
More from the episode
The story in 5 beats
- One guest only
Gideon agrees to diplomatic talks, on one condition: only Captain Kirk may set foot on the planet.
- Nobody home
Kirk beams down and seems to be back on the Enterprise. The crew have vanished, and there's a bruise on his arm he can't explain.
- Odona
A woman turns up who can't remember arriving. Her world is so crowded that empty corridors feel like a miracle to her.
- Red tape
On the real ship, Spock can't find Kirk anywhere. Hodin won't let him beam down to look, and the Federation's bureaucrats tell him to go through channels.
Faces at the windowSpoiler · tap to reveal
Kirk hears noises outside and sees crowds pressed against the viewport. The ship isn't what it seems, and Odona falls ill.
Why it still matters
The opening is one of the best hooks of the third season. Gideon will allow exactly one visitor, Captain Kirk. He beams down to the coordinates he's given and finds himself, apparently, still on board the Enterprise, with not a single crew member in sight. The only other person on the ship is a young woman named Odona, who has no idea how she got there and is thrilled simply to have room to move.
The story came from an actor. Stanley Adams, who played Cyrano Jones in "The Trouble with Tribbles," was worried about overpopulation, and Gene Roddenberry encouraged him to turn that worry into a treatment. It's one of the few times a Trek actor got a writing credit on the show.
Reactor's rewatch notes that the budget-starved third season gives this one little more than empty corridors to look at. What it does have is good chemistry between Kirk and Odona, and David Hurst as Ambassador Hodin, deliberately vague with Spock while the Federation's treaty bureau sends him back through Starfleet channels: a diplomat with something to hide.
A planet that can't die
Kirk never left Gideon. He's in a replica of the Enterprise built on the planet, and the people of Gideon have a problem: they hardly ever die. Their bodies regenerate, which rules out sterilization, and the planet is packed. Kirk's blood carries the virus behind Vegan choriomeningitis, and that disease is what Gideon wants from him.
Odona is Hodin's daughter. She has caught the disease from Kirk's blood on purpose, so that she can carry it to anyone on Gideon willing to volunteer to die. Spock defies orders, beams to Kirk's original coordinates, finds the fake ship and brings Kirk and Odona home, where McCoy cures her. She chooses to go back to Gideon anyway, to supply the virus herself, and Kirk forgives her for the deception.
Behind the scenes
- The story grew from Stanley Adams's concerns about overpopulation. Adams had played Cyrano Jones in "The Trouble with Tribbles," and Gene Roddenberry encouraged him to write a treatment.
- Its basic plot has been compared to C. M. Kornbluth's 1951 short story "The Marching Morons."
- Gene Dynarski, who plays Krodak, had been a miner in "Mudd's Women," and Richard Derr had played a commodore in "The Alternative Factor."
- James Blish's prose adaptation in Star Trek 6 includes a scene not in the episode, where Odona burns off a fingertip and it grows back. Reactor's rewatch suggests it may have been cut for budget reasons.
- Den of Geek ranked it 14th of the original series' "best worst" episodes in 2017.
The thread
A population story with a hall-of-mirrors opening, written by the man who brought the tribbles aboard.
Came before
Shares DNA with
Left its mark on
DNA strand
Is Any of This Real?
For most of the hour, Kirk is in a perfect copy of his own ship, and the episode lets us share his uncertainty. The corridors look right and the controls work, but nothing adds up, and the first real crack comes from something outside the ship.
Every great sci-fi story is built from a handful of strands like this one. Each strand page explains how it works and traces it across shows, books and films.
If this one stayed with you
Where to go next, and why.
Watch · The Twilight Zone
"Where Is Everybody?"
If the empty corridors got under your skin, here's the Twilight Zone version: a man walking through a town where everyone seems to have just stepped out.
Watch · Star Trek
"The Trouble with Tribbles"
See Stanley Adams on the other side of the camera, as the trader whose cute pets have a population problem of their own.
Read · Short story
"The Marching Morons", by C. M. Kornbluth
A much meaner satire about an overcrowded future, written in 1951 and still sharp.
