
The story in 5 beats
- The last asylum
The Enterprise delivers a medicine meant to end mental illness to Elba II. Kirk and Spock beam down through the asylum's force field to meet the governor.
- An old hero
Among the inmates is Garth of Izar, once a celebrated starship captain whose exploits were required reading when Kirk was a cadet.
- Anyone he likes
Garth has learned to change his shape. He's running the place, the inmates are loose, and he wants Kirk's ship.
The passwordSpoiler · tap to reveal
Garth needs Kirk's countersign to take the ship. He tries the torture chair first, then a cleverer trick.
Two KirksSpoiler · tap to reveal
Garth kills Marta, then turns himself into Kirk. Spock has to work out which captain is the real one.
Why it still matters
The setup is pure third-season Trek: the Federation has nearly cured mental illness, and Elba II, an asylum planet with a poisonous atmosphere, holds the last fifteen patients who need the new medicine. Kirk and Spock beam down with it. Waiting for them is Garth of Izar, a former starship captain whose campaigns Kirk studied at the Academy, and who can now take on anyone's shape.
Steve Ihnat plays Garth's madness as intelligent and mostly controlled, which is what Keith R.A. DeCandido's rewatch for Reactor likes best about him. He also gets a cape that keeps falling off and boots that don't match (one silver, one gold). Yvonne Craig, TV's Batgirl, is Marta, an Orion inmate who dances and recites poetry she says she wrote herself. The plot runs on rails, and it's fun to watch anyway.
Fans have kept Garth's story going. His past, especially the Battle of Axanar, has been filled in by novels, a role-playing game and the fan film Axanar, all built out of a few lines of dialogue.
The emperor of Elba II
The man who greets Kirk as Governor Cory is Garth, wearing Cory's face; the real governor is locked in a cell. After Garth was badly injured on Antos, its people taught him how to change his own cells, and he repaid them by ordering his crew to destroy their planet when they wouldn't join his conquest. Now he has destroyed the medicine and wants the Enterprise as his first step to ruling the galaxy.
Every move is aimed at Kirk's countersign. When torture fails, Garth stages a rescue, gives Kirk a phaser that doesn't work and poses as Spock long enough to hear the answer. He crowns himself, names Marta his consort and then kills her with an explosive necklace. After the two Kirks trade punches, Spock sorts out which one is real, a medical team and security detail beam down, and McCoy gives the new medicine to the surviving inmates. Garth comes round seeming to remember none of it.
Behind the scenes
- Leonard Nimoy sent a memo to producers Fred Freiberger and Douglas Cramer complaining that everyone was out of character and that the story repeated "Dagger of the Mind."
- The original script had Spock telling the two Kirks apart by asking questions, and James Blish's adaptation kept that version. Director Herb Wallerstein changed it to a fight for more action.
- Steve Ihnat was three years younger than William Shatner, so the production silvered his hair to make him look like the older officer.
- Yvonne Craig had played Batgirl on the 1960s Batman, and she was reportedly considered for Vina, the part that went to Susan Oliver in the pilot.
- Garth's torture device is a modified version of the rehabilitation chair from "Dagger of the Mind."
- Marta claims two famous poems as her own work: Shakespeare's Sonnet 18 and, later, one by A. E. Housman.
- TrekMovie's review of the remastered version says the episode was kept off British television for years because of its torture scenes.
The thread
An asylum story from inside Starfleet's own family, and a villain fans have been writing about ever since.
Came before
Shares DNA with
Garth's afterlife
DNA strand
Alternate Selves
Garth can become anyone, and the whole episode is a game of which face to trust: the governor, the captain, the first officer. It works best when the impostor is in the room with the real thing and the crew has to decide on very little evidence.
Every great sci-fi story is built from a handful of strands like this one. Each strand page explains how it works and traces it across shows, books and films.
If this one stayed with you
Where to go next, and why.
Watch · Star Trek
"Dagger of the Mind"
If the asylum and the chair felt familiar, this is where they came from. The first-season version plays the same idea as a slow-burning mystery.
Watch · Star Trek
"The Enemy Within"
Two Kirks again, but this time both of them are really him. Shatner gets more to play, and the episode asks a sharper question about what makes a captain.
Watch · Fan film
Axanar
If Garth's war stories made you want the battle itself, fans went and made it.
Read · Poem
Sonnet 18, by William Shakespeare
Marta claims it as her own. Here's the real thing, which holds up rather better than the asylum dinner party.