
The story in 5 beats
- Omicron Theta
On the way to a starbase, the Enterprise stops at the colony where Data was found. The colonists are gone and the farmland is barren.
- Soong's lab
Underground, the away team finds the lab of Dr. Noonien Soong, Data's maker, and a disassembled android identical to Data.
- Lore
Put back together, the android calls himself Lore and says he's the more perfect model. To the crew, he plays naive.
Brother to brotherSpoiler · tap to reveal
In private, Lore tells Data what destroyed the colony: a crystalline entity. Then he disables Data and takes his place on the bridge.
The cargo baySpoiler · tap to reveal
Wesley spots the impostor. Data, revived, fights Lore, and Wesley beams Lore into space.
Why it still matters
Until now Data's past was a blank, even to him. He was found on Omicron Theta, a colony that had vanished. This episode gives him a maker, Dr. Noonien Soong, a lab hidden underground, and a brother. Much of what TNG later did with Data, from "Brothers" to "Descent" to Star Trek: Nemesis, starts here.
Brent Spiner gets the hour to himself. He plays both androids, sometimes in the same scene, and Lore is everything Data isn't: smooth, emotional and openly scornful of the humans around him. Spiner was the one who suggested the evil-twin story, and director Rob Bowman credited him with making the double role work.
The script is clumsy, and critics have mostly said so: DeCandido gave it four out of ten, Wheaton a D. But Spiner's Lore is a gift, and the episode has a line fans still quote, said at different moments by Picard, Dr. Crusher and Wesley himself: "Shut up, Wesley!"
The first brother
Lore tells Data that the order of their creation was the other way round: Lore was built first. The colonists were afraid of him and petitioned to have him taken apart, and Data came after. Lore also knows what happened to Omicron Theta. A crystalline entity drained the colony of life, and Lore means to hand it the Enterprise.
He drugs Data, swaps clothes with him and walks onto the bridge as Data, planning to lower the shields and let the entity in. Picard grows suspicious, and Wesley is the one who works out that this Data isn't Data.
Lore overpowers Worf. Beverly and Wesley wake the real Data, and the three of them confront Lore in the cargo bay. After a brawl, Data knocks Lore onto the transporter pad and Wesley beams him into space. The entity leaves, and the ship goes on its way.
Behind the scenes
- According to Larry Nemecek's The Star Trek: The Next Generation Companion, the story began with a female android who would be a love interest for Data. After many rewrites, Spiner suggested the evil twin instead.
- Rick Berman named "Datalore" as the first-season episode that changed most from its original idea.
- It's Gene Roddenberry's last Star Trek script credit.
- Rewrites delayed it, so it swapped places in the schedule with "The Big Goodbye" and Rob Bowman directed it instead of Joseph L. Scanlan. The swap gave Bowman and Spiner an eight-day shoot and time to work on the script.
- A late change made Data unable to use contractions, which held up filming. He uses them in this episode and earlier ones anyway.
- The Crystalline Entity was among the show's first computer-generated effects, and the Blu-ray release rebuilt it with new CGI. Ron Jones wrote the score.
- About 10.3 million people watched, down from 11.5 million for "The Big Goodbye."
The thread
Evil twins, android doubles and the first chapter of Data's family history.
Came before
Shares DNA with
Left its mark on
DNA strand
Alternate Selves
Lore is the brother who came first, the one the colonists were afraid of. Spiner plays the two as mirror images, and the pairing makes you wonder what Soong held back when he built Data.
Every great sci-fi story is built from a handful of strands like this one. Each strand page explains how it works and traces it across shows, books and films.
If this one stayed with you
Where to go next, and why.
Watch · TNG S2
"The Measure of a Man"
If Data's origins hooked you, this is where Starfleet argues about what he actually is.
Watch · Star Trek
"The Enemy Within"
Kirk split into two, one of them much nastier: the original series' take on the evil double.
Read · Novel
Immortal Coil by Jeffrey Lang
Ties Star Trek's many artificial minds together, Soong's work included.
Read · Novel
Do Androids Dream of Electric Sheep? by Philip K. Dick
Androids that pass for human and the people trying to tell the difference, a world Lore would fit right into.