Black Mirror / Series 3 / Episode 4

San Junipero

Two women meet in a beach town in 1987 and keep finding each other in other decades. Black Mirror's famous exception: a love story that ends well.

  • Released Oct 21, 2016 · Netflix
  • Directed by Owen Harris
  • Written by Charlie Brooker
  • Starring Gugu Mbatha-Raw and Mackenzie Davis
Still from Black Mirror, "San Junipero"
Still from Black Mirror, "San Junipero"
Image via TMDB · 1 of 4
Black Mirror, "San Junipero" (Netflix, 2016). Image via TMDB.

More from the episode

The story in 5 beats

  1. 1987

    Shy Yorkie wanders into Tucker's, a club full of arcade games. Kelly, who is having a great time, decides to talk to her.

  2. Midnight

    They spend a night together at Kelly's beach house. At midnight, Kelly is gone.

  3. Other decades

    Yorkie looks for her week after week, in the 1980s, the '90s, the 2000s, and finally finds her.

  4. Where they really areSpoiler · tap to reveal

    San Junipero is a simulation. The old and the dying visit for a few hours a week, and the dead can stay for good.

  5. Heaven Is a Place on EarthSpoiler · tap to reveal

    Kelly chooses to stay. They drive off together, and the camera pulls back to a hall of blinking servers.

Why it still matters

For its first two series, Black Mirror was the show where the technology always wins and the people always lose. Then, for its move to Netflix, Charlie Brooker wrote a romance. Yorkie is shy, wears glasses and has never danced. Kelly is loud, funny and in no hurry to get attached. They meet at a club called Tucker's in a sunny town called San Junipero, and the episode keeps you wondering why the town only seems to exist on Saturday nights, and why each visit lands in a different decade.

It was the first script Brooker wrote for the series, in four days, and it surprised almost everyone. It won two Emmys, Outstanding Television Movie and the writing award, and was widely called the best episode of 2016. A lot of that comes from Gugu Mbatha-Raw and Mackenzie Davis, who play two people with very good reasons not to fall in love and do it anyway.

Spoilers from here on. The reveal lands best if you don't know it's coming. Watch it first.

What San Junipero is

San Junipero is a simulated town. Elderly people can visit for a few hours a week in younger bodies, and people who have died can have their minds uploaded and live there permanently. In the real world, Yorkie was paralyzed in a car crash at 21, right after coming out to her parents, and has been in a hospital bed for 40 years. Kelly is old and dying, and she has decided not to upload, because her husband refused it after their daughter died. Kelly marries Yorkie so she can sign the consent for Yorkie's euthanasia, and Yorkie moves in for good. After a fight, and a lot of thought, Kelly chooses to join her. The final shot leaves both of them in a building full of servers, dancing to Belinda Carlisle.

The Question Underneath

If you could live any decade again, which would you pick, and who would you want there?

Yorkie and Kelly want different things from San Junipero. One wants the life she never got to have; the other is wary of a heaven that might feel like nothing after a while. The episode doesn't settle whether forever in a simulation is paradise or a very nice waiting room. It settles something smaller and warmer: that choosing it with someone changes what it is.

Challenge the DNA

Is San Junipero heaven?

Is San Junipero heaven?
Or skip ahead to our reading

For Yorkie and Kelly, yes. The last shot of the servers is there so you remember it's also a building someone has to keep running.

Behind the scenes

  • Brooker started from an idea about investigating whether an afterlife exists, then moved to nostalgia therapy, where older people are surrounded by the music and furniture of their youth.
  • His first draft had a man and a woman, and an unhappy ending. He changed both, partly because same-sex marriage wasn't legal in 1987, which gave the story more weight.
  • He set it in California to upend what viewers expected from a British show. It was still filmed outside the U.S. to save money: interiors in London, exteriors in Cape Town, South Africa, over 15 days.
  • An idea for a theme park for the dead was dropped after HBO's Westworld arrived in 2016. A scene in a kindergarten for children who had died was cut as too sad.
  • The songs carry hints. Arcade games with crash and death themes, and the Smiths' "Girlfriend in a Coma" for about five seconds (expensive to license), all point at the twist. Every song they wanted was cleared except one by Prince.
  • Director Owen Harris says he picked 1987 "fairly arbitrarily" and thought of the 1980s as a really optimistic time. He and Brooker pointed to Pretty in Pink and Ferris Bueller's Day Off (both 1986).
  • Yorkie wears the same outfit the whole way through, on purpose, to avoid the cliché of the geek who gets a makeover.

The thread

Where the idea came from, who else has built a heaven out of a machine, and how the show keeps coming back here.

Came before

The Young OnesBBC · TV series · 1982 · one of Brooker's starting points

Shares DNA with

UploadAmazon · TV series · 2020 · a digital afterlife, played for comedy

Left its mark on

DNA strand

Love Beyond Limits

Love stories in sci-fi usually put a barrier between two people: time, distance, death, a body that won't cooperate. San Junipero has all four and treats them as real. Kelly's reluctance has weight: she has a whole marriage behind her and a real reason to say no. The happy ending works because the episode lets her argue against it first.

Every great sci-fi story is built from a handful of strands like this one. Each strand page explains how it works and traces it across shows, books and films.

Also in this strand:"The Inner Light""Hang the DJ"Explore this strand →

If this one stayed with you

Where to go next, and why.

Watch · Black Mirror S4

"Hang the DJ" (2017)

The closest thing Black Mirror has made to a follow-up: two people in a dating system that won't let them stay together, and an ending that rhymes with this one.

Watch · Star Trek: TNG S5

"The Inner Light" (1992)

A whole life lived inside a machine, from 24 years earlier. Sadder, and just as good.

Watch · Film

Her (2013)

A love story where one partner isn't physical at all. If you were moved by Kelly and Yorkie, this asks what happens when the other one can live forever and you can't.

Read · Novel

Permutation City — Greg Egan

The hard-science version of uploading your mind to live forever, with all the questions San Junipero lets you skip.

Your next episode

Three directions to go from here, all on Sci-Fi DNA.

Still from Black Mirror, "Be Right Back"

Same question, different answer

Be Right Back

Black Mirror

Love, loss and technology again, and a very different ending.

Still from The Twilight Zone, "Nightmare at 20,000 Feet"

Something completely different

Nightmare at 20,000 Feet

The Twilight Zone

From a beach party to a window seat over the wing.

On the trail Sci-fi without spaceships (stop 5 of 5).

Sources