
The story in 5 beats
- A cooling planet
The Enterprise helps Atrea IV, whose molten core is solidifying. Two scientists, Pran and Juliana Tainer, come aboard to work on it.
- Mother
Juliana tells Data she was Noonien Soong's wife and helped create him. He checks her story, finds it holds up, and starts getting to know her.
- A duet
They play music together. She admits she was the one who insisted Data be left behind on Omicron Theta, afraid he'd turn out like Lore.
The armSpoiler · tap to reveal
An accident on the planet knocks Juliana out and her arm comes off, showing circuitry. She's an android, and doesn't know it.
A message from SoongSpoiler · tap to reveal
A hologram of Soong explains, and asks Data to let her keep believing she's human. Data has to decide.
Why it still matters
Data's family keeps growing. By season 7 he has met his creator, his brother Lore and the daughter he built himself, and "Inheritance" adds the last piece: Juliana Tainer, a scientist helping the Enterprise save a planet whose core is cooling, who turns out to have been Noonien Soong's wife. She remembers Data's earliest days, including the ones he can't.
Fionnula Flanagan gives Juliana warmth and a guilty conscience, and the scenes where she and Data get to know each other are the heart of it. They play music together, he on violin and she on viola. She sees the painting of Lal and learns about the granddaughter she never met. And she has something to confess about why Data was left behind when the colony on Omicron Theta fell.
Watch Data throughout. He checks her story the way he checks everything, and his reactions are worth a second look.
Soong's last creation
Geordi finds a holographic interface chip in Juliana's positronic brain, and Data activates it on the holodeck. It plays a recording of Soong. The real Juliana was mortally hurt in the Crystalline Entity's attack, he explains, so he built an android and transferred her memories into it, and she has believed ever since that she is human. She later left him, and he admits the real Juliana would have done the same. He asks Data to let her keep her humanity.
Data says he had already suspected. Her blinking pattern and her musicianship matched his own. He reinstalls the chip, tells her Dr. Crusher repaired her arm, and says nothing more. As she leaves he tells her, "My father told me that he had only one great love in his life. I am certain he was referring to you." Not every critic was comfortable with it: The A.V. Club's Zack Handlen called Soong's choice to build "a robot copy of his dying wife" the episode's big unexamined question.
Behind the scenes
- Fionnula Flanagan played three Star Trek guest roles. This was the second, after Enina Tandro in Deep Space Nine's "Dax," and later came the Vulcan ambassador V'Lar in Enterprise's "Fallen Hero."
- Brent Spiner has now played Soong at three ages: old in "Brothers," young in "Birthright, Part I" and middle-aged here.
- Juliana mentions three prototypes before Lore. One of them, B-4, turns up later in Star Trek Nemesis.
- The planet where Data met Soong in "Brothers" gets a name for the first time here.
- The ship manifests Data looks through include names honouring the production staff, such as "Alpha Echevarria IV," after co-writer René Echevarria.
- Juliana returns in the tie-in novels, including Jeffrey Lang's Immortal Coil and David Mack's Cold Equations trilogy.
The thread
Data's family tree gets its last branch, and he finds out what his parents owed him.
Came before
Shares DNA with
Left its mark on
DNA strand
Do Machines Dream?
Data has spent seven years wondering whether a machine can be a person. Here the question comes home through family, as he weighs what the people who built him owed him and what he owes them. The episode answers with kindness, which is very Data.
Every great sci-fi story is built from a handful of strands like this one. Each strand page explains how it works and traces it across shows, books and films.
If this one stayed with you
Where to go next, and why.
Watch · Film
Blade Runner (1982)
Androids, their makers and a love story with a hard question in the middle. If Data's side of this one stayed with you, this is the next stop.
Read · Novel
Do Androids Dream of Electric Sheep? by Philip K. Dick
The novel Blade Runner came from, and a stranger, sadder look at what makes an android's feelings count.
Watch · TNG S3
"The Offspring" (1990)
Data as a father, and the daughter whose portrait Juliana finds. The best of the Data family episodes.
Sources
- “Inheritance (Star Trek: The Next Generation),” Wikipedia
- “Star Trek: The Next Generation season 7,” Wikipedia
- Keith R.A. DeCandido, “Star Trek: The Next Generation Rewatch: "Inheritance",” Reactor (Tor.com), 2013
- Zack Handlen, “Star Trek: The Next Generation: "Force Of Nature"/"Inheritance",” The A.V. Club, 2011
- “Blade Runner,” Wikipedia