
The story in 5 beats
- Missiles from nowhere
Old-fashioned missiles fire on the Enterprise. Chekov traces them to Yonada, an asteroid on a collision course with an inhabited planet.
- McCoy's secret
McCoy tells Kirk he has xenopolycythemia and about a year to live. He beams down with Kirk and Spock anyway.
- Touched the sky
Underground, an old man gives them pills and tells them he once touched the sky. Then he collapses and dies.
The Oracle's bargainSpoiler · tap to reveal
Natira asks McCoy to marry her. The Oracle agrees if he becomes one of her people, implant and all, and he says yes.
The book of the peopleSpoiler · tap to reveal
Kirk and Spock get hold of the book the Oracle guards and repair the engine. Spock finds something in it meant for McCoy.
Why it still matters
This is McCoy's episode, which the original series didn't give out often. It opens with him admitting he has xenopolycythemia, a terminal illness, and a year left. DeForest Kelley gets to play a man who has stopped expecting a future and then, very suddenly, is offered one, in the form of Natira (Katherine Woodville) and a whole world that wants him to stay.
The big idea is better than almost anything else in the third season. Yonada is an asteroid more than ten thousand years old, with a breathable interior and a population that has no idea it's travelling anywhere. Science fiction had been building ark ships like this for decades. The title, the show's longest at the time, comes from an old man who has worked out the truth and said it out loud.
Keith R.A. DeCandido, rewatching it for Reactor, called it "an object lesson in why the execution of a story is far more important than an idea" and gave it 4 out of 10. He has a point: the opening missile attack is never explained and the romance moves at warp speed. Watch it for Kelley and Woodville, and for that line.
A world that's really a ship
Yonada is a ship, carrying what may be the last of the Fabrini, and the Oracle is the system that keeps its passengers in line. Anyone who learns too much is punished through the instrument of obedience, a small implant under the skin. That's what kills the old man, and it's what McCoy accepts when he agrees to stay with Natira. Soon it turns on him too, and Spock has to remove it.
Kirk tells Natira what her world is, and her own implant starts to punish her, which proves his point. The Oracle superheats the room around Kirk and Spock, but they come away with the book, find the controls and repair the engine. Natira frees McCoy from his promise. And in the Fabrini records Spock finds a cure for xenopolycythemia, so McCoy gets his life back and walks away from the one he'd just chosen. Kirk promises they'll be nearby when Yonada arrives, a year from now.
Behind the scenes
- It's Rik Vollaerts's only Star Trek script. He also wrote "The Bookworm Turns" for the 1966 Batman series.
- Tony Leader directed. Katherine Woodville plays Natira, Jon Lormer the old man who has touched the sky, and Byron Morrow the admiral who orders Kirk to move on.
- At the time it aired it had the longest title of any Star Trek episode.
- The ark-ship idea was already a science fiction standby. Reactor's rewatch traces it back through Olaf Stapledon, Robert A. Heinlein, Harlan Ellison and others.
- Tie-in fiction kept McCoy's Fabrini connection alive: the novelization of Star Trek: The Motion Picture and the novel The Lost Years both have him spending his retirement researching Fabrini medicine.
- The Mirror Universe novel The Sorrows of Empire imagines the flip side: its McCoy never met Yonada, so the disease killed him.
The thread
Ark ships that forgot they were ships, a computer god, and a doctor who almost stayed.
Came before
Shares DNA with
Left its mark on
DNA strand
Is Any of This Real?
The people of Yonada live inside a sky they've never questioned, on a world that is really a vehicle. The best touch is that one old man already knows the truth, and saying it is what kills him. On Yonada, the Oracle makes sure that learning your world is hollow costs you something.
Every great sci-fi story is built from a handful of strands like this one. Each strand page explains how it works and traces it across shows, books and films.
If this one stayed with you
Where to go next, and why.
Watch · Star Trek S1
"The Return of the Archons" (1967)
If the Oracle and its implants got under your skin, this is the earlier episode where Kirk takes on a computer that runs a whole society.
Watch · Star Trek S2
"The Apple" (1967)
Another people living happily under a machine's rule, and another argument about whether the Enterprise should leave them that way.
Read · Novel
The Lost Years
If you wanted more of McCoy and the Fabrini, this tie-in novel picks up the thread years later.
Watch · Star Trek S1
"Miri" (1966)
A planet with a terrible secret and a doctor racing a deadline, from the show's first season.