
The story in 5 beats
- A rescue interrupted
The Enterprise is on its way to help colonists hurt in an explosion on Quadra Sigma when Q appears and demands they stop to play a game.
- The game
Q strands Riker and most of the bridge crew on a barren planet where the rule is to stay alive. When Yar objects, he puts her in a penalty box.
- The wager
Q tells Picard the Continuum wants Riker. If Riker takes their powers, Q gets the Enterprise. If he refuses, Q leaves humanity alone.
- Power
Riker uses the powers to bring his friends back from the dead, then promises Picard not to again. At the rescue site he leaves a dead girl dead, and regrets it.
GiftsSpoiler · tap to reveal
Riker offers his friends what he thinks they want: adulthood for Wesley, sight for La Forge, humanity for Data. One by one, they say no.
Why it still matters
John de Lancie's Q makes his second visit, and the show starts to work out what to do with him. This time he arrives as a tempter with a wager: the Q Continuum wants to know whether Riker is worthy of their powers. If Riker accepts them, Q wins command of the Enterprise. If he turns them down, Q has to leave humanity alone for good.
The episode is uneven, and critics have said so: The A.V. Club called it a mess, and Tor.com's Keith DeCandido found it predictable. Two scenes keep it in rewatches anyway. One is a ready-room duel of Shakespeare quotations between Picard and Q. The other comes when Riker starts handing out wishes to his friends and learns what they actually want.
It also points ahead to a lot of later TNG, with Q as a recurring character, the Continuum as an offstage authority that can yank him home, and the Picard and Q double act that later seasons kept coming back to.
Nobody wants the wish
The powers change Riker fast. He gets short-tempered and starts calling his captain "Jean-Luc." With Q's nudging and Picard's blessing, he gives his friends what he thinks they want. Wesley becomes a man of 25. La Forge gets working eyes. Worf gets a Klingon companion. Data is offered the chance to be human.
Each of them turns the gift down. Data's reason is the one people remember: humanity handed to him this way wouldn't be real to him.
Riker gives the powers up. Picard declares that Q has lost, Q tries to back out of the bet, and the Continuum summons him home. Picard's trust in his Number One turns out to have been well placed.
Behind the scenes
- Maurice Hurley asked to be credited as C.J. Holland because Gene Roddenberry had rewritten his script so heavily. Hurley later called it a misunderstanding, and it changed how scripts were developed: Roddenberry did fewer detailed rewrites afterwards.
- Hurley's original story had three Q and about 100,000 residents of the Q's own dying planet who needed to be relocated. None of it was used later.
- Cliff Bole watched "Encounter at Farpoint" to prepare, then found de Lancie slipped back into the part on his own. Bole later called the episode "a lot of fun."
- Troi doesn't appear. Being left out of this and three other episodes made Marina Sirtis think she might be cut from the show.
- At one point Q passes himself off as Data, yellow contact lenses and all.
- Its Nielsen rating of 11.0 was higher than the episodes on either side of it.
The thread
All-powerful beings, tempting offers and humans who say no thanks.
Came before
Shares DNA with
DNA strand
Be Careful What You Wish For
Q offers Riker unlimited power with no strings attached. Riker's wishes are all for other people, though, and each of them knows better than he does what they'd lose by accepting.
Every great sci-fi story is built from a handful of strands like this one. Each strand page explains how it works and traces it across shows, books and films.
If this one stayed with you
Where to go next, and why.
Watch · TNG S2
"Q Who"
Maurice Hurley's next Q story, and the one where Q's games stop being a nuisance.
Watch · Star Trek
"The Squire of Gothos"
If you like your all-powerful aliens petulant and theatrical, here's the original-series version.
Read · Play
Hamlet by William Shakespeare
Picard and Q trade Shakespeare in the ready room, and Picard makes a point of knowing his Hamlet.
Read · Novel
Q & A by Keith R.A. DeCandido
One writer's answer to the question this episode raises: why Q keeps coming back to humans.