
More from the episode
The story in 5 beats
- The boy from Thasus
The cargo ship Antares hands over Charlie Evans, the only survivor of a crash, bound for the colony Alpha V. Its crew seem very keen to be rid of him.
- Learning to be human
Charlie attaches himself to Kirk as a father figure and fixates on Rand. He can't work out why he isn't allowed to have her.
- Party tricks
Meatloaf turns into real turkeys. Uhura loses her voice mid-song, and Spock's lyrette goes haywire. Charlie is behind all of it.
Nobody laughs at CharlieSpoiler · tap to reveal
A crewman who laughs at him vanishes. The Antares is destroyed. When Rand slaps him, she disappears too, and Charlie takes the ship.
"I wanna stay!"Spoiler · tap to reveal
The Thasians arrive to take Charlie home. He begs Kirk to let him stay with people, and Rand cries as he's taken.
Why it still matters
Charlie Evans spent fourteen years alone on the planet Thasus after a crash, learning to talk from the wreck's surviving computers. Now he's on a starship full of adults, and nobody ever taught him how people work. He latches on to Kirk as a father figure, falls hard for Janice Rand, and takes every brush-off like a wound.
Robert Walker plays him gawky, sweet and painfully needy, and that makes the episode hard to sit through in the best way. Every adolescent humiliation happens in front of the whole crew, and Charlie has the power to make the embarrassment stop. Syfy later ranked Walker the sixth-best guest star of the original series, and Hollywood.com put the episode 13th of 79, calling it a primary-colored fantasia of '60s pop art.
The story goes back to Gene Roddenberry's 1964 pitch for the series, and D. C. Fontana turned it into the teleplay. Listen for Roddenberry himself as the voice of the ship's cook.
Too much for a seventeen-year-old
Charlie admits he got rid of the Antares by removing a vital part of its warp core. After that he stops pretending. He makes all the ship's phasers vanish, turns crew members into other things or freezes them where they stand, and won't say whether Rand is still alive. Kirk tries running every system at once in the hope of draining him. It doesn't work, but it keeps Charlie busy long enough.
A Thasian ship arrives. Its commander explains that his people gave Charlie his powers and can't take them back, which makes him too dangerous to live among humans. The Thasians restore everyone Charlie harmed, except the crew of the Antares. Kirk speaks up for the boy, and it changes nothing. The last thing Charlie says is "I wanna stay!", and Rand is in tears.
Behind the scenes
- Roddenberry had the premise in his March 1964 pitch for the series, under the name "The Day Charlie Became God", and handed it to D. C. Fontana to dramatize.
- Its working title was "Charlie's Law", which James Blish kept for his prose adaptation.
- Studio executives didn't want it to air second, but the only other finished episode was "Where No Man Has Gone Before". Because almost all of it takes place aboard the Enterprise, it needed little post-production and was ready early.
- Gene Roddenberry voices the cook who discovers the meatloaf has become real turkeys. It's his only speaking role in the original series.
- Director Lawrence Dobkin later played the Klingon ambassador Kell in The Next Generation's "The Mind's Eye".
- The Antares crew wear the turtleneck uniforms from the two pilots, and the ship exteriors were reused from "The Cage" and "Where No Man Has Gone Before".
The thread
The child with unlimited power was already a sci-fi nightmare when Charlie came along, and this one asks you to feel sorry for him.
Came before
Shares DNA with
Left its mark on
DNA strand
Be Careful What You Wish For
Every teenager wishes they could make the embarrassment stop. Charlie can, and the episode shows what that does to everyone around him, and finally to him. The powers the Thasians gave him are the reason he can't stay with people.
Every great sci-fi story is built from a handful of strands like this one. Each strand page explains how it works and traces it across shows, books and films.
If this one stayed with you
Where to go next, and why.
Watch · The Twilight Zone
"It's a Good Life"
If Charlie's tantrums unsettled you, meet Anthony, a six-year-old with the same gift and a whole town too frightened to tell him no.
Watch · Star Trek
"Where No Man Has Gone Before"
The episode that aired the following week. This time the person with godlike powers is a grown man, and Kirk's oldest friend.
Watch · Film
Chronicle (2012)
Three teenagers get telekinesis, and the loneliest of them can't handle being laughed at. It's Charlie's problem again, told as found footage.
Read · Short story
"It's a Good Life" by Jerome Bixby
The 1953 story behind the Twilight Zone episode, and even bleaker on the page.

