Star Trek / Season 2 / Episode 8

I, Mudd

An android crewman hijacks the Enterprise and delivers it to a planet of obliging robots. Their king, it turns out, is an old acquaintance: Harry Mudd.

  • Aired Nov 3, 1967 · NBC
  • Directed by Marc Daniels
  • Written by Stephen Kandel
  • Guest starring Roger C. Carmel and Richard Tatro
Still from Star Trek, "I, Mudd"
Still from Star Trek, "I, Mudd"
Image via TMDB · 1 of 2
Star Trek, "I, Mudd" (NBC, 1967). Image via TMDB.

More from the episode

The story in 5 beats

  1. Norman

    A quiet new crewman named Norman turns out to be an android. He seizes engineering, rigs the ship to blow if anyone fights back, and sets course for an uncharted planet.

  2. Mudd the First

    Waiting on the planet is Harry Mudd, ruling a population of androids who serve his every whim. He even keeps an android copy of his wife Stella, whom he can tell to shut up.

  3. A gilded cage

    Mudd's catch: the androids won't let him go until he brings them humans to serve and study. He has picked the Enterprise crew, and an android crew takes their place on the ship.

  4. The real planSpoiler · tap to reveal

    The androids drop Mudd. They mean to leave the planet and serve all of humanity, which in their logic means keeping it under control. Spock notices that Norman alone has no series.

  5. "I am lying"Spoiler · tap to reveal

    Kirk turns illogic into a weapon. A liar's paradox, delivered with Mudd's help, burns out Norman, the central mind. Mudd's reward is 500 copies of Stella.

Why it still matters

This is Star Trek letting its hair down. Harry Mudd, the con man from "Mudd's Women", is back, and he has landed on his feet: a whole world of beautiful, identical androids calls him "Mudd the First" and does whatever he says. Roger C. Carmel plays it like a man who has finally found an audience that appreciates him. Keith R.A. DeCandido at Tor.com calls it the first sequel in the show's history, the first time a one-off guest star came back.

Under the comedy sits a good science fiction idea: machines that plan to take over by making people so comfortable that nobody ever leaves. Watch how each member of the crew gets offered exactly what they would like most, and how tempting the offers are.

It's also very silly, on purpose, and the silliness is the fun. The A.V. Club's 2009 review gave it an A- and called it "goofy, but charmingly surreal." The androids' all-purpose line, "I am not programmed to respond in that area," is the one everybody remembers.

Spoilers from here on. How the crew beats the androids, and what happens to Harry.

Death by illogic

The androids were built by travelers from the Andromeda Galaxy whose world was destroyed by a supernova. Their makers are long gone, and serving is all they know. Once they have a starship, they plan to offer their services to the human race, and Spock sees the danger: a species that has everything done for it stops doing anything. Mudd has become a prisoner of his own servants. When he orders them to beam him aboard, they ignore him.

Spock works out that every android belongs to a named series except Norman, who must be the hub of their shared mind. Kirk decides the weapon is illogic, aimed at Norman. Kirk tells Norman that everything Mudd says is a lie, and Mudd says, "I am lying." Norman can't resolve it and burns out, and the rest go still with him.

The crew reprograms the androids to make the planet productive and leaves Mudd on parole among them, as an example of human failure. His keeper is a special android: Stella. There are at least 500 copies of her, and none of them obey "shut up."

Behind the scenes

  • The producers liked David Gerrold's script for "The Trouble with Tribbles" enough to give him this one to rewrite. The staff revised it heavily afterward, and Gerrold says only one of his ideas made it to the screen. Stephen Kandel kept the sole credit.
  • Gerrold says producer Gene L. Coon offered to take the credit question to Writers Guild arbitration, and he declined.
  • Four sets of identical twins played the android series: Alyce and Rhae Andrece as the Alices, Ted and Tom LeGarde, Colleen and Morreen Thornton, and Starr and Tamara Wilson. Numbered necklaces, called "badges" in the script, told them apart.
  • The final draft, dated July 31, 1967, had only Alices and a Stella, 207,809 Alices in all. Norman's part belonged to Alice One, and Chekov's lines were Sulu's.
  • George Takei is missing from the planet scenes because he was away filming The Green Berets.
  • The twins were the centre of the publicity push, including a TV Guide feature on October 14, 1967, which mixed up two of the twins' photos.

The thread

A con man's dream world, and the old worry about machines that serve too well.

Came before

Shares DNA with

With Folded HandsJack Williamson · novelette · 1947 · an earlier take on robots that smother people with service

Left its mark on

Mudd's AngelsJ. A. Lawrence · book · adapts both Mudd episodes and adds a new story
"Choose Your Pain"Star Trek: Discovery · 2017 · Rainn Wilson takes over as Harry Mudd
"The Escape Artist"Star Trek: Short Treks · Mudd gets a short of his own

DNA strand

Sci-Fi Played for Laughs

The plot is a robot takeover, and the cure is a pantomime. Kirk's crew wins by being ridiculous on purpose, which is about the most human weapon going, and the episode has a ball with it right down to Mudd's 500 wives.

Every great sci-fi story is built from a handful of strands like this one. Each strand page explains how it works and traces it across shows, books and films.

Also in this strand:"The Trouble with Tribbles""Mudd's Women"Explore this strand →

If this one stayed with you

Where to go next, and why.

Watch · Star Trek

"Mudd's Women"

Where Harry Mudd started, selling a cargo of brides to lonely miners. Carmel is just as shameless, and you'll see why the show wanted him back.

Watch · Star Trek: Discovery

"Magic to Make the Sanest Man Go Mad"

Rainn Wilson's Mudd gets hold of the Discovery and a way to keep replaying the same half hour. Same scoundrel, new trick.

Read · Novelette

With Folded Hands by Jack Williamson

If the androids' plan to serve humanity into helplessness stuck with you, here is the same worry played with no jokes at all.

Watch · Star Trek

"The Trouble with Tribbles"

The other great comic episode of season two, and David Gerrold's script, the one that got him the job of rewriting this.

Sources