Star Trek: The Next Generation / Season 6 / Episode 22

Suspicions

Dr. Crusher has been relieved of duty and faces a court-martial. Over a visit from Guinan, she explains how championing a Ferengi scientist turned her into a detective.

  • First aired the week of May 10, 1993 · Syndication
  • Directed by Cliff Bole
  • Written by Joe Menosky and Naren Shankar
  • Guest starring Whoopi Goldberg, Peter Slutsker, Tricia O'Neil and James Horan
Still from Star Trek: The Next Generation, "Suspicions"
Still from Star Trek: The Next Generation, "Suspicions"
Image via TMDB
Star Trek: The Next Generation, "Suspicions" (Syndication, 1993). Image via TMDB.

The story in 5 beats

  1. Tennis elbow

    Guinan visits Crusher, who has been relieved of duty and faces a hearing, and Crusher tells her how it happened.

  2. The Ferengi's shield

    Crusher invites Dr. Reyga and four skeptical scientists aboard to test his metaphasic shield, which should let a shuttle survive a star's corona.

  3. Two deaths

    The Takaran pilot Jo'Bril dies after the test, cause unknown. Then Reyga is found dead too. Worf calls it suicide; Crusher doesn't believe it.

  4. Against ordersSpoiler · tap to reveal

    Picard forbids an autopsy out of respect for the Ferengi family. Crusher does one anyway, finds nothing, and is relieved of duty.

  5. Into the starSpoiler · tap to reveal

    Crusher takes the shuttle into the star herself. A stowaway she thought was dead is waiting for her.

Why it still matters

TNG rarely let Beverly Crusher drive an episode, and this one gives her a locked-room mystery with her career on the line. It opens at the end: Guinan turns up at Crusher's quarters claiming tennis elbow, and Crusher admits she's been relieved of duty. The rest is flashback, with Crusher narrating.

The case starts with Dr. Reyga, a Ferengi scientist whose metaphasic shield is supposed to let a ship fly through a star's corona. Nobody at the conference takes him seriously, partly for his unorthodox methods and partly because he's a Ferengi, so Crusher invites him aboard and gathers a panel of skeptics to watch a test. The show first brought in the Ferengi as villains, and Reyga makes a welcome change: earnest, touchy and completely sure of his work.

Critics split on it. Star Trek FAQ 2.0 called it a credible whodunnit and a good vehicle for Gates McFadden; Keith R.A. DeCandido's Reactor rewatch wondered why Crusher, not Data, was the one investigating a physics experiment. Go in for McFadden and Guinan, and for the old-fashioned pleasure of a suspect list.

Spoilers from here on. Who killed Reyga, and what Guinan was really up to.

The corpse who wasn't

Jo'Bril never died. His species can fake death, and while everyone thought he was lying in the morgue, he was free to kill Reyga and dress it up as suicide. Tetryon traces that Ogawa digs out of the autopsy files point to sabotage. When Crusher flies the shuttle into the star alone, the shield works, and Jo'Bril climbs out of hiding. He plans to make it look as if the shuttle was destroyed, then take the shield home and turn it into a weapon. He attacks her, and she kills him with a phaser.

Reyga is vindicated, too late to enjoy it, and Crusher is reinstated without much fuss about the rules she broke on the way. In the closing frame she gives Guinan a replicated tennis racket as thanks, and Guinan admits she has never played tennis: the sore elbow was her excuse to find out what was wrong.

Behind the scenes

  • Joe Menosky and Naren Shankar wrote it, and Cliff Bole directed.
  • Tricia O'Neil, who plays the Klingon scientist Kurak, had played Captain Rachel Garrett in "Yesterday's Enterprise".
  • It was James Horan's first Star Trek role. He came back as Lieutenant Barnaby in "Descent, Part II" and in several later series.
  • The test shuttle is named the Justman, after producer Robert H. Justman.
  • Peter Slutsker's Reyga was the second of his three Ferengi roles on TNG.
  • Reyga's metaphasic shield turns up again in "Descent, Part II".

The thread

Detectives nobody asked for, and Ferengi the show learned to take seriously.

Came before

Murder, She WroteTV series · 1984 · an earlier amateur sleuth who keeps asking questions after the authorities have closed the case

Shares DNA with

Left its mark on

DNA strand

Us vs. Them

Reyga's real obstacle is the room: a conference full of scientists who hear "Ferengi" and stop listening. Crusher is the one person willing to judge the work on its merits, and that gives the mystery its stakes. If the science holds up, the room's dismissal was prejudice all along.

Every great sci-fi story is built from a handful of strands like this one. Each strand page explains how it works and traces it across shows, books and films.

Also in this strand:"The Drumhead""The Last Outpost"Explore this strand →

If this one stayed with you

Where to go next, and why.

Read · Novel

Murder on the Orient Express by Agatha Christie

If the best part was Crusher working through her list of scientists one interview at a time, this is the model: a sealed setting, a handful of suspects and a detective nobody asked for.

Watch · TNG S4

"The Drumhead" (1991)

Another investigation aboard the Enterprise, and a sharper look at what happens when suspicion lands on someone because of who they are.

Watch · TNG S1

"The Last Outpost" (1987)

Where the Ferengi started. Watch it after Reyga to see how far the show had come with them in six years.

Sources