
More from the episode
The story in 5 beats
- The obelisk
Kirk, Spock and McCoy beam down to an Earth-like planet in the path of an asteroid and find a strange obelisk near a village.
- Through the floor
Kirk falls through a trapdoor in the obelisk and is knocked out. Spock and McCoy can't find him, and the asteroid can't wait.
- A stranger made chief
Kirk wakes with no memory. He revives a drowned boy, the village takes him for a god, and the priestess Miramanee chooses him.
- Fifty-nine days
Spock's attempt to split the asteroid with phasers wrecks the warp drive. The trip back takes 59 days, with the asteroid four hours behind.
The stormSpoiler · tap to reveal
As storms hit, the village demands that its god open the temple. Kirk can't. They turn on him and on Miramanee.
Why it still matters
Strip away the starship and this is a story about a man who forgets his job and finds out what his life could have been without it. Kirk, who has never had a home that wasn't a bridge, gets a wife, a village and a quiet lake, and the episode gives him long enough with them that you start hoping he can stay. The story covers about two months, which Reactor's rewatch counts as the longest stretch of time of any original-series episode.
It has dated badly in other ways. The planet's people are descended from Native Americans moved there long ago, and the episode makes them a mix of several tribes. Zack Handlen of The A.V. Club gave it a C and called the tribe "Noble Savage style silliness." Watch it as a period piece about Kirk, and as the episode that introduced the Preservers.
It is also a favorite for Kirk's romance. Screen Rant ranked his love story with Miramanee the sixth-best in Star Trek in 2017, and Nerdist put it in a "Best of Kirk" viewing guide.
The Preservers' machine
Spock partly decodes the markings on the obelisk: it's an asteroid deflector, left by an ancient race he calls the Preservers, who moved endangered peoples to safe worlds. The deflector has malfunctioned, and nobody in the village knows how to get inside it. Spock and McCoy arrive in time to drive off the crowd stoning Kirk and Miramanee, Spock mind-melds Kirk's memory back, and Kirk opens the temple by sounding the right tones. Spock activates the deflector with minutes to spare.
The planet is saved and Kirk's new life is not. Miramanee has told him she is pregnant, and McCoy can't save her from her injuries. She dies in Kirk's arms, and the last thing the episode gives us is his grief.
Behind the scenes
- Paramount's daily production reports record filming on its Gower stages on June 11, 17 and 18, 1968, with the planet scenes shot at the Upper Franklin Canyon Reservoir on June 12 to 14.
- Franklin Canyon's lake is the one in the opening titles of The Andy Griffith Show.
- It was the first of five episodes directed by Jud Taylor, who directed more of the third season than anyone else.
- The Preservers are introduced here: an ancient race that moved endangered humanoid peoples to safe worlds. Reactor's rewatch ties the idea to Sargon's account in "Return to Tomorrow" and to the much later TNG episode "The Chase".
- The planet's name, "Amerind," is never spoken in the episode.
- Not everyone loves it: Hollywood.com ranked it 74th of the 79 original-series episodes in 2024, and Wired's binge guide marked it skippable.
The thread
A theory of why the galaxy is full of humans, and a captain who briefly gets to stop being one.
Came before
Shares DNA with
Left its mark on
DNA strand
Memory & Identity
Take away Kirk's memory and you find out what's left: a man who is good with people, quick in a crisis and badly in need of a quiet life. The episode asks which version is the real Kirk, and gives an answer he doesn't like.
Every great sci-fi story is built from a handful of strands like this one. Each strand page explains how it works and traces it across shows, books and films.
If this one stayed with you
Where to go next, and why.
Watch · TNG S5
"The Inner Light"
If Kirk's lost life stayed with you, this is the version that goes all the way: Picard lives out decades somewhere else in the space of an episode.
Watch · Star Trek
"This Side of Paradise"
Another planet that offers the crew an easier, happier life, this time with Spock as the one in no hurry to leave.
Watch · Star Trek
"Return to Tomorrow"
For the other half of the Preservers idea: ancient minds who claim a part in where humanity came from.
Read · Novel
Lost Horizon — James Hilton
The classic story of strangers who stumble into a hidden valley where life is gentler than anything they left behind, and have to decide whether to stay.



