
The story in 5 beats
- A missing shuttle
The J'naii, a people without genders, ask for help finding a shuttle lost in a pocket of null space.
- Co-pilots
Riker flies the rescue shuttle with the J'naii pilot Soren. Over a shared meal, the two of them get close.
- A secret
Soren admits to being attracted to Riker, and to identifying as female, which her society calls a perversion and treats with "psychotectic therapy".
On trialSpoiler · tap to reveal
The relationship is found out. Soren refuses to let Riker take the blame and defends herself before the J'naii.
Too lateSpoiler · tap to reveal
Riker and Worf go to rescue Soren without Picard's blessing. The therapy has already been done.
Why it still matters
The J'naii have no genders, and they consider having one a sickness. Riker and a J'naii pilot named Soren get close while searching for a lost shuttle, and Soren tells him a secret: she has always felt female, and her society has a treatment for people like her.
Writer Jeri Taylor was open about what this was. "We had wanted to do a gay rights story and had not been able to figure out how to do it," she said later, and she called the result "a gay rights story. It absolutely, specifically and outspokenly dealt with gay issues." As StarTrek.com points out, queer fans had long wanted gay characters on Star Trek.
People still argue about it. Some in the LGBT community found it too timid, an allegory where a gay couple should have been. Jonathan Frakes agreed: "Soren should have been more obviously male," he said. Others praised it. The A.V. Club gave it an A and wrote that it "feels less like a lecture and more like a cry of rage." Den of Geek put it among TNG's 25 must-watch episodes.
Cured
At her hearing, Soren refuses to hide. "I am female. I was born that way," she tells the J'naii, and asks: "What makes you think you can dictate how people love each other?" The J'naii are unmoved and order her into therapy, pointing to how happy their reformed citizens are.
Picard sympathizes but won't sanction a rescue, citing the Prime Directive and Riker's career. Riker goes anyway, with Worf, who volunteers. They're too late. Soren has been treated, and she now calls what she felt for Riker a sickness. She says she's happy and apologizes to him, and Riker leaves alone.
Critics said the ending seemed to let the conversion therapy win. StarTrek.com argues that the failed rescue underlines the tragedy, though it offended some LGBTQ+ fans. The A.V. Club's Zack Handlen called it brutal because Soren's "choice is stripped away from her," and ended his review by noting that, almost 20 years on, "it still stings."
Behind the scenes
- David Gerrold's first-season script "Blood and Fire" would have included an openly gay couple, but it was never made. "The Outcast" was meant, in part, to answer criticism that the show never acknowledged gay relationships.
- Producer Rick Berman said it "did deal with the issue of intolerance towards sexual orientation and it met that objective well," while admitting it didn't give some gay and lesbian viewers what they had asked for.
- Jonathan Frakes thought a man should have played Soren. "I didn't think they were gutsy enough to take it where they should have," he said in Captains' Logs.
- The episode sets the Federation's founding in 2161, a date Mike and Denise Okuda had guessed for the Star Trek Chronology. Here it became official.
- Megan Cole, who plays the J'naii judge Noor, later played the Romulan senator Cretak on Deep Space Nine.
The thread
A love story that can't be allowed, told through a people who have outlawed gender.
Came before
Shares DNA with
DNA strand
Love Beyond Limits
Riker and Soren fall for each other across a line her whole society exists to police. The science fiction lets the episode flip the roles, so the audience sees what it's like when the majority calls your feelings a disease.
Every great sci-fi story is built from a handful of strands like this one. Each strand page explains how it works and traces it across shows, books and films.
If this one stayed with you
Where to go next, and why.
Read · Novel
The Left Hand of Darkness by Ursula K. Le Guin
If the J'naii made you curious, this is the great novel about an envoy on a planet where gender works nothing like ours.
Watch · Black Mirror
"San Junipero" (2016)
Another love story between two women, told through science fiction, from a show that rarely goes for tenderness.
Watch · Film
The Miseducation of Cameron Post (2018)
The therapy the J'naii use, as it really happens: a teenager sent away to be fixed, and the friends she makes there.
Sources
- “The Outcast (Star Trek: The Next Generation),” Wikipedia
- Nitzan Pincu, “The Next Generation's Call for Equality,” StarTrek.com
- “Jonathan Frakes Doesn't Think Star Trek Went Far Enough With The Next Generation's LGBT Episode,” /Film
- Keith R.A. DeCandido, “Star Trek: The Next Generation Rewatch: "The Outcast",” Tor.com
- Zack Handlen, “Star Trek: The Next Generation: "The Outcast"/"Cause And Effect",” The A.V. Club