Black Mirror / Series 6 / Episode 3

Beyond the Sea

In an alternate 1969, two astronauts on a six-year mission can beam their minds home into robot copies of themselves. When one of them loses everything, the other lends him his.

  • Released Jun 15, 2023 · Netflix
  • Directed by John Crowley
  • Written by Charlie Brooker
  • Starring Aaron Paul, Josh Hartnett and Kate Mara
Still from Black Mirror, "Beyond the Sea"
Still from Black Mirror, "Beyond the Sea"
Image via TMDB · 1 of 4
Black Mirror, "Beyond the Sea" (Netflix, 2023). Image via TMDB.

More from the episode

The story in 5 beats

  1. Two years in

    Cliff and David are two years into a six-year mission. Off duty, they send their minds down to replicas of themselves on Earth, with their families.

  2. Home invasion

    A cult that hates the replicas breaks into David's house. His family is killed and his replica destroyed, leaving him stuck on the ship.

  3. Borrowing Cliff

    Worried about David, and urged on by his wife Lana, Cliff lets him use his own replica, an hour a week, to walk and paint.

  4. LanaSpoiler · tap to reveal

    David, in Cliff's body, falls for Lana. She turns him down. Cliff finds out and the arrangement ends badly.

  5. The alertSpoiler · tap to reveal

    A fault calls Cliff out on a spacewalk. When he links back to his replica at home, there's blood on his hands.

Why it still matters

Charlie Brooker wrote this during the pandemic, and a producer called it his "pandemic episode." He agreed, with a caveat: "not in the way you might think." Two men share a cramped ship for years while their real lives go on at home, and they can only touch those lives through a stand-in body. Under the 1960s space adventure is a story about working from home, and about what loneliness and isolation do to people.

The retro setting is the hook. Brooker was listening to late-sixties music and asked himself why he couldn't set it in 1969, so the technology sits in a world with no mobile phones and very settled ideas about husbands and wives. At 80 minutes it's long and slow, and deliberately so. John Crowley called it "like a Greek tragedy." Aaron Paul has to play two men in one body, and Crowley didn't want an impersonation. Watch how Paul changes when it isn't Cliff inside.

Spoilers from here on. The last scene is a single gesture. Here's what it means.

Join me

The alert was fake. While Cliff was outside the ship, David took over Cliff's replica and killed Lana and her son. Cliff comes back to his body on Earth covered in blood, with his family dead around him. Back on the ship, David is waiting. He says nothing; he just pulls out a chair for Cliff to sit in.

Brooker called that wordless chair "one of the biggest and deepest trap doors we've had," and summed it up as "Join me in hell." David has evened the score: now both men have lost everything, and they still have years left together in a tin can. Josh Hartnett said Cliff can't take revenge because "revenge on David is revenge on himself," since the ship needs two crew. Kate Mara's guess was blunter: "They're probably going to just kill each other."

Under the sci-fi it's a story about two kinds of 1960s men. Cliff leaves his wife feeling neglected and assumes that's normal. David wants what Cliff has and treats Lana's no as a problem to solve. As Hartnett pointed out, the attack that starts it all echoes the Manson murders of the same year, and the episode ends with that violence brought into another home.

Behind the scenes

  • Brooker's first idea had a family wiped out by a forest fire, a climate-change story. He changed it to violence by other people. The 1969 setting followed "Demon 79," the first series-six episode he wrote, and he drew on the Manson Family's "Helter Skelter" beliefs for the cult.
  • "Sea of Tranquility," the fake TV show that turns up across Black Mirror, was considered as a working title. Books on screen, including The Illustrated Man and Valley of the Dolls, hint at where it's going.
  • Josh Hartnett was offered his part a week before filming began. Aaron Paul had only been heard in the series before, as a voice cameo in "USS Callister." Director John Crowley didn't want Paul's David to be an impersonation, so Paul spent as much time with Hartnett as he could.
  • The ship was built in Twickenham, on the soundstage where the Beatles recorded "Get Back," and drew on NASA's Skylab and 2001: A Space Odyssey. Production designer Udo Kramer made it cramped on purpose, "like a prison." Hartnett, who is 6 foot 3, found it a squeeze.
  • It was shot over three weeks in summer 2022 during the UK heatwave, with Whitstable, Rye and Dungeness standing in for New England. David's California house was a midcentury house in Valencia, Spain, where it rained for three days.
  • Kate Mara was pregnant during the shoot; by the last day it showed, and a small visual effects fix hid it.
  • Several critics, including those at Paste and the i, named it the best episode of series six.

The thread

The real 1969 behind it, the earlier episodes about grief and stand-in bodies, and the doomed ship that came back as an in-joke.

Came before

The Manson Family murders1969 · real event · Hartnett said the attack on David's family mirrors the killing of Sharon Tate that year

Shares DNA with

Left its mark on

DNA strand

Alternate Selves

Here the other self is a body you can lend out, and the episode asks who you are when someone else is wearing your face. A shopkeeper offers condolences to the wrong man, and Lana has to work out which man is inside her husband.

Every great sci-fi story is built from a handful of strands like this one. Each strand page explains how it works and traces it across shows, books and films.

Also in this strand:"White Christmas""USS Callister"Explore this strand →

If this one stayed with you

Where to go next, and why.

Watch · Black Mirror S2

"Be Right Back" (2013)

If David's grief was the part that hurt, this is Black Mirror's quieter story about trying to fill the gap someone left with a machine.

Watch · Film

Moon (2009)

Another long shift far from home, another man alone with his thoughts and his family on a screen. Sam Rockwell carries it nearly single-handed.

Watch · Black Mirror S1

"The Entire History of You" (2011)

A marriage coming apart under jealousy and suspicion, with technology making everything worse.

Read · Short stories

The Illustrated Man — Ray Bradbury

The book Brooker put on screen. Bradbury's stories about rockets, families and the dark side of the space age sit very comfortably beside this one.

Sources