
The story in 5 beats
- Distress call
A Talarian observation craft sends a distress call. The away team finds four Talarian teenagers aboard and one human boy in the same uniform.
- Jeremiah Rossa
The boy, Jono, is a Federation citizen taken as a small child. His grandmother is a Starfleet admiral.
- Old injuries
Crusher finds old, unexplained injuries, and the crew starts to suspect abuse. Then his Talarian father, Captain Endar, arrives to take him home.
The knifeSpoiler · tap to reveal
Picard tries everything to win Jono over. That night the boy stabs him in his sleep.
Going homeSpoiler · tap to reveal
Picard decides the choice was Jono's all along, and lets him go back to Endar.
Why it still matters
Jono was born Jeremiah Rossa, a Federation citizen and the grandson of a Starfleet admiral, and he was raised by the people who killed his parents. Everyone on the Enterprise assumes they know where he belongs, and the episode spends its hour testing that assumption without letting the crew off easily.
Most of the weight falls on Picard, the only person Jono will listen to, because Talarian culture has taught him to answer only to the man at the top. Zack Handlen of The A.V. Club pointed out that earlier seasons would probably have made the Talarian father a plain villain, and he counted the way the episode handles the crew's assumptions as its main strength.
Not everyone agreed. Keith DeCandido's Tor.com rewatch gave it three out of ten, and Jammer's Reviews called it the least effective of three family episodes in a row. It's a hard one to stay neutral about, because the question it raises about Jono's injuries is a serious one.
Whose son he is
Endar explains himself plainly. He lost his own son fighting the Federation, and Talarian custom lets a warrior take in the children of slain enemies to replace those lost in battle. He says Jono's injuries came from reckless stunts the boy pulled to impress him, and Picard accepts that. The episode asks us to accept it too, and not every viewer did: the Tor.com rewatch notes that it drew outraged letters from people who saw it as sending a child back to an abusive parent.
Jono is torn. He has started to like Picard, and to his mind that is a betrayal of Endar. The stabbing is his way out: Picard survives, and Jono waits to be executed, as a Talarian would expect. Picard realizes he has been pushing his own wishes onto the boy, and with Endar's warships gathering, he hands Jono back. Before he goes, Jono takes off the gloves he wore so he wouldn't have to touch an alien and says goodbye to Picard in a Talarian way usually kept for family.
Behind the scenes
- This was Jeri Taylor's first script for Star Trek. She joined the writing staff afterward and went on to run Star Trek: Voyager in its early years.
- It was the second episode filmed for the season. LeVar Burton's only scene was added later, after he needed emergency surgery.
- The Talarians had been mentioned in "Heart of Glory" but make their first appearance here.
- In an old family photo, Jono's father wears the one-piece uniform from TNG's first two seasons.
- Chad Allen, who plays Jono, was later a regular on Dr. Quinn, Medicine Woman.
The thread
Children raised across enemy lines, the families on both sides, and what Jono's story led to.
Came before
Shares DNA with
Where it led
DNA strand
Us vs. Them
The Federation side is sure it's rescuing one of its own from the enemy. The episode keeps asking who "us" is for a boy who grew up on the other side, and it doesn't hand the crew an easy answer.
Every great sci-fi story is built from a handful of strands like this one. Each strand page explains how it works and traces it across shows, books and films.
If this one stayed with you
Where to go next, and why.
Watch · Film
The Searchers (1956)
If you kept thinking about who gets to decide where a stolen child belongs, John Ford's western asks the same question with much harder edges.
Watch · Star Trek: TNG S1
"Heart of Glory" (1988)
Worf, raised by humans, meets Klingons who want him to choose a side, which is Jono's dilemma turned around.
Read · Novel
Pigs in Heaven by Barbara Kingsolver
A loving adoptive mother, a birth community with its own claim, and a child in the middle. It takes both sides as seriously as this episode tries to.