Star Trek: The Next Generation / Season 1 / Episode 21

Symbiosis

Two planets, one medicine. Ornara needs felicium to fight a plague, and Brekka is the only place that makes it. Dr. Crusher starts asking questions about the medicine.

  • First aired Apr 18, 1988 · Syndication
  • Directed by Win Phelps
  • Teleplay by Robert Lewin, Richard Manning and Hans Beimler, from the story by Robert Lewin
  • Guest starring Judson Scott and Merritt Butrick
Still from Star Trek: The Next Generation, "Symbiosis"
Still from Star Trek: The Next Generation, "Symbiosis"
Image via TMDB
Star Trek: The Next Generation, "Symbiosis" (Syndication, 1988). Image via TMDB.

The story in 5 beats

  1. Cargo first

    The freighter Sanction is falling toward a planet. When the Enterprise beams people off, barrels come over before passengers do.

  2. Two worlds, one drug

    Ornara has a plague and the spaceships; Brekka makes the medicine. The Ornarans' ships are old, and nobody on Ornara remembers how to fix them.

  3. Tasha's talk

    Wesley doesn't understand why anyone would take drugs. Tasha tries to explain it to him.

  4. WithdrawalSpoiler · tap to reveal

    The Ornarans fall ill. A dose of felicium makes them better at once, and Crusher can't find any sign of disease.

  5. No spare partsSpoiler · tap to reveal

    Picard can't interfere with either world. He finds a way to let the trade end without saying a word against it.

Why it still matters

The Enterprise rescues four people from a freighter falling into a planet, and they're more worried about the cargo than the crew they just lost. Two are Ornarans, scruffy and desperate. Two are Brekkans, well dressed and calm. The cargo is felicium, the only treatment for a plague on Ornara, and both sides claim it.

This is TNG's drug episode, made in the era of "Just Say No," and it shows. The story itself is sharper than its reputation, about who profits from a medicine and what happens when an outsider has the power to change the deal. The writing around it is less subtle, including a speech producer Maurice Hurley added over the cast's objections. Watch it for Patrick Stewart, and for a Prime Directive decision that is uncomfortable on purpose.

Spoilers from here on. The plague ended a long time ago.

What felicium really is

Felicium did cure the plague, long ago. Since then the Ornarans have been taking an addictive narcotic, and the symptoms they call the plague are withdrawal. The Brekkans know it. Picard and Crusher question them privately, and they admit everything: the plague is gone, the drug is addictive, and Brekka's whole economy would collapse if Ornara stopped needing it. So they keep selling the cure for a disease that doesn't exist.

Crusher wants to help the Ornarans get off the drug. Picard says the Prime Directive forbids it. At Ornara, the Brekkans agree to keep supplying felicium on credit, and then Picard announces that the same Prime Directive means he can't give the Ornarans the spare parts for their freighters. Without working ships there's no trade, and without the trade there's no felicium. Both sides are furious. Afterwards Picard tells Crusher that the Ornarans' withdrawal may give both worlds a chance to move forward in their own ways.

Behind the scenes

  • Co-executive producer Maurice Hurley had worked on Miami Vice, and it shows: the story first had the Enterprise stumble on a drug deal in progress.
  • Hurley added Tasha Yar's "Just Say No"-style speech to Wesley himself, over the cast's objections, and said so later.
  • Director Win Phelps remembered continuity trouble, with characters' motives shifting between scenes. Actors often played scenes from revised pages they hadn't read beforehand.
  • It was filmed after "Skin of Evil," Denise Crosby's last episode as a regular, so this was Denise Crosby's last work as Yar until "Yesterday's Enterprise." As Picard and Crusher leave the cargo bay near the end, you can see her wave goodbye to the camera.
  • Judson Scott and Merritt Butrick both had parts in Star Trek II: The Wrath of Khan; Butrick also played Kirk's son, David Marcus. Butrick died of AIDS less than a year after this episode was made.
  • LeVar Burton later used behind-the-scenes footage from this episode in a Reading Rainbow segment.
  • It earned a 10.8 Nielsen rating, the show's best since February and not beaten until the second-season premiere.

The thread

Dependency as a business, and the outsider who decides whether to step in.

Came before

Miami ViceNBC · TV series · 1984 · Maurice Hurley's work there shaped the episode's drug story

Shares DNA with

Where it turned up next

Reading RainbowPBS · TV series · LeVar Burton used behind-the-scenes footage from this episode

DNA strand

The Cruel Twist

The turn here is quiet: there's no disease, only a habit and a market built around it. Once you know, every earlier scene of desperate Ornarans and patient Brekkans reads differently, and the ending asks whether walking away is cruel or kind.

Every great sci-fi story is built from a handful of strands like this one. Each strand page explains how it works and traces it across shows, books and films.

Also in this strand:"A Private Little War"A Scanner DarklyExplore this strand →

If this one stayed with you

Where to go next, and why.

Read · Novel

A Scanner Darkly — Philip K. Dick

If the business of felicium stayed with you, Dick's novel looks at addiction from the inside, with far more sympathy for the people caught in it.

Watch · Star Trek

"A Private Little War"

The original series faces a similar Prime Directive question, and Kirk's answer makes a good contrast with Picard's.

Watch · TNG S3

"Yesterday's Enterprise"

If you missed Tasha after this, here's where Denise Crosby comes back to the role.

Sources