Star Trek: The Next Generation / Season 6 / Episode 26

Descent: Part One

The Borg are back, and something has changed: they use names, they get angry, and they leave their dead behind. In the fight, Data feels his first emotion, and it's rage.

  • First aired the week of June 21, 1993 · Syndication
  • Directed by Alexander Singer
  • Teleplay by Ronald D. Moore, from a story by Jeri Taylor
  • Guest starring Stephen Hawking, John Neville, Jim Norton and Natalija Nogulich
Still from Star Trek: The Next Generation, "Descent: Part One"
Still from Star Trek: The Next Generation, "Descent: Part One"
Image via TMDB
Star Trek: The Next Generation, "Descent: Part One" (Syndication, 1993). Image via TMDB.

The story in 5 beats

  1. Poker with geniuses

    Data's holodeck card game with Newton, Einstein and Stephen Hawking ends in a red alert.

  2. Ohniaka III

    At a Federation outpost, the away team finds everyone dead and Borg who talk like individuals. Data, furious, kills one with his hands.

  3. Nechayev

    Admiral Nechayev takes over the hunt and blames Picard for letting Hugh go. Data tries to make himself angry again on the holodeck.

  4. The prisonerSpoiler · tap to reveal

    A captured Borg, Crosis, works on Data in the brig. Data frees him and they escape in a shuttle through a transwarp conduit.

  5. The sons of SoongSpoiler · tap to reveal

    Searching a planet, Picard's team is surrounded by Borg. Their leader steps forward, and Data stands beside him.

Why it still matters

It opens with the most famous card game in Star Trek. Data has set up a holodeck poker table for Isaac Newton, Albert Einstein and Stephen Hawking, and the real Hawking plays himself, the only time anyone has done that in the franchise. He gets the best line, too. Then a red alert ends the game and the season finale proper begins.

The Borg that attack a remote Federation outpost behave nothing like the hive that took Picard. They fight sloppily, call each other by name and swear revenge, and the crew can't help wondering whether this is what came of letting Hugh go home in "I, Borg". Admiral Nechayev certainly thinks so, and her argument with Picard about principle versus security is one of the sharpest scenes in the episode.

Data carries the episode. In the outpost fight he gets angry, really angry, for the first time, and afterward he admits to Geordi and Troi that he felt something else too. Troi's advice, that no emotion is bad in itself and what counts is what you do with it, is worth hanging on to. Critics were mixed on the episode as a whole (The A.V. Club gave it a B, Reactor's rewatch a 4 out of 10), though the rewatch still praised the poker game and Troi's talk with Data.

Spoilers from here on. Who is leading the Borg, and whose side Data is on.

Lore

Crosis, the captured Borg, triggers something in Data and talks to him about the pleasure of killing. Data takes Crosis, steals a shuttle and disappears through a transwarp conduit. Geordi works out how to open the conduits himself, and the Enterprise follows to a planet whose magnetic field blocks its sensors. Picard sends almost the whole crew down to search on foot, leaving Dr. Crusher in command of a skeleton crew with orders to run if the Borg turn up.

Picard, Troi, Geordi and a security guard find a building where their tricorders don't work. Borg appear by the hundred, the guard is killed, and "the One" the Borg spoke of steps out: Lore, Data's brother. Then Data joins him, and announces that the sons of Soong have come together and will destroy the Federation. The season ends there, "To be continued."

Behind the scenes

  • The writers had planned a "profound" scene for Hawking; executive producer Michael Piller suggested the poker game instead.
  • Stephen Hawking came to the show through a screening of A Brief History of Time where Leonard Nimoy introduced him. Visiting the set, he was invited to sit in the captain's chair, and agreed to appear when asked.
  • Hawking made changes to his scenes, including improving a joke, which Rick Berman called "delightful." Between setups he asked to wait in a closet-sized room so he could think without distractions.
  • Brent Spiner joked, "I still think the guy cost me an Emmy."
  • Ronald D. Moore said the shoot drew a crowd of staff, some inventing work reasons to be there.
  • It's the only TNG episode whose title and opening credits run in the cold open, before the title sequence.
  • Jim Norton's Einstein had appeared once before, as a hologram in "The Nth Degree". John Neville plays Newton.
  • The hillside location was also used in the original series' "This Side of Paradise", and the alien compound is the Brandeis-Bardin Institute, which played Camp Khitomer in Star Trek VI.

The thread

The Borg after Hugh, and an android finding out what anger feels like.

Came before

Shares DNA with

Heart of DarknessJoseph Conrad · novella · 1899 · StarTrek.com likens Jeri Taylor's story to it: a journey upriver to find who's running things

Left its mark on

DNA strand

Do Machines Dream?

Data has wanted feelings for six seasons. When one finally arrives it's anger, followed by pleasure at having killed, and he's frightened of what that says about him. The episode turns his long wish into something he has to fear, and asks what an android should do with feelings he never chose.

Every great sci-fi story is built from a handful of strands like this one. Each strand page explains how it works and traces it across shows, books and films.

Also in this strand:Do Androids Dream of Electric Sheep?"I, Borg"Explore this strand →

If this one stayed with you

Where to go next, and why.

Watch · TNG S5

"I, Borg" (1992)

If you're not sure why Nechayev is so angry with Picard, start here. It's the decision this whole episode turns on.

Read · Novella

Heart of Darkness by Joseph Conrad

A journey into unmapped territory toward a figure everyone talks about and nobody has seen. StarTrek.com compared Jeri Taylor's story to it.

Read · Novel

Do Androids Dream of Electric Sheep? by Philip K. Dick

If Data's frightened talk with Troi about anger was the scene that stuck, Dick spends a whole novel asking what feeling does and doesn't prove about a machine.

Watch · TNG S3

"The Best of Both Worlds: Part One" (1990)

The Borg as they were before Hugh, in the earlier season-ending cliffhanger this one follows.

Sources