
The story in 5 beats
- The Defiant
The Enterprise finds the missing USS Defiant adrift. Kirk, Spock, McCoy and Chekov beam over in environment suits and find a dead crew who killed one another.
- Fading away
The Defiant is slipping out of the universe. The transporter can't bring everyone back at once, and Kirk is left aboard as the ship vanishes.
- Interphase
Spock works out that two universes overlap here at intervals and refuses to leave. Then Commander Loskene's Tholian ship arrives, claiming the space as theirs.
The webSpoiler · tap to reveal
After a fight, two Tholian ships begin spinning an energy web around the crippled Enterprise. The crew start to see Kirk, ghostly, on the ship.
The tapeSpoiler · tap to reveal
Spock and McCoy play the message Kirk left in case he died. It tells them to work together.
Why it still matters
For a lot of fans this is the one they remember from season 3, and the image is the reason: a glowing net being spun around the Enterprise, strand by strand, by aliens who never set foot on the ship. Keith R.A. DeCandido, rewatching it for Reactor, admits it was a childhood favourite and still rates it a 6, good by the standards of the final season. The Television Academy took it seriously too: it was nominated for an Emmy for art direction and scenic design.
Most of the hour is about the crew coping with Kirk gone. Spock takes command, McCoy needles him at every turn, and the ship sits in a region of space where the walls between universes are wearing thin. The A.V. Club's Zack Handlen gave it a B+ and liked that it's honest science fiction, with no godlike beings in sight.
It left more behind than you'd expect. The Tholians turned up again in later series, the derelict USS Defiant got its own sequel decades later, and a law professor once cited Kirk's recorded message to his officers as an early example of a video will.
Saved by a schedule
Kirk isn't dead. He's caught in the interphase, drifting between universes in his environment suit with his air running out, and he flickers into view on the Enterprise at intervals. Uhura and Scotty see him first, and eventually he appears on the bridge. Meanwhile the space around the Defiant has been driving the crew to violence, which is why Chekov lashed out early on, and McCoy develops an antidote.
With the web nearly closed, Spock calculates when and where Kirk will next appear. The Enterprise locks onto him, uses its engines to ride through the rift and out of the trap, and Kirk is beamed aboard just as his oxygen gives out. Afterwards he asks Spock and McCoy whether they watched his last orders. McCoy says there wasn't time, Spock backs him up, and Kirk lets it go. It's a small, kind lie, and the best scene in the episode.
Behind the scenes
- Ralph Senensky started directing and was fired partway through for going over schedule. Herb Wallerstein finished the job and got the screen credit. Senensky has said the overrun came from the environment suits being delivered late.
- Judy Burns and Chet Richards wrote it.
- The episode was nominated for an Emmy for Outstanding Achievement in Art Direction and Scenic Design, losing to Mission: Impossible.
- Barbara Babcock voices the Tholian commander Loskene without a credit.
- Star Trek: Enterprise finally explained where the Defiant went: in the two-part "In a Mirror, Darkly," it turns up in the Mirror Universe of Archer's era.
- In 2010 Gerry W. Beyer of Texas Tech University School of Law cited Kirk's recorded message as an early example of a video will.
The thread
A ghost ship, universes that overlap, and a sequel that waited decades.
Came before
Shares DNA with
Left its mark on
DNA strand
Alternate Selves
Kirk isn't gone, only out of phase, sliding in and out of a universe that sits on top of ours. The episode makes that strange idea simple by showing it: a captain in a spacesuit, see-through, standing on his own bridge where nobody can reach him.
Every great sci-fi story is built from a handful of strands like this one. Each strand page explains how it works and traces it across shows, books and films.
If this one stayed with you
Where to go next, and why.
Watch · Star Trek: Enterprise
"In a Mirror, Darkly"
If you wondered what happened to the Defiant, this two-parter answers it, from the far side of the mirror.
Watch · Star Trek S2
"Mirror, Mirror" (1967)
The original trip to the universe next door, and the one the Defiant's later fate depends on.
Watch · Star Trek S2
"The Doomsday Machine" (1967)
Another derelict starship, another command crisis, and one of the tensest hours of the original series.
Read · Novel
Solaris by Stanisław Lem
If the madness creeping through the crew was what stayed with you, Lem's novel puts a handful of scientists next to something they can't understand and lets it work on their minds.