
More from the episode
The story in 5 beats
- A stowaway
A man stows away from Tantalus V, attacks a crewman and storms the bridge asking for asylum. Spock subdues him.
- The model colony
Dr. Adams says his assistant, van Gelder, hurt himself in an experiment. Kirk and Dr. Noel beam down and find a staff that seems strangely flat.
- The first meld
Spock joins his mind to van Gelder's to reach past the pain. The truth comes out in pieces: the machine empties minds.
In the chairSpoiler · tap to reveal
Kirk tests the neural neutralizer on himself. Adams takes over the controls, turns it up and fills Kirk's head with whatever he likes.
Lights outSpoiler · tap to reveal
Noel crawls through the vents and cuts the power. In the fight that follows, Adams is left alone in his own machine.
Why it still matters
The Enterprise drops off supplies at Tantalus V, a penal colony run by Dr. Tristan Adams, a celebrated reformer who has made the treatment of the criminally insane humane at last. Then a stowaway turns up on board: Simon van Gelder, wild-eyed, begging for asylum, and insisting he is not a patient. He turns out to be Adams's own assistant. Adams says the man hurt himself testing a new machine, McCoy doesn't buy it, and Kirk beams down with Dr. Helen Noel, a ship's psychiatrist, to look around.
This is the episode that introduced the Vulcan mind meld. Leonard Nimoy pushed for it, and the scene where Spock reaches into van Gelder's head, the two men speaking in fragments, is the best thing in the hour. The episode is also a sharp little nightmare about a machine that can empty a mind and put something else in, sold to the public as therapy. Morgan Woodward's van Gelder is the performance people remember: sweating, shaking and trying to get a sentence out before the pain stops him.
The romance between Kirk and Noel is the weakest part and hasn't aged well. The meld, and the scenes in the neutralizer's booth, more than make up for it.
The loneliest room in the galaxy
The neural neutralizer doesn't calm anyone. It wipes the mind blank and leaves a person open to suggestion, and Adams has used it on patients and staff alike to keep the colony running his way. What it leaves behind, the meld reveals, is a loneliness so total it's almost unbearable. When Kirk tries it with Noel at the controls, she plants a harmless thought as a test. Then Adams takes over, cranks the power, and convinces Kirk he has been in love with Noel for a long time.
Noel gets through the ventilation ducts and kills the power. Kirk overpowers Adams, Spock beams down and drops the force field, and when the power comes back the neutralizer is still running with Adams in front of it. With no one at the controls, it empties him, and he dies. Back aboard, van Gelder has destroyed the machine. McCoy finds it hard to believe a man could die of loneliness; Kirk, who sat in that room, believes it.
Behind the scenes
- Shimon Wincelberg wrote the episode but asked to be credited as S. Bar-David.
- The mind meld was born here. The script called for alien hypnosis; Leonard Nimoy's insistence helped make it a Vulcan technique instead. Sixteen years later, a meld helped set up the ending of Star Trek II: The Wrath of Khan.
- Dr. Helen Noel's part was first written for Grace Lee Whitney's Yeoman Rand. The producers made her a psychologist instead so that Kirk wouldn't get too involved with a member of his own crew.
- The title comes from Macbeth's soliloquy about a dagger that turns out to be a hallucination. A Columbo episode later used the same title.
The thread
Asylums that cure by erasing, and the long life of one Vulcan trick.
Came before
Shares DNA with
Left its mark on
DNA strand
Technology Outpaces Ethics
Adams built a machine that could have been a real kindness for violent, suffering patients, and he used it to make everyone around him agree with him. The episode puts the danger in the man with his hand on the dial, and in the fact that nobody outside thought to check.
Every great sci-fi story is built from a handful of strands like this one. Each strand page explains how it works and traces it across shows, books and films.
If this one stayed with you
Where to go next, and why.
Watch · Black Mirror
"White Bear"
If the neutralizer scenes got to you, this is the modern version: a woman wakes with no memory in a world that seems to know exactly who she is, while a lot of people watch.
Watch · Film
Eternal Sunshine of the Spotless Mind (2004)
A gentler, sadder machine that edits what you remember, and a story about what's left of you when it's done.
Read · Novel
One Flew Over the Cuckoo's Nest — Ken Kesey
The same fight between a patient and the people running the ward, told from inside, without a starship to come to the rescue.

