Star Trek / Season 3 / Episode 23

All Our Yesterdays

A planet's sun is hours from going nova, and its whole population has vanished into its own past. Kirk, Spock and McCoy follow them in, and end up in two different centuries.

  • Aired Mar 14, 1969 · NBC
  • Directed by Marvin J. Chomsky
  • Written by Jean Lisette Aroeste
  • Guest starring Mariette Hartley and Ian Wolfe
Still from Star Trek, "All Our Yesterdays"
Still from Star Trek, "All Our Yesterdays"
Image via TMDB
Star Trek, "All Our Yesterdays" (NBC, 1969). Image via TMDB.

The story in 5 beats

  1. An empty planet

    With Sarpeidon's sun hours from going nova, the landing party find only Mr. Atoz and his library of the planet's past, viewed through the Atavachron.

  2. Through the portal

    Kirk hears a woman scream and runs through. He lands in a city like 17th-century England and is jailed as a witch for talking to friends who aren't there.

  3. The ice age

    Spock and McCoy land 5,000 years back, in a frozen wasteland. Zarabeth, an exile living alone in a cave, saves them from the cold.

  4. Spock changesSpoiler · tap to reveal

    Spock grows angry and falls for Zarabeth. McCoy works out that the trip has taken him back toward the emotions of ancient Vulcans.

  5. No way back for herSpoiler · tap to reveal

    Spock and McCoy can only return together, and Zarabeth says she can't return at all. They are beamed up just before the star explodes.

Why it still matters

Sarpeidon's star is about to explode, and the only person left on the planet is a fussy librarian, Mr. Atoz, who runs a time portal called the Atavachron. The people of Sarpeidon have each picked a period from their history and stepped into it to escape. When Kirk hears a woman scream on the other side, he dives through, and Spock and McCoy go after him into a different era entirely.

It's one of the best episodes of a thin third season, and the lists agree: Hollywood.com put it 15th of the 79 original episodes in 2024, and The Hollywood Reporter ranked it 39th across the whole franchise in 2016. The pleasure is in the split. Kirk gets a swashbuckling witch-trial story, while Spock and McCoy are stranded in an ice age, and Leonard Nimoy gets to play a Spock who is slowly coming apart.

Mariette Hartley plays Zarabeth, a woman exiled alone to the ice age, and she brings a lot of feeling to what could have been a stock part. The title comes from Macbeth's "Tomorrow, and tomorrow, and tomorrow" speech, which is about time running out, and the whole episode runs on that clock.

Spoilers from here on. Why Spock changes, and what it costs him to come home.

A Vulcan out of his time

Spock's temper has a cause. The jump 5,000 years back is pushing him toward the behaviour of ancient Vulcans, emotions and all. He snaps at McCoy and falls in love with Zarabeth, and he doesn't notice anything is wrong until McCoy forces him to. Zarabeth, for her part, was sent here as a punishment and admits she doesn't know what a return trip would do to anyone.

Because Spock and McCoy came through together, neither can go back alone, and Zarabeth, by her own account, can't go back at all. Kirk, meanwhile, gets the prosecutor, who turns out to be from the future too, to show him back to the portal, and reaches his friends by communicator. Spock leaves Zarabeth behind, Atoz escapes into his chosen past, and the Enterprise pulls away as the star destroys Sarpeidon.

Behind the scenes

  • The episode grew from Jean Lisette Aroeste's outline "A Handful of Dust." She was a fan of the show with no previous writing credits, and she also wrote "Is There in Truth No Beauty?".
  • The network wouldn't let Zarabeth's navel be shown. Gene Roddenberry later gave Hartley two navels in his pilot Genesis II, saying the network owed him one.
  • Hartley told StarTrek.com that she had never seen the show, and that when she saw the costume, "I thought I was going to die."
  • She also remembered the cave set being lit in red and green, and called Marvin Chomsky "a terrific director, very caring."
  • A. C. Crispin wrote two novels that follow on from it, Yesterday's Son and Time for Yesterday, in which Spock and Zarabeth have a son, Zar.

The thread

A trip into a planet's past that changes the traveller, and a love story that can only happen in another time.

Came before

Shares DNA with

Continued in print

Yesterday's SonA. C. Crispin · novel · picks up the story of Spock and Zarabeth
Time for YesterdayA. C. Crispin · novel · the second sequel

DNA strand

Time Loops & Timelines

The time travel here remakes people to fit where they land, and that gives the episode its sting. Spock's romance is real, but it belongs to a Spock who only exists in that century, and he can't take it home with him.

Every great sci-fi story is built from a handful of strands like this one. Each strand page explains how it works and traces it across shows, books and films.

Also in this strand:"The City on the Edge of Forever""The Inner Light"Explore this strand →

If this one stayed with you

Where to go next, and why.

Watch · Star Trek S1

"The City on the Edge of Forever" (1967)

If the goodbye in the ice age stayed with you, this is the original series' other great story about loving someone in a time you can't stay in.

Watch · TNG S5

"The Inner Light" (1992)

Another doomed planet and another officer who gets a whole other life for a little while.

Read · Novel

Yesterday's Son — A. C. Crispin

For anyone who wanted to know what happened after Spock went home. Crispin's sequel gives Spock and Zarabeth a son.

Sources