
More from the episode
The story in 5 beats
- Twenty-five years
Barbara has lived with her cruel uncle Simon for decades, waiting to inherit. He mocks her and bars her from his lab.
- The stairs
She sneaks down to the lab. He raises his cane, she blocks it, and he falls down the basement stairs.
- The will
Simon dies, and his lawyer Mr. Schwimmer reads the will. To inherit, Barbara must live in the house and care for his last invention.
The robotSpoiler · tap to reveal
The invention is a robot. It starts out clumsy and mechanical, and it learns.
Hot chocolateSpoiler · tap to reveal
It picks up Simon's voice, his insults and, after she damages it, his limp. Barbara brings it cocoa and calls it Uncle.
Why it still matters
Barbara Polk has spent a quarter of a century waiting on her uncle Simon, an inventor who insults her for sport and keeps his basement lab locked. She stays because she's his only heir. They loathe each other in a way that's almost cozy, two people who have had the same fight every evening for years. Sir Cedric Hardwicke, a theater-trained English actor with a Tony and a knighthood, plays Simon with relish. It was his only Twilight Zone, and he died less than a year after it aired.
The A.V. Club's Emily St. James called it spectacularly strange and spectacularly unpleasant, and she thought the problem was Barbara, who is hard to root for. That's also what makes it worth a look: a Serling story with no one to like, directed by Don Siegel, the man who made Invasion of the Body Snatchers and later Dirty Harry. The Twilight Zone Vortex notes that Siegel shoots the study and the basement stairs in matching ways, so the house keeps rhyming with itself.
That's Robby the Robot, by the way. The Forbidden Planet star turns up in the Polk basement with a new, plainer head.
Simon's last invention
The robot named Simon begins as a stiff, plainly mechanical thing. Over the weeks it learns. It copies the old man's manners and his voice, and repeats his insults. When Barbara tries to destroy it, the damage leaves it with Simon's limp and a cane. Schwimmer's regular visits make sure she can't simply walk away from the arrangement, and in the last scene she's bringing it a mug of hot chocolate and calling it "Uncle."
The cruel old man gets the last word by building a successor that will go on bullying her for as long as she wants the money. Serling's closing narration hands the house over to a metal man who'll go by the name of Simon. It's a nasty little joke about inheritance, since what Barbara really inherited was the relationship. St. James thought the story might have worked better at the previous season's hour length, with more room to make Barbara someone we care about.
Behind the scenes
- The robot is Robby, built for MGM's Forbidden Planet (1956). For this episode its head was simplified: a plain cylinder replaced the famous dome, and the mouth lights and ear tubes came off. Dion Hansen was inside, and Vic Perrin, the Control Voice of The Outer Limits, provided the voice.
- Robby also appears in "One for the Angels" and "The Brain Center at Whipple's."
- It was the first of Don Siegel's two Twilight Zone episodes; the other is "The Self-Improvement of Salvadore Ross." Siegel had directed Hardwicke before, in Baby Face Nelson (1957).
- Constance Ford, who plays Barbara, had been in Serling's Emmy-winning Playhouse 90 drama "The Comedian." She later played Ada Hobson on the soap Another World from 1967 to 1992.
- A scene with a police officer, played by John McLiam, was cut from the finished episode.
- It aired a week before the Kennedy assassination. The following week's planned episode, "Night Call," was pulled and didn't air until February 1964.
The thread
Bad uncles, faithful machines and the robot who kept getting cast.
Came before
Shares DNA with
Left its mark on
DNA strand
Do Machines Dream?
This robot studies instead of dreaming. Everything it becomes, it learns from watching how Simon treated Barbara, and it learns it perfectly. It's an early, sour take on a machine trained on one person's behavior, where the bad habits are what carry over.
Every great sci-fi story is built from a handful of strands like this one. Each strand page explains how it works and traces it across shows, books and films.
If this one stayed with you
Where to go next, and why.
Watch · Film
Forbidden Planet (1956)
See Robby in his original role, with the full dome head, a very different robot from the one in the Polk basement.
Watch · Black Mirror
"Be Right Back"
A machine that learns to talk like someone who's gone, and a woman who can't decide what to do with it: the grieving version of Barbara's problem.
Read · Short story
"The Monkey's Paw" by W. W. Jacobs
If you enjoyed watching an inheritance turn into a punishment, this is the classic story of getting exactly the money you wanted.
Watch · Twilight Zone S1
"The Lonely"
The opposite of Barbara's arrangement: a man alone on an asteroid who is sent a machine and ends up caring for it.
Sources
- “Uncle Simon,” Wikipedia
- “The Twilight Zone (1959 TV series) season 5,” Wikipedia
- Emily St. James, “The Twilight Zone: "The Old Man In The Cave"/"Uncle Simon",” The A.V. Club, 2014
- Brian Durant, “Uncle Simon,” The Twilight Zone Vortex, 2024
- “The Twilight Zone: Season 5, Episode Eight, Uncle Simon,” Great Books Guy
- “Probe 7, Over and Out,” Wikipedia
