Star Trek: The Next Generation / Season 5 / Episode 18

Cause and Effect

The Enterprise blows up before the opening credits. Then the crew sits down to play poker again, with a nagging feeling they've seen these cards before.

  • First aired the week of Mar 23, 1992 · Syndication
  • Directed by Jonathan Frakes
  • Written by Brannon Braga
  • Guest starring Kelsey Grammer
Still from Star Trek: The Next Generation, "Cause and Effect"
Still from Star Trek: The Next Generation, "Cause and Effect"
Image via TMDB
Star Trek: The Next Generation, "Cause and Effect" (Syndication, 1992). Image via TMDB.

The story in 5 beats

  1. Abandon ship

    The episode opens with the bridge in flames and Picard ordering everyone off. Then the Enterprise explodes.

  2. Poker night

    Earlier, or later, or again: the senior officers play cards. Crusher can't shake the feeling she's seen this hand before.

  3. Voices

    Crusher hears voices in her quarters at night and records them. They are the crew, panicking, at the end of days they don't remember.

  4. ThreeSpoiler · tap to reveal

    The crew works out the loop and how to slip a message past the reset. In the next pass, the number three keeps turning up everywhere.

  5. Welcome to the futureSpoiler · tap to reveal

    They break out. The other ship, the Bozeman, has been stuck far longer, and its captain doesn't know what year it is.

Why it still matters

Most time-travel episodes send the crew somewhere. This one keeps them exactly where they are, on the same day, and kills them at the end of it. A ship comes out of a strange rift, collides with the Enterprise, and everyone dies. Then the senior staff are back at their poker game, Crusher knocks over a glass, and it all starts over. Each time round, a few people feel a little more déjà vu, and the episode becomes a puzzle about how you'd send a message to yourself through a reset button.

It's built like a piece of music: the same scenes played again and again with small variations, and Jonathan Frakes found a different way to shoot each pass so it never feels like a rerun. The opening, with the ship exploding before the credits, is still one of the boldest teasers Star Trek ever did. It aired almost a year before Groundhog Day, and some viewers were so thrown by the repetition that they phoned their local stations to report a broadcast fault.

Spoilers from here on. How they get out is half the fun.

Riker's three pips

Each loop ends the same way. The USS Bozeman comes out of the rift on a collision course. Riker suggests decompressing the main shuttlebay to push the Enterprise clear; Data suggests a tractor beam to shove the Bozeman away. Picard goes with Data, and the Bozeman hits a warp nacelle. Once the crew understands the loop, Data rigs himself to send a tiny message into the next cycle. All he can get through is a hint, and in the next loop it shows up as threes: poker hands of all threes, threes on the instruments. Data realizes it means the three pips on Riker's collar. This time they take Riker's idea, and the ship clears.

They've been stuck for 17 days. The Bozeman's captain, Morgan Bateson, played by Kelsey Grammer, hails them to ask what's going on, and Picard gently tells him that his ship has been missing for over 90 years.

The Question Underneath

How would you know if you'd already made this mistake before?

The crew keep making the same reasonable choice, and it keeps killing them. They escape through a tiny message across the loop, a number Data plants in himself. It's a puzzle episode with a quiet idea underneath: experience matters only if some trace of it carries forward, and the smallest hint can change everything if someone listens.

Challenge the DNA

Who should Picard have listened to the first time?

Who should Picard have listened to the first time?
Or skip ahead to our reading

Data's was a perfectly sensible call; nobody could have known. The fun is that the answer was in the room the whole time, and the crew's own hint across the loops points them back to it.

Behind the scenes

  • Brannon Braga first wanted to tell one event from several points of view, like Rashomon. When that didn't fit an hour of television, he turned it into a time loop instead, partly to avoid yet another broken-timeline plot.
  • Rick Berman insisted that every loop be shot fresh, with no reused footage, so it wouldn't look like a clip show. Frakes prepared while filming "The Outcast" and used odd angles on familiar sets, a bungee-cord camera rig and slow zooms to keep each pass different.
  • The Bozeman was meant to be an original-series-era Constitution-class ship, but the budget ruled that out. The model is the USS Reliant from The Wrath of Khan, modified. A cameo by Kirstie Alley as Saavik fell through because of her schedule.
  • Showrunner Michael Piller had Braga rewrite the technobabble briefing scene many times. A planned closing montage of ship collisions was cut for budget.
  • It drew a 13.0 Nielsen rating, the sixth most-watched episode of the season. Some viewers called stations thinking the repeated scenes were a technical fault.

The thread

Where the loop idea came from, who did it before, and who copied the homework.

Came before

Shares DNA with

Left its mark on

Legends of Tomorrow, "Here I Go Again"2018 · a time-loop episode inspired by this one
X-Men '972024 · Beau DeMayo cited it as an influence on the season finale

DNA strand

Time Loops & Timelines

A time loop is a trap made of habit. The crew can't remember the last cycle, so the only way out is to leave themselves a clue small enough to survive the reset. It turns the strand into a puzzle about memory: what can you carry forward when you can't carry anything at all?

Every great sci-fi story is built from a handful of strands like this one. Each strand page explains how it works and traces it across shows, books and films.

Also in this strand:Groundhog Day"Yesterday's Enterprise"Explore this strand →

If this one stayed with you

Where to go next, and why.

Watch · Film

Groundhog Day (1993)

The comedy version of the same trap, released the year after. Bill Murray, a small town and a day that won't end.

Watch · Film

Edge of Tomorrow (2014)

A soldier relives the same battle every time he dies. If the 'how do we get a message through' part was your favorite, this is that for two hours.

Read · Novel

Replay — Ken Grimwood

A man dies at 43 and wakes up at 18 with his memories intact, again and again. The quiet, adult version of a time loop.

Your next episode

Three directions to go from here, all on Sci-Fi DNA.

Still from Star Trek: The Next Generation, "Yesterday's Enterprise"

More of this feeling

Yesterday's Enterprise

Star Trek: The Next Generation

More TNG time trouble, with the whole ship at stake.

Still from Black Mirror, "Nosedive"

Something completely different

Nosedive

Black Mirror

From a ship that keeps exploding to a world that rates every smile.

On the trail Time loops that do more than repeat the day (stop 1 of 6).

Sources