Star Trek / Season 3 / Episode 19

Requiem for Methuselah

Hunting a cure for a fever aboard ship, Kirk, Spock and McCoy meet a recluse whose house is full of masterpieces that look brand new. Then Kirk meets his ward.

  • Aired Feb 14, 1969 · NBC
  • Directed by Murray Golden
  • Written by Jerome Bixby
  • Guest starring James Daly and Louise Sorel
Still from Star Trek, "Requiem for Methuselah"
Still from Star Trek, "Requiem for Methuselah"
Image via TMDB
Star Trek, "Requiem for Methuselah" (NBC, 1969). Image via TMDB.

The story in 5 beats

  1. Fever on board

    Rigellian fever is spreading through the Enterprise. Kirk, Spock and McCoy beam down to a planet that has the mineral to cure it.

  2. Flint

    A flying robot attacks, and its owner calls it off. Flint wants them gone, but agrees to let them gather what they need.

  3. The collection

    Flint's home is full of art that matches Leonardo's brushwork, on modern canvas. His ward Rayna plays billiards with Kirk and dances while Spock plays a waltz.

  4. Six thousand yearsSpoiler · tap to reveal

    Spock's tricorder says Flint is more than 6,000 years old. He has been a lot of people.

  5. A room full of RaynasSpoiler · tap to reveal

    Spock finds a lab with several unfinished bodies labeled "Rayna." Flint's ward is his creation, and Kirk has been her teacher.

Why it still matters

Jerome Bixby's last script for the series is a strange, romantic chamber piece. The crew has Rigellian fever, and the only cure is a mineral, ryetalyn, that happens to exist on a planet owned by a man named Flint. He lives with a flying robot, a young ward called Rayna and an art collection that includes paintings with brushwork Spock can only call Leonardo's, on modern canvas. There's also a Brahms waltz in Brahms's own hand that Spock has never heard.

James Daly plays Flint with weary, aristocratic charm, and Louise Sorel's Rayna is bright and curious about everything. You can see why Kirk falls for her, though how fast he falls is harder to buy: Reactor's rewatch finds the love story unconvincing after one game of billiards and one dance, and The A.V. Club called the episode forgettable.

Stay for the last scene anyway, a quiet one for the three leads that nearly didn't happen. DeForest Kelley refused to perform Bixby's original fifteen pages, and the speech he finally gave was rewritten in about five minutes, in Kirk's chair on the bridge set.

Spoilers from here on. Who Flint is, what Rayna is, and the ending.

The man who couldn't die

Flint was born in 3834 BC and found, after a battle, that he couldn't die. Over the centuries he has been Methuselah, Solomon, Alexander the Great, Lazarus, Leonardo da Vinci and Brahms. He built Rayna to be his immortal companion, and he has used Kirk's visit to teach her how to love. To keep his secret, he shrinks the Enterprise to a model on his table, crew frozen inside. When Rayna objects, he restores it.

Kirk and Flint fight over her until Rayna insists on choosing for herself. Overwhelmed by the choice, she can't make it, and it kills her. Back on board, McCoy reports that Flint has been aging normally since he left Earth's environment and will soon die like anyone else. McCoy talks to Spock about love, and about how little Spock understands it. Then, as Kirk sleeps at his desk, Spock melds with his mind and suggests that he forget.

Behind the scenes

  • Jerome Bixby wrote about 15 pages for the final scene, a McCoy speech to Spock about love that he said was inspired by T. S. Eliot. DeForest Kelley refused to say it. When director Murray Golden asked for part of it back, Bixby rewrote it in about five minutes, sitting in Kirk's chair on the bridge set.
  • Rayna's surname, Kapec, is a nod to Karel Čapek, whose 1920 play R.U.R. introduced the word "robot."
  • It was the last of Bixby's four original-series scripts. His final work, the 2007 film The Man from Earth, is also about a man who doesn't age.
  • It was Murray Golden's only Star Trek episode as director.
  • The original broadcast reused the matte painting of Rigel VII from the pilot "The Cage" for Flint's home. The 2006 remaster replaced it with a palace with an observation tower.
  • The repeat on September 2, 1969, was the last network telecast of the series on NBC; syndication began the following Monday.

The thread

A Shakespearean island story with a robot at its heart, written by a man who kept coming back to immortality.

Came before

Shares DNA with

Left its mark on

"Concerning Flight"Star Trek: Voyager · refers back to Kirk's claim to have met Leonardo

DNA strand

Do Machines Dream?

Rayna was built to love one man and is taught to feel by another, and what she feels turns out to be more than she can survive. The episode treats her inner life as real, so the ending plays as a death, with Kirk left to grieve her.

Every great sci-fi story is built from a handful of strands like this one. Each strand page explains how it works and traces it across shows, books and films.

Also in this strand:"What Are Little Girls Made Of?""The Measure of a Man"Explore this strand →

If this one stayed with you

Where to go next, and why.

Watch · Film

The Man from Earth

If Flint's story got to you, this is Bixby returning to the same question nearly four decades later: a quiet, talky film about a man who may have lived for millennia.

Watch · The Twilight Zone

"Long Live Walter Jameson"

Another man who has lived far longer than he should, and the people who get hurt when they love him. It's a small, sad story told mostly in one room.

Watch · Film

Forbidden Planet

The recluse on a remote planet, the young woman in his care, the robot servant and the visiting captain will all look familiar.

Read · Play

The Tempest, by William Shakespeare

The island, the old magician and the daughter who has never met another man. Ruth Morse is one of the scholars who sees Flint in Prospero.

Sources