
More from the episode
The story in 5 beats
- Paradise, apparently
Kirk's landing party beams down to a lush, mild planet. Within minutes a crewman is killed by a plant that shoots poisoned thorns.
- Trapped
An energy field drains the Enterprise's power and knocks out the transporter. A beam from the planet has the ship in its grip.
- The Feeders of Vaal
Akuta, the villagers' leader, takes his orders from Vaal, a dragon-headed rock that the people keep fed.
- Forbidden things
Chekov and Yeoman Landon kiss, two young villagers copy them, and Vaal decides the strangers have to die.
Starving the godSpoiler · tap to reveal
Kirk keeps the villagers from feeding Vaal, then orders the Enterprise to fire on it.
Why it still matters
If you've ever heard someone joke about the guy in the red shirt not making it home, this is one of the episodes they mean. Four security men die on Gamma Trianguli VI, to thorns, lightning, an exploding rock and the villagers' attack, and Reactor's rewatch counts it among the episodes that codified the redshirt habit.
Underneath the body count is a question the show kept returning to. The people of the planet, the Feeders of Vaal, stay young and healthy and never have to grow their own food. They also never have children, never touch each other and do whatever the machine says. Kirk thinks that's no way to live. Spock isn't so sure they have any right to change it.
The episode doesn't settle the argument, and critics have been arguing with it since. The A.V. Club's Zack Handlen felt it never deals with how the villagers will cope without Vaal. Watch it for that debate, and for a young David Soul, under red body paint and a wig, eight years before Starsky & Hutch.
Out of the garden
Kirk's party keeps the villagers away from Vaal, so it can't be fed. Weakened, it can't hold off the Enterprise's phasers, and it overloads and goes dark. The tractor beam lets go and the ship is saved.
Akuta is devastated, and Kirk tells him his people will now learn to grow their own food and make their own choices. Spock points out that they've just repeated the story of Eden, expelling a people from paradise, and Kirk turns it into a joke about which of them looks more like Satan. The episode treats it as a happy ending. Whether it is depends on how much you trust people to manage on their own.
Behind the scenes
- "The Apple" was Max Ehrlich's only Star Trek script, and producer Gene L. Coon rewrote it without credit.
- The script had the Enterprise separate its saucer section, but that was too expensive to film. Saucer separation finally appeared with the Enterprise-D in The Next Generation.
- Celeste Yarnall's Yeoman Landon wore Grace Lee Whitney's old costume, refitted for her.
- David Soul, who plays Makora, was making only his third screen appearance. SlashFilm called the Vaalians' make-up "a little hokey."
- Reactor's rewatch gave it a warp factor rating of 3 out of 10, finding it too close to "The Return of the Archons."
The thread
Gardens with a catch, computers that play god, and the crew's habit of pulling the plug.
Came before
Shares DNA with
Left its mark on
DNA strand
The State Knows Best
Vaal is a benevolent dictator. It keeps everyone healthy and fed and asks only obedience, plus no sex and no questions. The episode plainly sides with Kirk, but it lets Spock raise the obvious objection, and that unresolved argument is the reason to watch.
Every great sci-fi story is built from a handful of strands like this one. Each strand page explains how it works and traces it across shows, books and films.
If this one stayed with you
Where to go next, and why.
Watch · Star Trek S1
"The Return of the Archons" (1967)
The earlier, stronger take on a society run by a machine, with a creepier town and a better twist.
Watch · Star Trek S1
"This Side of Paradise" (1967)
If the debate over whether paradise is worth the price interested you, this is the version where the crew is tempted too.
Read · Short story
"The Machine Stops" by E.M. Forster (1909)
A century-old story about people who let a machine run every part of their lives, and what happens when it falters.


