
More from the episode
The story in 5 beats
- Miso jam
Maria pitches her new miso-jam chocolate bar to a focus group at Ditta. The testers aren't sold.
- The new hire
Verity, an old schoolmate, joins the team and turns the tasting around: the bar, she says, tastes better the second time.
- Nobody remembers
Small things start to shift, down to the name of a chicken shop. Each time, everyone else sides with Verity.
Verity's houseSpoiler · tap to reveal
Fired and desperate, Maria breaks into Verity's home and finds a room full of servers and a set of pendants like the one Verity wears.
Empress of the UniverseSpoiler · tap to reveal
In the struggle that follows, the pendant changes hands, and so does the power to decide what's true.
Why it still matters
Maria develops new products at Ditta, a British food company. Then Verity joins the team. They were at school together, and from the day Verity arrives, small things stop adding up. Maria's memory of the simplest details turns out to be wrong, and her colleagues start giving her the look people give someone who is losing it.
For most of its running time this is a workplace psychological drama with almost no visible technology, which is unusual for Black Mirror. Brooker called it "a gaslighting parable about what happens when your reality is chipped away at," and said the tone is "light and playful, but also claustrophobic and disturbing." Siena Kelly plays Maria naturally and Rosy McEwen makes Verity heightened and hard to read, so for a long time you can't be sure which of them to believe.
Netflix released two versions with one small detail changed, handed out at random. Watch with a friend on another account and compare notes.
What the pendant does
Maria was right. Verity has built a quantum computer in her house, and her pendant is a remote for it. In her words, it "retunes our corporeal frequency to one of the parallel realities where whatever I've said has always been true." Every time Maria was contradicted, Verity had simply moved them all to a world where Maria was wrong. At school, Maria started a rumour that got Verity bullied, and never owned up to it. Verity has already used the device on another classmate, Natalie, who took her own life, and she has been trying to drive Maria to do the same.
When Maria attacks her, Verity summons the police, and Maria shoots her with an officer's gun. She presses Verity's finger to the pendant, takes control, and remakes the world with herself at the top: Empress of the Universe, with kneeling guards and adoring crowds. Brooker called it "kind of a joke ending," and said the first draft had dressed Maria in "almost fascist gear" before the team settled on "a little bit Beyoncé meets Khaleesi."
Brooker isn't fully on either side. Maria "did something thoughtless more than malicious," he said, while Verity is "a tormented villain," in pain like Robert Daly in "USS Callister," "but that isn't justifying what they're doing."
Behind the scenes
- In an earlier draft Verity used a ring, and the episode was called "Ring of Truth." Brooker dropped the title as too on the nose; he likes his titles slightly mysterious. Bête noire is French for a thing you particularly hate.
- Netflix issued two versions of the episode, one with a chicken restaurant called "Bernie's" and one with "Barnie's," and viewers got one at random. Brooker later posted a video holding the cap from the show and refused to say anything more: "Did we change anything? Well I couldn't possibly comment."
- The miso-jam bars were real. Brooker said they had to be vegan because he thought Siena Kelly was, and that a cake-sized one was made for his birthday.
- The plot leans on the Mandela effect, the name for a false memory shared by lots of people, and one scene mentions it by name.
- Ditta's snack shelf is full of callbacks: Raiman almond milk from "USS Callister," Possetts crisps from "Demon 79" and Lacie's Licorice Roll, after Lacie in "Nosedive." A Tuckersoft billboard, from Bandersnatch, is visible outside the office, and a "Gemini Orbits" poster points to "Beyond the Sea."
The thread
Older stories about a person who can rewrite everyone else's reality, and the worlds that kept slipping sideways.
Came before
Shares DNA with
Left its mark on
DNA strand
Is Any of This Real?
Most "is any of this real?" stories put a whole world in question. This one shrinks it to an office and a chicken shop, and the person who's going mad, as far as everyone can tell, is the only one who's right. The sci-fi explanation comes late, so for most of the episode you're as unsure as Maria.
Every great sci-fi story is built from a handful of strands like this one. Each strand page explains how it works and traces it across shows, books and films.
If this one stayed with you
Where to go next, and why.
Read · Novel
The Lathe of Heaven (1971)
If one person secretly editing the world was the part that stuck with you, Le Guin's novel follows a man whose dreams do it, and a psychiatrist who sees how useful that could be.
Watch · TNG S7
"Parallels" (1993)
Worf comes home to find the details of his life don't match what he remembers. It's the same unease, set on a starship.
Watch · Twilight Zone S3
"It's a Good Life" (1961)
A town that has to smile and agree with whatever one person decides, which makes it Verity's distant ancestor.
Watch · Film
Everything Everywhere All at Once (2022)
If the final minutes made you want more reality-hopping, this is the maximal version, with a lot more heart.
Sources
- “Bête Noire (Black Mirror),” Wikipedia
- “Black Mirror 'Bête Noire' Ending Explained: Siena Kelly and Rosy McEwen,” Netflix Tudum
- Joey Nolfi, “Black Mirror creator breaks down 'claustrophobic and disturbing' ending to 'Bête Noire' episode,” Entertainment Weekly (via AOL)
- Jade Biggs, “'Black Mirror' Creator Weighs in on 'Bête Noire' Mystery: Is It Bernie's or Barnie's?,” Cosmopolitan (via AOL)
- Daron James, “'Black Mirror' Creator Charlie Brooker on Remaking Reality,” The Credits (Motion Picture Association)
- Louisa Mellor, “Black Mirror Season 7 Episode 2 Review: Bête Noire,” Den of Geek
- Stephan Lee, “All the 'Black Mirror' Season 7 Easter Eggs,” Netflix Tudum


