
More from the episode
The story in 5 beats
- The stolen Aurora
The Enterprise chases a stolen space cruiser. Its engines overload, and Scotty beams its six passengers aboard just before it explodes.
- Guests with demands
The group, led by Dr. Sevrin, refuse to cooperate and want to be taken to Eden. Spock wins them over. Chekov recognises Irina, someone from his past.
- A concert and a takeover
McCoy finds Sevrin carries a dangerous bacterium. During a concert, the group free him, seize Auxiliary Control and set course for Eden.
Sound as a weaponSpoiler · tap to reveal
Sevrin knocks out the crew with an ultrasonic broadcast and the group steal a shuttle. Kirk shuts the sound off and follows them down.
Paradise bitesSpoiler · tap to reveal
Eden is lush, and every plant on it is acid. Adam is dead from a poisonous fruit, and Sevrin bites into one himself.
Why it still matters
This is the one with the space hippies, and nearly everyone who has seen it remembers it for that. A band of barefoot dropouts led by the brilliant, unsteady Dr. Sevrin wants out of a Federation they find sterile and over-managed, and they want Kirk's ship to get them to a planet they've only heard about. One of them is the Catullan ambassador's son, and Kirk treats the whole group as guests. Spock, to the crew's surprise, speaks their language.
It is usually listed among the weakest episodes of the original series, and the reviews aren't kind. Still, Zack Handlen of The A.V. Club, who gave it a C-minus, pointed out that it lets a dissenting voice argue against Star Trek's tidy utopia, which the show rarely did. Watching it now, you get a 1969 network's idea of the counterculture, with all the costumes and slogans that implies.
The other reason to watch is Charles Napier as Adam, the group's musician, in his first guest role. The songs are exactly as dated as you'd expect, and TVLine still put the sickbay concert among Star Trek's twenty best moments. Den of Geek called it the best of the "best worst" episodes, which sounds about right.
The garden that burns
Eden turns out to be exactly as beautiful as promised, and lethal. Chekov learns it the hard way when he touches a flower: the plants secrete a powerful acid. The search party find Adam dead after eating a poisonous fruit, and the survivors huddled in the shuttle with burned feet. Sevrin, who has staked everything on this place cleansing him, refuses to leave, bites into a fruit and dies.
Back aboard, the episode doesn't gloat. Irina says goodbye to Chekov, and Spock tells the survivors they may yet find their Eden, or make one. That small kindness is the most interesting choice in the script. The scholar Aniko Bodroghkozy notes that the episode has it both ways: the followers are duped by Sevrin and sent home apparently contrite, but they also get to question whether the Federation is really as superior as it thinks.
Behind the scenes
- D. C. Fontana's original script was called "Joanna" and centred on Dr. McCoy's daughter, who would get involved with Kirk. The character became Irina, with Chekov as her foil.
- Arthur Heinemann rewrote the script heavily, and Fontana asked to be credited under the pseudonym Michael Richards, as she also did for "That Which Survives."
- Charles Napier said he got the part of Adam by jumping on a table and singing "The House of the Rising Sun" at his audition. It was his first guest role.
- Deborah Downey, who plays one of the group, wrote much of the music with Napier, and Heinemann wrote lyrics.
- Napier came back to the franchise as General Denning in the Deep Space Nine episode "Little Green Men."
- White Zombie sampled dialogue from the episode in "Starface" (1992).
The thread
A search for paradise that goes wrong, from a show that usually assumed paradise had already arrived.
Came before
Shares DNA with
Left its mark on
DNA strand
Be Careful What You Wish For
The group want a place with no rules and no Federation, and they get one. What makes it work is that the episode keeps some sympathy for the dream even after the garden turns on them.
Every great sci-fi story is built from a handful of strands like this one. Each strand page explains how it works and traces it across shows, books and films.
If this one stayed with you
Where to go next, and why.
Watch · Star Trek S1
"This Side of Paradise" (1967)
If you're in the mood for another planet that seems too good to be true, this is the original series doing that idea with more heart.
Watch · Star Trek S2
"The Apple" (1967)
Another garden world the Enterprise doesn't quite trust, with Kirk once again arguing for the messy option over the comfortable one.
Read · Book
The Electric Kool-Aid Acid Test — Tom Wolfe
A charismatic leader and a band of seekers on the road, from real life. Wolfe's account is a lot stranger than anything NBC put on screen.

