
The story in 5 beats
- Prisoners
Picard, Troi and Geordi are locked in a cell, stripped of their combadges and Geordi's VISOR. Troi can sense only anger from their jailer.
- Forty-seven left behind
Crusher beams up who she can before a new Borg ship arrives. Forty-seven people, Riker and Worf among them, are still on the surface.
- Into the sun
Crusher won't leave. With the ship crippled, she takes the Enterprise into the star's corona, where metaphasic shielding lets it go and the Borg can't.
The experimentSpoiler · tap to reveal
Data straps Geordi down for a brain procedure with a 60% chance of killing him. Picard and a blinded Geordi rig a device to reboot Data's ethics.
BrothersSpoiler · tap to reveal
Lore orders Data to kill Picard. Data refuses, Hugh's rebel Borg attack with Riker and Worf, and Data shuts his brother down.
Why it still matters
Season 6 ended on a cliffhanger, and this premiere had to answer it. René Echevarria wrote it, and the story splits three ways: Picard, Troi and Geordi in a cell, Riker and Worf on the run across the planet, and Beverly Crusher in the captain's chair upstairs.
Watch the Crusher plot. With most of the crew still on the surface and a Borg ship arriving, she refuses to leave anyone behind, and she and two junior officers improvise a way out with technology first seen in "Suspicions". StarTrek.com singles out her risky strategy and the emergency extraction she pulls off.
Critics were cool on it. The A.V. Club called it hollow and Reactor's rewatch gave it a 2 out of 10, but it settles questions about Data's emotions that the films would pick up.
The sons of Soong
Lore explains himself to his prisoners. When Picard sent Hugh home, Hugh's sense of self spread through his ship's Borg, and Lore found them leaderless and promised to make them like himself and Data. Geordi's VISOR has caught a carrier wave running from Lore to Data: Lore is feeding his brother emotions, mostly negative ones, and has switched off his ethical program. When Data voices doubts, Lore withholds the feelings until Data begs for them back.
Riker and Worf are taken to a cave where Hugh and a group of rebel Borg are hiding from Lore's experiments. Picard's reboot device takes hold just as Lore orders Data to kill him to prove his loyalty. Data refuses, Hugh's rebels storm in, and Lore runs. Data catches him, fires in self-defense and deactivates him; Lore's last words are "I love you, brother." Hugh becomes the leader of his Borg.
Data recovers Dr. Soong's emotion chip and plans to destroy it as too dangerous. Geordi talks him into keeping it until he's ready, which sets up Star Trek Generations.
Behind the scenes
- René Echevarria on taking over from Part One: "Part I left many balls in the air and I had to catch them," and "nothing turned out quite as simple as it had seemed."
- Jeri Taylor and Echevarria regretted not developing every plot line, Hugh's especially, as fully as they wanted; the show's late return from hiatus was partly to blame.
- Early drafts ended with an extended phaser battle in which Data shoots Lore. Michael Piller wanted to avoid that, and the quieter shutdown scene replaced it; Reactor's rewatch reads it as a deliberate echo of HAL 9000 in 2001: A Space Odyssey.
- Ensign Taitt was originally Reg Barclay in an early draft, but Dwight Schultz wasn't available.
- Director Alexander Singer on the location shoot in 100-degree heat in Simi Valley: "Those Borg extras were dying! They had to wear black longjohns under those rubber suits!"
The thread
A Borg story that grew out of one act of mercy, and an android learning what his first feelings cost.
Came before
Shares DNA with
Left its mark on
DNA strand
Do Machines Dream?
Data has emotions at last, and this episode asks whether a mind can still choose well when its feelings aren't entirely its own. It's a question the films kept coming back to.
Every great sci-fi story is built from a handful of strands like this one. Each strand page explains how it works and traces it across shows, books and films.
If this one stayed with you
Where to go next, and why.
Watch · TNG S5
"I, Borg" (1992)
If the Borg here made you wonder how they got this way, this is the episode where Picard makes the choice that started it.
Watch · TNG S4
"The Best of Both Worlds: Part Two" (1990)
The other time TNG opened a season by digging itself out of a Borg cliffhanger, and worth watching side by side with this one.
Sources
- “Descent (Star Trek: The Next Generation),” Wikipedia
- “Star Trek: The Next Generation season 7,” Wikipedia
- Keith R.A. DeCandido, “Star Trek: The Next Generation Rewatch: "Descent, Part II",” Reactor (Tor.com)
- Zack Handlen, “Star Trek: The Next Generation: "Descent: Part 2"/"Liaisons",” The A.V. Club, 2011
- “Descent, Part II: Behind the scenes,” TrekCore
- “A Look Back at "Descent",” StarTrek.com
- “2001: A Space Odyssey,” Encyclopaedia Britannica