Star Trek: The Next Generation / Season 6 / Episode 6

True Q

A bright young intern from Kansas joins the Enterprise and starts doing things no intern should be able to do. Then Q shows up, very interested in her.

  • First aired Oct 26, 1992 · Syndication
  • Directed by Robert Scheerer
  • Written by René Echevarria
  • Guest starring Olivia d'Abo and John de Lancie
Still from Star Trek: The Next Generation, "True Q"
Still from Star Trek: The Next Generation, "True Q"
Image via TMDB
Star Trek: The Next Generation, "True Q" (Syndication, 1992). Image via TMDB.

The story in 5 beats

  1. The intern

    Amanda Rogers joins the Enterprise to study under Dr. Crusher. A falling cargo container swerves away from Riker, and she single-handedly contains a warp core breach.

  2. Q explains

    Q arrives and tells Amanda the truth: her parents were Q who took human form. He's there to teach her, and to take her back to the Continuum.

  3. Trying out power

    Amanda starts experimenting, sometimes for fun and sometimes recklessly. Crusher objects to Q's lessons, and Picard insists the choice has to be hers.

  4. A tornado in KansasSpoiler · tap to reveal

    Picard has Data look into her parents' deaths in a Kansas tornado, an almost impossible event with Earth's weather control. Q admits what really happened.

  5. Tagra IVSpoiler · tap to reveal

    Q gives Amanda a choice. Then a nearby planet's atmospheric systems begin to fail, faster than the crew can help.

Why it still matters

Amanda Rogers is a cheerful Starfleet intern who has come aboard to study under Dr. Crusher, and she's been hiding something: when a cargo container falls toward Riker, it lands somewhere else. Then Q arrives, and it's clear he knows exactly what she is and has been sent to find out more.

Q episodes tend to be comedies with Picard as the straight man. This one plays more like a coming-of-age story with a menacing edge, and it shows the Q Continuum as something like a government, with rules for its own members. Olivia d'Abo makes Amanda smart and likable, so the question of what she'll become lands harder. Zack Handlen at The A.V. Club gave it a B+ and called the ending "a 'real' ending, and not a TV ending."

John de Lancie's Q is darker than usual here, and Picard, who normally just wants Q gone, spends the hour making sure a young woman understands what she's being asked to choose.

Spoilers from here on. What happened to Amanda's parents, and what she decides.

The Continuum's rules

The tornado was no accident. Amanda's parents had chosen to live as humans in Kansas, and the Q Continuum executed them when they couldn't stop using their powers. Q's real assignment was to find out whether Amanda is a full Q or a hybrid, with orders to destroy her if she turned out to be a hybrid. Picard is appalled. Q's answer is that beings with unlimited power have to be governed somehow, and the Continuum takes that job seriously.

Q decides she is a true Q and gives her a choice: join the Continuum, or live as a human and never use her powers, the promise her parents couldn't keep. When the planet's atmosphere starts to fail and the people below are about to die, Amanda saves them with a gesture, which Q says he expected. She agrees to go with him, but first she says goodbye to the parents who raised her and to Crusher, who reminds her that as a Q she can do whatever she wants.

Behind the scenes

  • Olivia d'Abo told StarTrek.com in 2011, "I really didn't know anything about the franchise of Star Trek," though she and her brother had grown up watching the original series.
  • She had just done a play at the Mark Taper Forum, and said the role called for theater training and the ability to learn dialogue fast.
  • She said John de Lancie reminded her of Puck from A Midsummer Night's Dream, and that she loved working with Patrick Stewart, especially in the last scene, where Picard lets Amanda choose.
  • Keith DeCandido's Tor.com rewatch reads the Kansas tornado as a less cute riff on The Wizard of Oz, and Q's line about unlimited power bringing responsibility as a nod to Spider-Man.
  • DeCandido also points out that Amanda can't resist using her powers any more than Riker could in "Hide and Q."

The thread

A girl from Kansas, a famous lesson about power, and Q's earlier attempts to give mortals what he has.

Came before

Shares DNA with

CarrieStephen King · novel · 1974 · a young woman discovering a power everyone around her fears

Picked up later

The Eternal TideKirsten Beyer · Star Trek: Voyager novel · Amanda returns again

DNA strand

The State Knows Best

The Q Continuum looks like a society of free gods until you see it set rules for its own. Amanda's choice comes with an authority behind it that she has never met, and Picard can do nothing about that except make sure she understands what she's choosing.

Every great sci-fi story is built from a handful of strands like this one. Each strand page explains how it works and traces it across shows, books and films.

Also in this strand:"Hide and Q""Déjà Q"Explore this strand →

If this one stayed with you

Where to go next, and why.

Watch · TNG S3

"Déjà Q" (1990)

The flip side: Q thrown out of the Continuum and made human. If you want to see how the Continuum treats its own, this is the funny version.

Watch · Star Trek

"Charlie X" (1966)

A lonely teenager with enormous powers joins the original Enterprise. It asks Amanda's question twenty-six years earlier, and much less kindly.

Read · Novel

Carrie by Stephen King

A teenage girl finds out what she can do, and the people around her aren't ready. If Amanda's story felt too gentle, this is the dark version.

Watch · TNG S1

"Hide and Q" (1987)

Q's first attempt to hand his powers to a member of the crew, with Riker as the test subject.

Sources