Star Trek / Season 3 / Episode 21

The Cloud Minders

On Ardana, the rulers live in a city floating above the clouds and the miners who keep it running live in the dirt below. Kirk needs their ore, and the miners have stopped digging.

  • Aired Feb 28, 1969 · NBC
  • Directed by Jud Taylor
  • Teleplay by Margaret Armen, from a story by David Gerrold and Oliver Crawford
  • Guest starring Jeff Corey, Diana Ewing and Charlene Polite
Still from Star Trek, "The Cloud Minders"
Still from Star Trek, "The Cloud Minders"
Image via TMDB
Star Trek, "The Cloud Minders" (NBC, 1969). Image via TMDB.

The story in 5 beats

  1. Ambush at the mines

    Kirk and Spock beam down to collect zenite and are jumped by miners. High Advisor Plasus drives them off and invites the officers up to Stratos.

  2. The city in the clouds

    Stratos is all art and leisure. Spock is taken with Plasus's daughter Droxine, until she explains how little she thinks of the Troglytes.

  3. Vanna and the rays

    Vanna, the Disrupters' leader, tries to take Kirk hostage. Plasus has her interrogated with painful rays and orders Kirk and Spock off Stratos.

  4. The gas in the oreSpoiler · tap to reveal

    McCoy finds raw zenite gives off a gas that dulls the mind and heightens emotion. Plasus refuses Kirk's offer of filter masks.

  5. Down the mineSpoiler · tap to reveal

    Kirk breaks Vanna out, is betrayed, then collapses the mine and beams Plasus down to dig beside them.

Why it still matters

The image everyone remembers is Stratos, a gleaming city hanging in the sky, home to artists and thinkers who never touch the ground. Below it, the Troglytes dig zenite in the mines, and a group of them, the Disrupters, have started fighting back. The Enterprise needs a shipment of zenite fast, because another planet, Merak II, needs it to stop a plague killing its plant life, so Kirk can't simply take a side and leave.

This is the original series doing class politics out in the open. David Mack, writing for Tor.com's rewatch, pointed out its debt to Fritz Lang's Metropolis, with workers below and a privileged elite above. Spock gets to fall a little for Droxine, the High Advisor's daughter, and then watch her elitism cool him off, and his voice-over sums up the planet's system in one line: "It is not a wise leadership."

Look out for Jeff Corey as High Advisor Plasus, a man who is entirely reasonable until anyone questions him, and Charlene Polite as Vanna, the Disrupters' leader, who is nobody's fool. The A.V. Club's Zack Handlen gave it a C-plus, saying it had enough story not to drag, though he felt it lost its nerve at the end.

Spoilers from here on. What the zenite gas proves, and how far the ending is willing to go.

The gas that made a class

The Troglytes aren't slower by nature. Raw zenite gives off an odourless, invisible gas that dulls the mind and heightens emotion, and the miners have been breathing it their whole lives. Spock suspects the Troglytes who worked up in the city escaped the worst of it, which is how they were able to organise. The gas wears off once the exposure stops, so the whole basis for Stratos's view of the Troglytes turns out to be a matter of where they were made to work.

Kirk proves it the hard way. Trapped in a collapsed mine with Vanna and a beamed-down Plasus, both men breathe the gas, grow irritable and end up brawling, while Vanna finally believes Kirk and calls the Enterprise. The zenite is delivered in time, Plasus grudgingly lets the filter masks be handed out, and Vanna says her people's struggle for equality will go on. David Mack called that resolution a cop-out in Tor.com's rewatch, and Handlen felt the episode backed away from its own argument.

Behind the scenes

  • The story began with David Gerrold's 40-page treatment "Castles in the Sky," set on a planet called Aronis where floating cities were kept aloft by dilithium mined by the people below.
  • In earlier drafts the sky city was called G'aela, then Strato, before it became Stratos. Vanna was briefly named Varga.
  • The Stratos model was reportedly carved from foam and shown as an optical effect, matted with clouds and combined with a separate shot of Kirk and Spock.
  • The view of Ardana's surface is a 1965 Gemini IV photograph of the Hadramawt Plateau in Yemen, cropped, recoloured and given animated clouds.
  • Manny Coto, showrunner of Star Trek: Enterprise, said he had wanted to set an episode of that show's fourth season on Stratos.

The thread

A city for the few, built on the backs of the many, and the long tradition of stories that put the rich upstairs.

Came before

Shares DNA with

DNA strand

Us vs. Them

Stratos has built a whole philosophy on the idea that the Troglytes are simply lesser. The episode's science fiction is the gas, which turns that prejudice into something you can measure and fix. Kirk has to breathe it himself before anyone believes him.

Every great sci-fi story is built from a handful of strands like this one. Each strand page explains how it works and traces it across shows, books and films.

Also in this strand:MetropolisThe Time Machine"The Devil in the Dark"Explore this strand →

If this one stayed with you

Where to go next, and why.

Watch · Film

Metropolis (1927)

The silent-film blueprint for a gleaming city above and workers below. If Stratos caught your eye, here's where that look comes from.

Read · Novel

The Time Machine — H. G. Wells

Wells imagined humanity split into a comfortable upper world and a laboring underground one, and followed the idea a very long way.

Watch · Star Trek S1

"The Devil in the Dark" (1967)

Another mining colony where Kirk has to work out what the people underground actually want, and the original series at its most generous.

Watch · Film

Elysium (2013)

The same split, updated: the wealthy orbit above a worn-out Earth, and the people below want in.

Sources