Red Dwarf / Series I / Episode 2

Future Echoes

Red Dwarf breaks the light barrier and the crew start seeing bits of their own future. One of them is Lister getting blown up, and Rimmer finds that rather cheering.

  • Aired Feb 22, 1988 · BBC2
  • Directed by Ed Bye
  • Written by Rob Grant and Doug Naylor
  • Starring Craig Charles and Chris Barrie
Still from Red Dwarf, "Future Echoes"
Still from Red Dwarf, "Future Echoes"
Image via TMDB · 1 of 4
Red Dwarf, "Future Echoes" (BBC2, 1988). Image via TMDB.

More from the episode

The story in 5 beats

  1. Faster than light

    Lister is about to go into stasis with the Cat for the trip home when Red Dwarf breaks the light barrier, and odd things start to happen.

  2. Echoes

    Holly explains: they're seeing future echoes, glimpses of things still to come. Rimmer sees Lister killed when the navicomp explodes.

  3. Changing fate

    Lister sets out to prove the future can be changed, starting with a smaller echo involving the Cat's tooth, and it doesn't go to plan.

  4. An old manSpoiler · tap to reveal

    Lister fixes the navicomp and nothing happens. Then a much older Lister appears with an explanation.

  5. Two babiesSpoiler · tap to reveal

    In the medical unit, Lister and Rimmer catch one last echo: a future Lister holding twin baby boys.

Why it still matters

This is the episode where Red Dwarf worked out what kind of show it was. Lister wants to sleep through the long trip home in stasis. Before he can, the ship passes the speed of light and time goes wrong: a reflection moves on its own, a second Rimmer babbles in the Drive Room, and the crew catch glimpses of things that haven't happened yet. The worst of them is Lister dying in an explosion.

It was the first time the series built a plot on real science, here time dilation and relativity, and that became the house style. It was the fourth episode recorded, but the team thought it was the strongest of the run and moved it up to second. The writers have said it saved the show; Rob Grant suggested Red Dwarf might not have existed without it.

Watch it for the argument at its center, which is whether a future you've already seen can be changed. Lister spends the episode trying to dodge his fate, and Rimmer is delighted to find out he won't have to share the ship for much longer.

Spoilers from here on. Who really dies, and the twins.

Not Lister after all

Lister tries to stop the Cat's tooth from getting broken and ends up knocking it out himself, which is the episode's first hint that the echoes always come true. When he repairs the navicomp with no explosion at all, he thinks he has beaten fate. Then an elderly Lister, with a robotic arm, turns up to explain what Rimmer actually saw. The man killed in the blast was one of Lister's twin sons, Bexley.

Holly explains that the echoes creep closer to the present as the ship slows, and the final one shows a future Lister carrying two newborn babies. So the last human alive is somehow going to be a father. The episode treats the son's death lightly, and the writers later felt so too: when they adapted it for the novel Infinity Welcomes Careful Drivers, they made the victim Lister's grandson instead, uneasy about how casually Lister takes the death of his own son.

Behind the scenes

  • It was recorded on October 18, 1987, at BBC Manchester, as the fourth episode made. The team liked it so much they moved it to second in the running order.
  • The writers found it very hard to write and the script confused a lot of people, reportedly including director Ed Bye. Naylor often had to remind the cast what was going on, and a spoken introduction by Holly was added to each episode to remind viewers of the premise.
  • Scenes with two of the same character were done with split-screen: Craig Charles played to an empty space, and Chris Barrie was filmed separately and combined with him.
  • The skutters were built from things like shoe boxes and radio-controlled car engines. Radios from a nearby taxi firm interfered with them; one poked Craig Charles in the eye, and another went for Chris Barrie's groin.
  • In a 1992 Red Dwarf Smegazine readers' poll it came second among the first series' episodes, behind "The End," though only 24th of 30 overall.
  • The older Lister's robotic arm wasn't planned as a setup, but the official site notes it foreshadows Lister losing his right arm in Series VII's "Epideme."

The thread

Seeing the future, and trying to argue with it.

Came before

Special relativityAlbert Einstein · theory · 1905 · the time dilation the episode plays with

Shares DNA with

Left its mark on

DNA strand

Time Loops & Timelines

The rule here is simple: what you see in an echo will happen, and trying to stop it only makes it happen. The episode gets its laughs from Lister trying anyway and its sting from finding out what he misread.

Every great sci-fi story is built from a handful of strands like this one. Each strand page explains how it works and traces it across shows, books and films.

Also in this strand:"Cause and Effect""Nick of Time"Explore this strand →

If this one stayed with you

Where to go next, and why.

Watch · TNG S5

"Cause and Effect"

The Enterprise crew get flashes of things they shouldn't know yet. It plays the same kind of puzzle completely straight.

Watch · Film

Arrival (2016)

Another story about time behaving strangely and a person deciding how to live with it, with far more tears and no skutters.

Read · Novel

Slaughterhouse-Five — Kurt Vonnegut

Billy Pilgrim comes unstuck in time and knows how everything ends. It's funny and sad in roughly the proportions Red Dwarf aims for.

Sources