
The story in 5 beats
- Lincoln on the viewscreen
Surveying a lava planet, the Enterprise finds Abraham Lincoln drifting in space. Kirk gives him full presidential honours and beams him aboard.
- Meeting Surak
Lincoln leads Kirk and Spock to an Earth-like patch of the surface, where their phasers and tricorder fail to arrive. Waiting there is Surak.
- Yarnek's experiment
A rock creature, Yarnek, sets four "good" figures against four "evil" ones, including Kahless, Genghis Khan and Colonel Green, to fight to the death.
The price of peaceSpoiler · tap to reveal
Green's offer of a truce is an ambush. Surak goes alone to negotiate and is killed, and Lincoln falls trying to free him.
Two against fourSpoiler · tap to reveal
Kirk and Spock fight on alone. Kirk kills Kahless and Green, and the rest flee.
Why it still matters
The opening is one of the oddest in the series. The Enterprise is surveying Excalbia, a molten planet that shouldn't support life, when a figure looking exactly like Abraham Lincoln drifts toward the ship and asks permission to come aboard. Kirk gives him full presidential honours. Spock is polite and doubtful. Lincoln, a man of the 1860s, somehow knows a Vulcan word.
What follows is a staged contest, set up by the planet's rock-like inhabitants, between figures from history and legend. The episode matters mostly for who it introduced. Surak, the father of Vulcan civilization, and Kahless, a central figure in Klingon history, both appear for the first time here, and later series built a lot on both of them. Barry Atwater's calm, still Surak is the best thing in it.
Keith R.A. DeCandido, in his Tor.com rewatch, called it a weaker rerun of "Arena" and criticised its handling of Genghis Khan, and lists of the worst episodes have not been kind either. It's still worth seeing for Lee Bergere's gentle Lincoln and for the first look at two characters the franchise would spend decades returning to.
What they fight for
Yarnek also tampers with the Enterprise's matter/antimatter containment, giving Kirk four hours to win or lose his ship. Surak tries the Vulcan way and goes alone to talk peace. He is killed, and Green's side lures the others in by imitating his cries for help. Lincoln slips round to free him, finds the body, and is mortally wounded, warning Kirk and Spock before he dies. Kirk and Spock, now outnumbered, fight on, and Kirk kills Kahless and Green.
Yarnek declares the experiment over and concludes that good and evil are no different, since both fight the same way. Kirk disagrees: what matters is what each side is fighting for. Back aboard, Spock suggests the Excalbians built their Lincoln and Surak from the crew's own ideas of them, and Kirk remarks that the Enterprise might be carrying on their work.
Behind the scenes
- Mark Lenard was originally set to play Lincoln but was busy filming Here Come the Brides.
- Yarnek was played physically by Janos Prohaska and voiced by Bart LaRue.
- Surak returned in Star Trek: Enterprise ("Awakening" and "Kir'Shara"), played by Bruce Gray. A clone of Kahless appears in The Next Generation's "Rightful Heir," played by Kevin Conway.
- Colonel Green came back too, in Enterprise's "Demons," played by Steve Rankin.
- Colonel Green's costume is thought to have been reused for Mork's red spacesuit in Happy Days and Mork & Mindy.
The thread
A contest between good and evil staged by aliens, and the start of two legends the franchise kept coming back to.
Came before
Shares DNA with
Surak and Kahless return
DNA strand
Us vs. Them
Yarnek wants to know which side is stronger, good or evil, and builds both teams to find out. The episode's answer is that both sides fight the same way once the fighting starts, and what separates them is why they fight. Surak walking in unarmed is the clearest picture of that.
Every great sci-fi story is built from a handful of strands like this one. Each strand page explains how it works and traces it across shows, books and films.
If this one stayed with you
Where to go next, and why.
Watch · Star Trek S1
"Arena" (1967)
The earlier and better version of an alien-staged fight, with Kirk alone against the Gorn and a final choice that matters.
Watch · TNG S6
"Rightful Heir" (1993)
If you wanted more of Kahless, this is where the Klingon legend comes back, and the question becomes whether it matters if he's real.
Read · Novel
To Your Scattered Bodies Go — Philip José Farmer
Everyone who ever lived wakes up on the banks of an endless river, Richard Burton among them. A much bigger take on putting history's famous names in one place.