Black Mirror / Series 1 / Episode 3

The Entire History of You

Everyone has an implant that records everything they see and hear, and they can replay any moment. Liam watches his wife laugh at a dinner party, and then he watches it again.

  • Aired Dec 18, 2011 · Channel 4
  • Directed by Brian Welsh
  • Written by Jesse Armstrong
  • Starring Toby Kebbell and Jodie Whittaker
Still from Black Mirror, "The Entire History of You"
Still from Black Mirror, "The Entire History of You"
Image via TMDB · 1 of 4
Black Mirror, "The Entire History of You" (Channel 4, 2011). Image via TMDB.

More from the episode

The story in 5 beats

  1. The appraisal

    Liam leaves a work review and replays it on the way home, over and over, looking for how it went wrong.

  2. Dinner

    At a friend's dinner party, Ffion seems very comfortable with Jonas, a guest Liam has never liked. One woman at the table has no grain at all; hers was cut out and stolen.

  3. The re-do

    At home, Liam replays the evening on the TV. Ffion's account of her history with Jonas shifts every time he asks.

  4. Jonas's houseSpoiler · tap to reveal

    Liam drives over drunk to make Jonas delete his recordings of Ffion. He finds something worse.

  5. The bladeSpoiler · tap to reveal

    Alone in an empty house, Liam watches the old happy memories, then decides he can't live with the machine.

Why it still matters

The gadget is small: a grain behind the ear that records your life, and a little remote to scroll through it. Airport security asks to see your last week. Your partner can ask to see your afternoon. Liam, a lawyer coming home from a bad work review, goes to a dinner party, sees his wife Ffion laughing a bit too easily with an old flame, and that's the whole plot. It isn't about the technology going wrong. It works perfectly. What goes wrong is Liam, who can now rewind a glance forty times until it means what he's afraid it means.

It's the only episode of the first series that Charlie Brooker didn't write. Jesse Armstrong, who co-created Peep Show, pitched it as a story about how much relationships depend on being able to forget things. Critics in 2011 noticed it played less like science fiction than a description of phones and social media, and the grain only looks more familiar every year. Toby Kebbell's performance is the reason it hurts: jealous, funny, pathetic and frightening, sometimes in the same replay.

Spoilers from here on. The ending goes where you fear it will, and further.

What Liam finds

Liam wakes up in his crashed car and replays the night he can barely remember. He beat Jonas and made him delete every recording of Ffion, and in the middle of it he saw one Jonas hadn't deleted: Ffion and Jonas in bed together. He goes home and forces Ffion to admit it, then forces her to play the memory. After a fight with Liam around the time their daughter was conceived, she slept with Jonas.

Some time later, Liam wanders an empty house, replaying memories of Ffion and the baby. Then he takes a razor blade and tweezers and cuts the grain out from behind his ear. The screen goes black. Charlie Brooker has said the moral is that Liam shouldn't have gone looking for something that was only going to hurt him, and that the baby is Liam's. Plenty of viewers still read that last part the other way.

The Question Underneath

Would you want to remember everything exactly as it happened?

Perfect memory gives Liam an endless supply of evidence to worry at, and every replay feeds the suspicion. Forgetting, the episode suggests, is part of how people forgive each other, and a relationship can't breathe when every glance can be rewound. The grain makes Liam's jealousy easier to act on, but the jealousy was already his.

Challenge the DNA

Was the grain the problem, or Liam?

Was the grain the problem, or Liam?
Or skip ahead to our reading

Liam, with a very good shovel. The grain doesn't make him jealous; it just never lets him stop.

Behind the scenes

  • Executive producer Annabel Jones was looking for a satirical writer whose stories "still have meat." Armstrong had been thinking about how fast computer memory was growing, and pitched an idea about the value of being able to forget.
  • The first draft was much bigger. Brooker had suggested side effects of the grain, like people going to the cinema to have affairs because grains are switched off there for copyright reasons. It was cut down to a "domestic bubble."
  • The world was designed for around 2050 with a deliberately mid-century feel. Production designer Joel Collins avoided gadget-shine, and the crew nicknamed the grain's little remote the "pebble."
  • Director Brian Welsh had little industry experience and was recommended by producer Barney Reisz. He gave Kebbell and Whittaker private notes, so neither knew how the other would play a scene.
  • Armstrong kept the film rights. In 2013, Robert Downey Jr. and George Clooney were both reported to be bidding, and Downey's company Team Downey got the option. By 2018 Armstrong said it was stuck in development hell.

The thread

Older stories about the cost of a perfect memory, and the devices that made this one feel like next year.

Came before

"Funes the Memorious" — Jorge Luis Borgesshort story · 1942 · a man who can't forget anything, and is crushed by it

Shares DNA with

Left its mark on

Google Glass2013 · critics reached for this episode when camera glasses arrived

DNA strand

Memory & Identity

This strand usually worries about losing memories. "The Entire History of You" worries about keeping all of them. Liam's problem is that nothing ever fades, so every doubt can be replayed until it hardens into proof, and a marriage that survived on forgetting has nothing to stand on.

Every great sci-fi story is built from a handful of strands like this one. Each strand page explains how it works and traces it across shows, books and films.

Also in this strand:"Be Right Back""The Inner Light"Explore this strand →

If this one stayed with you

Where to go next, and why.

Watch · Film

Eternal Sunshine of the Spotless Mind (2004)

A couple erase each other from memory. It's the mirror image of the grain, and a lot kinder about what memory is for.

Read · Short story

"The Truth of Fact, the Truth of Feeling" — Ted Chiang

Lifelogs that let you search your past, told alongside a story about the arrival of writing. It asks the same question as the episode and gives a more hopeful answer.

Watch · Film

The Conversation (1974)

Gene Hackman replays one recorded conversation until he no longer knows what he heard. The analog ancestor of Liam's re-dos.

Your next episode

Three directions to go from here, all on Sci-Fi DNA.

Still from Black Mirror, "Be Right Back"

More of this feeling

Be Right Back

Black Mirror

Another quiet Black Mirror about love, loss and what gets recorded.

Still from Star Trek: The Next Generation, "The Inner Light"

Same question, different answer

The Inner Light

Star Trek: The Next Generation

What are memories worth? Picard gets a whole lifetime of them, and a gentler answer.

Still from Star Trek, "The Trouble with Tribbles"

Something completely different

The Trouble with Tribbles

Star Trek

After that, something with no marriages in it. Kirk versus fur.

Sources