
More from the episode
The story in 5 beats
- A bad day at work
Joan fires Sandy, who worked on emissions reduction, on the board's orders. Later she meets up with her ex, Mac.
- Tonight on Streamberry
That night a new Streamberry show, Joan Is Awful, replays her whole day, with Salma Hayek as Joan.
- The small print
The show costs Joan her job. Her lawyer says Streamberry is in the clear: it's all in the terms she agreed to.
Getting Salma's attentionSpoiler · tap to reveal
Joan does something outrageous in a church to provoke Hayek. It works, and the two Joans team up.
The machineSpoiler · tap to reveal
Inside Streamberry they find what makes the show, and learn that breaking it would break a lot more than they thought.
Why it still matters
Joan Tait is a mid-level manager having an ordinary bad day. She fires an employee because the board told her to, and she meets up with her ex. That evening she and her fiancé open Streamberry and find a new show called Joan Is Awful, in which Salma Hayek plays Joan doing everything Joan did that afternoon, only worse. Streamberry is a barely disguised Netflix, down to the menu design and the "tudum" sound, and Brooker said Netflix was supportive from the start.
Brooker called it the only series-six episode that felt like a traditional Black Mirror, though an openly comic one. He wrote Joan for Annie Murphy after watching Schitt's Creek, and Hayek, playing a version of herself, kept asking for wilder lines. It was filmed in September 2022, before ChatGPT came out, and arrived in June 2023 while the writers' strike was on and Hollywood's unions were fighting the studios over AI. Director Ally Pankiw called the timing "spookily timely." Keep an eye on how carefully it sets up the terms and conditions early on.
How deep it goes
The show is made by a quantum computer, using CGI versions of actors and live data from Joan's devices. Hayek can't stop it either: she licensed her likeness. Joan crashes a wedding dressed as a cheerleader, with a penis drawn on her forehead, and relieves herself in the church, because if TV Joan has to do it, Hayek has to be seen doing it. The two break into Streamberry, where CEO Mona Javadi explains the plan: personalized, computer-made shows for every subscriber. Joan was picked for being perfectly average, and the misery keeps people watching.
Then the technician, Beppe, lets slip that they're inside a simulation. The Joan we've been following is herself a generated copy, and Annie Murphy is the actress playing a real Joan one level up. Javadi begs them to leave the computer alone, since destroying it would wipe out the other layers too. Joan realizes the Joan above her has already made the choice, so she does what that Joan does and smashes it.
In the source reality, Source Joan and Annie Murphy end up friends, both under house arrest, and Source Joan opens the coffee shop she'd talked about with her therapist. A happy ending is rare for the show, and critics praised it for that, though one found it a little twee. Stay through the credits for the church scene that started it all.
Behind the scenes
- Brooker and his wife were watching The Dropout (2022), which he said dramatized "things that happened ten minutes ago," and joked about a prestige drama based on their own lives. Early ideas included Joan landing in newspaper headlines over petty complaints, and news networks using deepfakes of politicians.
- He wrote Joan with Annie Murphy in mind, describing her as "likeable yet relatable, goofy, and flawed." Murphy wanted to do it before she'd read the script.
- Brooker wrote Hayek's lines on the tame side so as not to scare her off. She pushed for more outrageous ones and suggested real facts about herself, which is how her dyslexia and her Catholicism got into the script.
- It was filmed in September 2022. Joan's American-style house is a bungalow in Crowthorne, England; a crew of about 70 repainted it, added rock gardens and put American postboxes on the neighbors' houses.
- The Streamberry office is dressed in white, black and red to echo Netflix's logo. For the launch, Netflix's social accounts briefly renamed themselves Streamberry, and youareawful.com let fans make their own Is Awful thumbnails.
- The song playing when Joan meets Mac is Irma Thomas's "Anyone Who Knows What Love Is (Will Understand)," its sixth appearance in the series.
- Brooker counted about 42 speaking parts and called the casting a "logistical nightmare." Pankiw said Catherine Lutes was the first female cinematographer in Black Mirror's history.
The thread
Where Joan's nightmare came from, who else has had their life turned into a show, and where Streamberry went next.
Came before
Shares DNA with
Left its mark on
DNA strand
Technology Outpaces Ethics
Nobody hacks Joan. She clicked accept, like the rest of us, and most of the laughs and the sting come from how little anyone can do about it afterward. Streamberry's machine is legal, its lawyers are calm about it, and meanwhile the show is a hit.
Every great sci-fi story is built from a handful of strands like this one. Each strand page explains how it works and traces it across shows, books and films.
If this one stayed with you
Where to go next, and why.
Watch · Film
The Truman Show (1998)
A man whose life has been a TV show all along, slowly noticing the seams. Gentler than Joan's ordeal, with the same itch about being watched for someone else's entertainment.
Watch · Black Mirror S3
"Nosedive" (2016)
Another woman whose every move is judged by an audience, and another Black Mirror that plays the nightmare mostly for laughs.
Watch · Black Mirror S6
"Loch Henry" (2023)
The next Streamberry production, seen from the audience's side: this time the show is built on someone else's worst moments, and everyone wants to watch.
Read · Novel
Nineteen Eighty-Four (1949)
The classic novel of a system that sees everything you do. If Streamberry's data harvesting got to you, this is the fear in its best-known form.
Sources
- “Joan Is Awful,” Wikipedia
- “'Black Mirror' Behind the Scenes of 'Joan Is Awful',” Netflix Tudum
- “All of the 'Black Mirror' Season 6 Easter Eggs and References,” Netflix Tudum
- “All the 'Black Mirror' Season 7 Easter Eggs,” Netflix Tudum
- “Annie Murphy and 'Black Mirror' Director on 'Joan Is Awful's' Feminist Themes and 'Spookily Timely' AI Story,” Yahoo News


