
More from the episode
The story in 5 beats
- Three years married
Mike, a welder, and Amanda, a schoolteacher, have been married three years and are trying for a baby.
- The collapse
Amanda collapses at school. The diagnosis is an inoperable brain tumour.
- Rivermind
Gaynor from Rivermind offers a free operation and synthetic brain tissue run on the company's servers, for $300 a month.
Dum DummiesSpoiler · tap to reveal
To pay for upgrades, Mike secretly humiliates himself for cash on a streaming site, masked at first.
Thirty minutes of LuxSpoiler · tap to reveal
A year on, back on the cheapest plan, Amanda uses a short upgrade to ask Mike for one last thing.
Why it still matters
Mike and Amanda are an ordinary couple: he's a welder, she teaches at an elementary school, and they're trying for a baby. When Amanda collapses with an inoperable brain tumour, a startup called Rivermind offers a free operation that replaces the damaged tissue with synthetic tissue run on its servers. The catch is a $300 monthly subscription, and the fine print keeps growing.
After a series six that went off into horror and the supernatural, Brooker opened series seven back in the near future, with technology nobody would call far-fetched. He meant it as a comedy at first, a riff on podcast hosts who stop mid-story to read an ad. Watch Rashida Jones, who co-wrote "Nosedive" years earlier, play a woman who doesn't notice what's coming out of her own mouth, and Chris O'Dowd as a husband who will pay anything rather than lose her.
Critics mostly praised the cast and the ending, though not all of them: Vulture found it jumbled, and Mashable ranked it the second most pessimistic episode the show has made. It earned Emmy nominations for Jones and for Brooker and Ali's writing.
What Amanda asks for
The upgrades never end: the basic tier only works near home, the Plus tier costs another $500 a month, and Rivermind has Amanda reading ads without knowing it. Mike's streams are found by a co-worker, a fight leaves the man badly hurt, and Mike loses his job. When the couple beg Gaynor for more time and mention the baby, she tells them a pregnancy would cost extra.
A year later Amanda is on the Common tier, sleeping about 16 hours a day and spouting ads when she's awake. Mike buys 30 minutes of Lux, which calms her enough to ask him to end her life once she's no longer really there. When the time runs out and she blacks out mid-pitch, he smothers her. Brooker called it "perfectly bleak and perfectly Black Mirror," and said it happens almost as if in her sleep. Then Mike walks into the next room, where Dum Dummies is streaming on his laptop, picks up a box cutter and looks straight at the viewer.
Jones first found the ending mean, then came to see it as an act of love. She thinks Mike goes to join her: the two of them, she said, "couldn't live together, and they couldn't live apart."
Behind the scenes
- Brooker started from the question of what happens if someone needs a subscription service to stay alive. He'd been listening to podcasts whose hosts break off to pitch products, and thought it was going to be a funny one. The deeper he got into the script, the grimmer the conclusion became.
- The story is credited to Brooker and Bisha K. Ali, with the teleplay by Brooker alone. Director Ally Pankiw had made "Joan Is Awful" for series six, and a cinema sign in this episode lists her debut feature, I Used to Be Funny.
- Jones and Tracee Ellis Ross are old friends; Jones had guest-starred as Ross's sister on Black-ish. Both agreed to star before they knew the story, and Ross called Jones her built-in safety partner on the British set.
- Chris O'Dowd had known Brooker since they both worked at Channel 4, 15 to 20 years earlier. He was still surprised by how dark it got.
- The Easter eggs reach across the series. Amanda's school is Cooper Elementary, after Cooper in "Playtest"; she teaches a class about the drone bees from "Hated in the Nation"; and the office across from Gaynor's is Skillane Legal, after Victoria Skillane in "White Bear."
The thread
Black Mirror's earlier ratings and tiers, other stories where the body is bought on credit, and the series that kept the brand names going.
Came before
Shares DNA with
Left its mark on
DNA strand
Technology Outpaces Ethics
The operation works. Everything that goes wrong afterwards is a pricing decision, made by people who never meet Amanda. The episode takes the subscription model everyone already lives with and moves it somewhere you can't cancel it.
Every great sci-fi story is built from a handful of strands like this one. Each strand page explains how it works and traces it across shows, books and films.
If this one stayed with you
Where to go next, and why.
Watch · Film
Repo Men (2010)
If the monthly bill for staying alive was the part that got to you, this is the action-movie version: replacement organs sold on credit, and men who come to collect.
Read · Novel
Super Sad True Love Story (2010)
Gary Shteyngart's near-future love story, where everyone's credit rating is public and the economy is falling apart. Funnier than this, and just as worried.
Watch · Black Mirror
"Fifteen Million Merits" (2011)
Mike's streams have an ancestor: a world where people earn their keep on exercise bikes and the only way out is an audience.
Watch · Black Mirror
"Be Right Back" (2013)
Another couple, another company offering to keep someone with you. It's quieter, and just as hard to shake.


