed. Serling's closing calls Goldsmith an eyewitness to man's imperfection, and, as he did in "The Shelter," he signs off with a reminder that this is not a prediction of what is to be, just a projection of what could be.

Marc Scott Zicree, in The Twilight Zone Companion, asked how the computer survived the fallout and where it came from, and the episode never says.

Behind the scenes

  • Serling wrote the teleplay from Henry Slesar's short story "The Old Man." It was the first of two Slesar adaptations that season; the other was "The Self-Improvement of Salvadore Ross."
  • Film critic Andrew Sarris observed that a realistic picture of an atomic bomb's aftermath would likely have been barred from network television at the time.
  • Serling's narration stresses that the story is fiction, as it does in "The Shelter." Both episodes are set in the United States.
  • John Anderson had already appeared in "A Passage for Trumpet," "The Odyssey of Flight 33" and "Of Late I Think of Cliffordville." This was his fourth and last episode.
  • John Marley, who plays the townsman Jason, had played the superintendent of the old-age home in "Kick the Can."
  • The score is stock music, mostly borrowed from the first-season episode "And When the Sky Was Opened."
  • A Twilight Zone radio drama version, with Stacy Keach and Adam Baldwin, was released in 2002.

The thread

Survivors, oracles and the machines people would rather not know they're obeying.

Came before

"The Old Man"Henry Slesar · short story · the source

Shares DNA with

Left its mark on

The Twilight Zone Radio Dramas2002 · Stacy Keach and Adam Baldwin

DNA strand

Atomic-Age Anxiety

This one picks up ten years after the bomb, when the danger is invisible, in the food and the soil, and survival depends on trusting a voice you can't see. The war is over, and the episode is about the fear left behind.

Every great sci-fi story is built from a handful of strands like this one. Each strand page explains how it works and traces it across shows, books and films.

Also in this strand:"The Shelter""Two""Time Enough at Last"Explore this strand →

If this one stayed with you

Where to go next, and why.

Watch · Twilight Zone S1

"The Monsters Are Due on Maple Street"

If French's talent for turning neighbors into a mob was the scariest part, this is where Serling first tried it, on a nice suburban street.

Watch · Twilight Zone S3

"Two"

Another look at the years after the war, almost without words, and with a lot more hope in it.

Read · Novel

A Canticle for Leibowitz by Walter M. Miller Jr.

Centuries of survivors after a nuclear war, keeping knowledge alive they no longer understand. The same argument about faith and machines, at novel length.

Watch · Star Trek S1

"The Return of the Archons"

Kirk finds a planet that does whatever an unseen ruler says, and if you liked arguing with the ending here, this one takes the other side.

Sources