Star Trek: The Next Generation / Season 5 / Episode 19

The First Duty

A cadet dies in a training crash at Starfleet Academy, and Wesley Crusher was flying in the same formation. The official story satisfies everyone except Picard.

  • First aired Mar 30, 1992 · Syndication
  • Directed by Paul Lynch
  • Written by Ronald D. Moore and Naren Shankar
  • Guest starring Wil Wheaton, Robert Duncan McNeill and Ray Walston
Still from Star Trek: The Next Generation, "The First Duty"
Still from Star Trek: The Next Generation, "The First Duty"
Image via TMDB
Star Trek: The Next Generation, "The First Duty" (Syndication, 1992). Image via TMDB.

The story in 5 beats

  1. Commencement

    The Enterprise heads to Earth for Picard's Academy address. On arrival he learns of a training crash: Wesley is hurt and cadet Joshua Albert is dead.

  2. Locarno's account

    At the inquiry, squadron leader Nick Locarno describes a Yeager Loop over Titan that went wrong, and lets the blame settle on Albert.

  3. The numbers don't fit

    Satellite data contradicts the cadets' account of the formation. They turn evasive, and Picard starts asking questions of his own.

  4. Kolvoord StarburstSpoiler · tap to reveal

    The crew works out what the team was really doing: a banned maneuver. Picard tells Wesley to come forward by the next hearing, or he will.

  5. The hearingSpoiler · tap to reveal

    With the inquiry about to close for lack of proof, Wesley tells the truth. Locarno takes the blame and is expelled.

Why it still matters

There are no aliens here and nothing to fix with the deflector dish. The Enterprise goes home to Earth so Picard can give the Academy's commencement speech, and the story becomes a tight drama about students who closed ranks after one of their own died. It's the first time Star Trek showed the Academy on screen, and it gets the campus details right: cliques, a charismatic upperclassman and a hearing room full of adults who want a tidy answer.

Wil Wheaton had left the show full-time in 1990, and he said coming back for this one felt like coming home. Wesley gets his best material in years, and the test is whether he'll tell the truth when his friends are counting on him not to. Patrick Stewart gets one of Picard's most quoted speeches, and Robert Duncan McNeill makes squadron leader Nick Locarno so persuasive that the producers later built a Voyager character on him.

Watch for Ray Walston as Boothby, a name Picard had dropped twice before this episode finally put him on screen.

Spoilers from here on. What really happened over Titan, and what it cost.

The first duty

Nova Squadron was never flying a Yeager Loop. Picard and his engineers work out that the team was attempting the Kolvoord Starburst, a maneuver banned more than a century earlier after a training accident killed five cadets. Albert had been nervous about flying, and Locarno kept him on the team anyway. Locarno's story protects the squadron by blaming the one member who can't answer back.

Picard doesn't report it himself straight away. He tells Wesley that the first duty of every Starfleet officer is to the truth, and gives him until the next day's hearing to come forward. Locarno leans on Wesley to stick to the story. At the hearing, with the admiral ready to dismiss the case, Wesley confesses. Locarno takes full responsibility and is expelled; Wesley and the two other survivors lose their flight privileges and a year of academic credit. As they part, Picard passes on some advice Boothby once gave him, back when he was the cadet in trouble.

Behind the scenes

  • McNeill's Nick Locarno became the template for Tom Paris on Star Trek: Voyager.
  • Boothby had been mentioned in "Final Mission" and "The Game" before he finally appeared here, played by Ray Walston of My Favorite Martian.
  • Michael Piller said on the DVD commentary that the US Air Force has shown the episode to its cadets.
  • The bell rung at the hearing is the one from the original series episode "Court Martial."
  • Wheaton, 19 at the time, told an interviewer on set that his chair no longer had his name on it now that he was a guest star, and that two days with the Nova Squad cast had been more fun than almost any cast in years.
  • Shannon Fill made the first of her two appearances as cadet Sito Jaxa; the second was the seventh-season episode "Lower Decks."

The thread

Military hearings, closed ranks and the kids from Nova Squadron who kept turning up.

Came before

Shares DNA with

Left its mark on

DNA strand

Be Careful What You Wish For

Nova Squadron wanted to be the team that pulled off the impossible, the one the Academy would remember. The episode is honest about how good that wanting feels, and that's why the cost lands as hard as it does.

Every great sci-fi story is built from a handful of strands like this one. Each strand page explains how it works and traces it across shows, books and films.

Also in this strand:"The Drumhead"A Few Good MenExplore this strand →

If this one stayed with you

Where to go next, and why.

Watch · TNG S7

"Lower Decks" (1994)

Sito Jaxa gets a second chance, and the episode looks at the Enterprise from the junior officers' side of the table. It hits harder with this one fresh in your mind.

Watch · Film

A Few Good Men (1992)

Released the same year: a military hearing, a code of loyalty that protects the wrong people, and a lot of shouting about the truth.

Read · Novel

The Caine Mutiny by Herman Wouk

If Wesley's bind between his friends and the service got to you, Wouk spends a whole novel inside that problem, ending in a court-martial.

Watch · TNG S4

"The Drumhead" (1991)

Picard in a hearing room again, this time on the other side of the questions.

Sources