
The story in 5 beats
- A royal passenger
The Enterprise collects Ambassador Petri of Troyius, then Elaan of Elas, whose arranged marriage is meant to end the war between their planets.
- Lessons in manners
Elaan stabs Petri when he tries to teach her Troyian customs. Kirk takes over the lessons, and she tries to stab him too.
- A shadow
A Klingon warship shadows the Enterprise and ignores every hail.
TearsSpoiler · tap to reveal
Elaan breaks down crying. Kirk wipes a tear from her cheek, and suddenly he can't stop thinking about her.
SabotageSpoiler · tap to reveal
One of Elaan's guards kills an engineer and wrecks the warp drive. With the Klingons attacking, the ship can't fire or run.
Why it still matters
The idea is right there in the title: Helen of Troy by way of The Taming of the Shrew, set on a starship. France Nuyen plays Elaan, the Dohlman of Elas, a ruler sent off to marry the king of Troyius to end a war between their two worlds, and she wants no part of it. Kirk ends up as her tutor in manners, which goes about as well as you'd expect.
John Meredyth Lucas both wrote and directed it, the only time one person has done both jobs on a Star Trek episode. It also introduced the Klingon battle cruiser designed by Matt Jefferies, and the show kept reusing that footage.
Reviews split hard. The A.V. Club gave it a B for its space battle and a restrained Shatner. Keith R.A. DeCandido at Reactor called it "wrongheaded drivel" that wastes Nuyen, and scholars still argue over whether Elaan is a satire of a stereotype or simply one. Watch it with that argument in mind, and for Nuyen, who has more presence than the script gives her room for.
The crystals around her neck
An Elasian woman's tears bind any man who touches them to her, and Kirk, having wiped one away, is in love with the Dohlman he's supposed to deliver to someone else. The sabotage was the work of Kryton, Elaan's bodyguard, who loved her himself and couldn't stand the marriage. He kills himself before he can be questioned, and his damage to the dilithium crystals leaves the ship without warp drive or weapons just as the Klingons attack in earnest.
The answer is around Elaan's neck. Petri has persuaded her to wear a Troyian royal necklace as a sign of peace, and Spock notices that its ordinary stones are dilithium crystals, which is why the Klingons care about this little war at all. Scott and Spock install them, power comes back just in time, and the Klingons are driven off. Elaan, changed, gives Kirk her dagger before she leaves, since on Troyius "they do not wear such things." McCoy has found an antidote for the tears, but Kirk doesn't need it: as Spock puts it, the Enterprise infected the captain long before the Dohlman did.
Behind the scenes
- It's the only Star Trek episode written and directed by the same person, John Meredyth Lucas.
- The story went through several hands. Alfred Brenner pitched "Journey to Reolite" in April 1966, Gene Roddenberry outlined "Helen of Troyius" that December, and Lucas wrote a new outline in March 1968, which Fred Freiberger revised and retitled.
- France Nuyen is believed to be the first Vietnamese actress on American television. She had starred opposite William Shatner on Broadway in The World of Suzie Wong, and the two later played a married couple in the Kung Fu episode "A Small Beheading."
- The episode introduced Matt Jefferies' Klingon battle cruiser, and its footage was reused later in the season.
- It was the last original-run appearance of Eddie Paskey as Lt. Leslie.
The thread
Helen of Troy, Shakespeare's shrew, and a royal bride who keeps coming back to Trek.
Came before
Shares DNA with
Left its mark on
DNA strand
Love Beyond Limits
Kirk falls for a woman he's duty-bound to hand over to another man, and the reason is chemistry in the most literal sense. Taken one way it's a romance about duty winning. Taken another, it's a story about a woman tamed by a kiss, which is why people still argue about it.
Every great sci-fi story is built from a handful of strands like this one. Each strand page explains how it works and traces it across shows, books and films.
If this one stayed with you
Where to go next, and why.
Read · Play
The Taming of the Shrew by William Shakespeare
The play the episode borrows its shape from. Seeing the original makes it easier to decide what you think Lucas did with it.
Watch · Star Trek S2
"Journey to Babel" (1967)
If the cloak-and-dagger diplomacy was the fun part, this is the original series' best version of a ship full of dignitaries and one killer.
Watch · Star Trek: TNG S6
"Relics" (1992)
Scotty, decades later, telling stories from the old days, this one included.
Watch · Star Trek S2
"Friday's Child" (1967)
More Klingon interference in a planet's affairs, and another guest star who refuses to be anybody's pawn.