Star Trek / Season 3 / Episode 17

That Which Survives

A landing party is stranded on a planet that shouldn't exist, the Enterprise is flung far across space, and a calm woman keeps appearing who can kill with a touch.

  • Aired Jan 24, 1969 · NBC
  • Directed by Herb Wallerstein
  • Teleplay by John Meredyth Lucas, from a story by Michael Richards (D. C. Fontana)
  • Guest starring Lee Meriwether
Still from Star Trek, "That Which Survives"
Still from Star Trek, "That Which Survives"
Image via TMDB
Star Trek, "That Which Survives" (NBC, 1969). Image via TMDB.

The story in 5 beats

  1. An impossible planet

    The Enterprise finds a planet the size of the moon, only a few thousand years old, with air and plants it has no business having. Kirk takes a landing party down.

  2. Stranded

    Just after the landing party beams down, a huge quake hits. When it's over, the Enterprise is hundreds of light-years away.

  3. "I am for you"

    Losira appears on the planet and on the ship. She says she is for one person only, and phasers do nothing to her.

  4. Runaway engines

    The engines have been sabotaged and the ship won't stop accelerating. Scotty crawls into a service crawlway to bypass the damage.

  5. The last KalandanSpoiler · tap to reveal

    Inside the rock, the landing party finds a computer and a message from the real Losira, explaining whom she was protecting the planet for.

Why it still matters

This is a third-season episode that gives everyone something to do. Kirk, McCoy, Sulu and a geologist are stranded on a moon-sized planet only a few thousand years old that somehow has air and plants. Meanwhile Spock and Scotty are on an Enterprise that has been thrown hundreds of light-years away and is racing out of control, and the same visitor keeps turning up in both places.

That visitor is Losira, played by Lee Meriwether, a former Miss America who had played Catwoman in the 1966 Batman film. She's polite, almost regretful, and each time she appears she announces who she is "for." Her touch can kill. StarTrek.com's anniversary piece remembers her as the alien woman who can disappear in a thin vertical line.

Keith R.A. DeCandido's rewatch for Reactor calls it far from great but free of any particular flaws, which in season three counts as a relief, and he likes the mystery on the planet. Watch for Spock at his most pedantic, which the same review thinks tips into self-parody.

Spoilers from here on. Who Losira is, and who she was guarding the planet for.

A guard with nobody left to guard

The planet is artificial, built by the Kalandans as an outpost, and building it released a disease that killed them. The woman who keeps appearing is a projection made by the outpost's computer, modeled on Losira, the last Kalandan there, and set to defend the place. Whatever flung the Enterprise away also left it partly dematerialized and slightly out of phase.

Inside the rock, several Losiras appear at once, each "for" a different person. Kirk has the computer shot, the images vanish, and a recording of the real Losira plays: she was the last of her people on the outpost. The defense outlived everyone it was meant to protect, and the replica's polite, almost regretful manner makes it sad as well as frightening.

Behind the scenes

  • D. C. Fontana wrote the story from her own March 1968 outline, titled "Survival." Unhappy with the rewrites, she took the on-screen pseudonym Michael Richards.
  • In the outline the landing party was Kirk, McCoy, Chekov and a man named Dawson. Sulu took Chekov's place, Dawson became D'Amato just before filming, and the runaway-engine subplot wasn't in the outline at all.
  • Losira began as a taloned energy being, then became "Osira the Thalassan" in the first draft, before turning into Losira the Kalandan.
  • Dr. M'Benga, played by Booker Bradshaw, was added only days before filming. Lt. Rahda was created by combining two male lieutenants from the first draft.
  • The outpost's cube-shaped computer hangs from the ceiling in the episode; the shooting script put it in the middle of the room.
  • It was John Meredyth Lucas's last script for the series.
  • Susan Wright's novel One Small Step, the first book of the Gateways saga, picks up right after this episode.

The thread

Machines that keep doing their job long after the people who built them are gone.

Came before

"There Will Come Soft Rains"Ray Bradbury · short story · 1950 · an automated house that keeps to its daily routine

Shares DNA with

Left its mark on

One Small StepSusan Wright · novel · opens the Gateways saga straight after the episode

DNA strand

Last Person on Earth

Losira is a computer's image of the last Kalandan, still defending an outpost for a people who are all dead. The episode keeps that loneliness at the edges until the final recording.

Every great sci-fi story is built from a handful of strands like this one. Each strand page explains how it works and traces it across shows, books and films.

Also in this strand:"There Will Come Soft Rains""What Are Little Girls Made Of?"Explore this strand →

If this one stayed with you

Where to go next, and why.

Read · Short story

"There Will Come Soft Rains", by Ray Bradbury

If the ending stayed with you, read Bradbury's few pages about an automated house that keeps to its daily routine.

Watch · TNG S1

"The Arsenal of Freedom"

Another away team stuck on a planet, this time up against automated weapons. It's fun to watch the two side by side.

Read · Novel

One Small Step, by Susan Wright

It starts right where the episode stops, for anyone who wants more of the Kalandans.

Sources