Star Trek: The Next Generation / Season 4 / Episode 3

Brothers

A sick boy needs a starbase fast, and Data picks that moment to take over the Enterprise, lock out the crew and fly it somewhere nobody ordered.

  • First aired Oct 8, 1990 · Syndication
  • Directed by Rob Bowman
  • Written by Rick Berman
  • Guest starring Cory Danziger and Adam Ryen
Still from Star Trek: The Next Generation, "Brothers"
Still from Star Trek: The Next Generation, "Brothers"
Image via TMDB
Star Trek: The Next Generation, "Brothers" (Syndication, 1990). Image via TMDB.

The story in 5 beats

  1. A prank goes wrong

    On shore leave, Jake Potts plays a trick on his little brother Willie, who runs off and eats a fruit full of parasites.

  2. Data takes the ship

    On the way to Starbase 416, Data clears the bridge, mimics Picard's voice and locks everyone out of command.

  3. The maker

    Data beams down to Terlina III and finds the man who built him, Dr. Noonien Soong, alive.

  4. Two sonsSpoiler · tap to reveal

    Soong has made a gift for Data. Then a second guest answers the same call: Lore.

  5. Brothers forgiveSpoiler · tap to reveal

    Back aboard, Willie recovers, the Potts boys make up, and Data watches them, thinking about his own brother.

Why it still matters

Data's first act here is about as unsettling as he ever gets. Without a word he walks off, shuts down the bridge and takes the ship, impersonating Picard's voice well enough to fool the computer. The first half plays like a heist, with the crew locked out of their own ship and a boy's life running down in sickbay.

Then the episode stops running and sits down for a conversation. Data meets his maker, and the questions he has carried since the first season finally get asked out loud. Michael Piller said he knew "Brent Spiner in three roles was going to make for an unforgettable episode," and Spiner plays Data, his brother Lore and their creator, sometimes all three in one scene.

The A.V. Club gave it a B+, and in 2016 Empire ranked it 19th among the 50 best Star Trek episodes of any series.

Spoilers from here on. What Soong wanted, and who ended up with it.

The gift goes to the wrong son

Soong used an automatic recall built into Data to summon him, and the same signal reached Lore, who was supposed to be in pieces. The Tor.com rewatch notes that a Pakled ship had picked him up after he drifted for two years. Soong is dying, and he has built one last thing: an emotion chip, meant for Data.

While Soong rests, Lore switches Data off, puts on his uniform, and receives the chip in his place. Soong warns that it isn't designed for Lore, and Lore attacks him and beams away. The away team finds Soong dying and Data shut down; Riker knows where the off switch is. Data tells Soong he is sorry he can't grieve for him, and Soong tells him he will grieve in his own way.

The episode ends with the Potts brothers, reconciled. When Data wonders aloud about Lore, Crusher gives him two words: "Brothers forgive."

Behind the scenes

  • Berman's first story had no Lore in it. Piller suggested bringing him back to add jeopardy, calling it "the obvious thing."
  • Laughing Squid's write-up of a video about the shoot says Spiner spent three full days with director Rob Bowman and visual effects coordinator Robert Legato blocking every scene and taping marks on the floor, that Data and Lore were shot on one day and Soong on another, and that Soong's makeup took four hours.
  • This was Rick Berman's first Star Trek writing credit, though he had been with the show from the start. It was also the last Trek episode for Rob Bowman, who had been TNG's most prolific director.
  • Data finally gets the chip back from Lore in "Descent, Part II," and puts it in during Star Trek Generations.

The thread

Data's first family reunion, the old story of a creation facing its maker, and where that chip ended up.

Came before

Shares DNA with

Where the chip went

"Descent, Part II"Star Trek: TNG · 1993 · the chip comes back into the story

DNA strand

Do Machines Dream?

Data has always wanted to be more human, and here he finally gets to ask the man who made him why. Soong answers him the way a father would, so a question about machines ends up as a conversation between a parent and his son.

Every great sci-fi story is built from a handful of strands like this one. Each strand page explains how it works and traces it across shows, books and films.

Also in this strand:"Datalore""The Offspring"Blade RunnerExplore this strand →

If this one stayed with you

Where to go next, and why.

Watch · Star Trek: TNG S1

"Datalore" (1988)

If Lore felt like a stranger, go back to where Data first found him. It sets up every bit of tension in this reunion.

Watch · Film

Blade Runner (1982)

Another story about manufactured people who want answers from their maker, told with a lot more rain.

Read · Novel

Frankenstein by Mary Shelley

The original creature-meets-creator story. Soong is a kinder father than Victor Frankenstein, but the questions are the same ones.

Watch · Star Trek: TNG S3

"The Offspring" (1990)

Data builds a child of his own. After meeting his father, it plays like the other half of the conversation.

Sources