Black Mirror / Series 4 / Episode 6

Black Museum

A traveler waits out a car charge at a roadside museum of crimes. The owner is happy to tell her where every exhibit came from, and to save the best for last.

  • Released Dec 29, 2017 · Netflix
  • Directed by Colm McCarthy
  • Written by Charlie Brooker, first story from Penn Jillette
  • Starring Letitia Wright and Douglas Hodge
Still from Black Mirror, "Black Museum"
Still from Black Mirror, "Black Museum"
Image via TMDB · 1 of 4
Black Mirror, "Black Museum" (Netflix, 2017). Image via TMDB.

More from the episode

The story in 5 beats

  1. The museum

    Nish stops at a remote museum while her car charges. The owner, Rolo, offers her the tour.

  2. The doctor

    A doctor gets an implant that lets him feel his patients' symptoms. He starts to enjoy the wrong ones.

  3. Carrie

    A husband agrees to carry his comatose wife's consciousness in his own head. Neither of them is happy for long.

  4. The main exhibitSpoiler · tap to reveal

    A hologram of a man from death row. Pull the lever and he feels it.

  5. SouvenirSpoiler · tap to reveal

    Nish has her own reason for coming, and her own souvenir to take home.

Why it still matters

It's built like "White Christmas": three nasty little stories told by a man who seems to enjoy telling them. Rolo Haynes runs a dusty museum in the desert, and every exhibit is a piece of technology he helped launch and a person it ruined. A doctor who can feel his patients' pain. A husband carrying his comatose wife's mind in his head. And the main attraction, a death-row prisoner turned into a hologram you can electrocute for a fee.

Brooker called it an episode about punishment and racism, in the vein of "White Bear," with the gleeful tone of Tales from the Crypt. Critics were split; Variety called it the series' worst and The Independent called it very strong. But it's the episode that finally confirmed every Black Mirror story lives in one world, and Letitia Wright's turn as Nish earned an Emmy nomination.

Spoilers from here on. The frame story has a twist, and it's the reason she stopped.

Why Nish came

Clayton Leigh signed his consciousness over to Rolo from death row. As a hologram he was electrocuted over and over by paying visitors, each of whom took home a souvenir copy of him in agony. After protests, only sadists and white supremacists kept coming, until there was nothing left of him but pain. His wife saw what had become of him and died of an overdose the next day.

Nish is their daughter. She has poisoned Rolo's water and sabotaged the air conditioning, and as he struggles to breathe she moves his consciousness into Clayton's hologram, pulls the lever and takes the souvenir. Then she frees Carrie from the toy monkey Rolo left her trapped in, burns the museum down and drives away, with her mother's consciousness riding along in her head, the way Carrie once rode in Jack's.

The Question Underneath

What does it say about us that people will pay to watch suffering?

Every exhibit in Rolo's museum rests on the same excuse: it's only a copy, so it doesn't really count. The episode keeps showing what that excuse lets people do, from a doctor addicted to pain to a prisoner tortured for tourists. By the end the story turns the excuse back on Rolo himself. If copies can suffer, then everything he sold was cruelty with a receipt, and the souvenirs are evidence.

Challenge the DNA

Is Nish's revenge justice?

Is Nish's revenge justice?
Or skip ahead to our reading

It's justice by the museum's own rules, which is the problem. Nish ends up carrying a souvenir of suffering, just like the customers she despises.

Behind the scenes

  • The first story is Penn Jillette's "The Pain Addict," published in a 1988 anthology and drawn from his time ill in a Spanish hospital in 1981, where a language barrier made diagnosis hard. He told Brooker about it before series three; two years later Brooker asked to use it.
  • Jillette also helped shape Rolo as a washed-up Las Vegas carny, partly inspired by Penn & Teller's own work. He wanted to audition for the part, but casting was too far along.
  • Brooker had earlier ideas about a digital prisoner electrocuted again and again, and an ex-partner living in someone's head. Both made it in.
  • Letitia Wright sent a self-tape with Daniel Kaluuya reading the other parts; they'd just worked together on Black Panther. She filmed this straight after.
  • It was shot in about a month in Spain and Nevada. Douglas Hodge called Rolo the most toxic person he'd ever played and kept his distance from Wright on set.
  • Director Colm McCarthy said the museum contains a reference to every earlier episode, many placed by set designer Joel Collins.

The thread

The special it echoes, the story it adapts, and the shared world it confirmed.

Came before

"The Pain Addict"Penn Jillette · short story · 1988 · the doctor's story
Tales from the CryptHBO · TV series · 1989 · the tone Brooker was after

Shares DNA with

Left its mark on

The shared Black Mirror worldthe museum's exhibits tied every episode into one storyworld

DNA strand

Technology Outpaces Ethics

Every exhibit is a device that worked exactly as designed. What failed was everyone deciding a copy of a person was a product, and the episode makes you watch where that ends up.

Every great sci-fi story is built from a handful of strands like this one. Each strand page explains how it works and traces it across shows, books and films.

Also in this strand:"White Christmas""USS Callister"Explore this strand →

If this one stayed with you

Where to go next, and why.

Watch · Black Mirror

"White Christmas"

The blueprint: three stories, one storyteller and a frame with its own twist. Darker, and tighter.

Watch · TV

Tales from the Crypt

The gleefully grisly anthology Brooker was channeling. Pick any episode.

Watch · Black Mirror

"USS Callister"

Digital copies of real people again, this time with a way out.

Your next episode

Three directions to go from here, all on Sci-Fi DNA.

Still from Black Mirror, "White Christmas"

More of this feeling

White Christmas

Black Mirror

The same three-stories-and-a-storyteller shape, colder and tighter.

Still from Black Mirror, "USS Callister"

Same question, different answer

USS Callister

Black Mirror

Digital copies of real people again, this time with a way out.

Sources