
More from the episode
The story in 5 beats
- Shuttle down
Troi's shuttle loses power and crashes on Vagra II. She and Lt. Prieto survive, but the transporter can't lock onto them.
- The slick
The away team finds a pool of black oil between them and the shuttle. It rises into a figure and calls itself Armus.
Armus strikesSpoiler · tap to reveal
Without warning, Armus lashes out. Phasers do nothing, and Crusher can't bring the officer back.
Into the oilSpoiler · tap to reveal
A second away team goes down. Armus swallows Riker whole while Troi tries to read it.
Picard aloneSpoiler · tap to reveal
Picard beams down by himself and needles Armus until its rage weakens its own field. Troi and Prieto are pulled out.
Why it still matters
On paper it's a simple rescue. A shuttle bringing Troi home from a conference comes down on Vagra II, she and her pilot are alive, and the transporter can't get a lock. Between the away team and the wreck sits a slick of tar that rises up, gives its name as Armus, and decides to play with them. The story is by Joseph Stefano, who wrote the screenplay for Psycho and produced the first season of The Outer Limits, and you can feel his taste for a monster that's mostly a mood.
Few viewers remember Armus fondly, and critics have been rough on him ever since. The quieter scenes hold up better, starting with a warm little exchange between Yar and Worf near the top of the hour.
It's also one of Troi's better outings. She spends most of the hour trapped in a wreck with an injured pilot, reading a creature that has nothing inside it but grievance, and she's the one who finds out where it came from.
Tasha Yar's death
When Tasha Yar tries to get past the slick to the shuttle, Armus throws her back with a blast and kills her on the spot. There's no heroic last stand and no meaning to it; Armus says he did it to amuse himself, and Troi senses that it didn't even manage that. Gene Roddenberry argued for exactly this: a sudden death that suited a security officer. Denise Crosby had asked to be released from her contract, and this was how the show let her go.
Troi learns what Armus is: everything ugly a species pushed out of itself, given a body and abandoned on Vagra II. Picard works out that its field weakens when it vents its anger instead of bottling it, so he goads it until it screams, and the transporter gets through. He orders the shuttle destroyed from orbit and puts the planet under quarantine. Roddenberry didn't want the creature killed, and it isn't.
Then the memorial. On the holodeck, a recorded message from Yar speaks to each of her crewmates in turn. Afterward Data tells Picard, "I find my thoughts are not for Tasha, but for myself," and asks if he missed the point, and Picard assures him he got it.
Behind the scenes
- Joseph Stefano's story was first called "The Shroud," and Hannah Louise Shearer rewrote it. The first draft killed Yar earlier and made Armus the focus.
- Crosby later called her time on the show "miserable," but said she wouldn't have wanted to leave if she'd had more scenes like the one she shares with Worf early in this episode.
- "Symbiosis" was the last episode Crosby filmed, even though it aired before this one.
- Armus was Mart McChesney in a suit, lowered in and out of the oil. He held his breath under the surface while the crew timed him with a stopwatch, and every suit fell apart over four days on set.
- The memorial was shot twice. Marina Sirtis's tears were real, cued by Crosby standing off camera.
- A stuntman stood in for Jonathan Frakes when Riker is pulled into the oil, and the face rising out of it is a plaster cast of Frakes painted black.
- Keith DeCandido's rewatch called the death "pointless" and said Armus "fails in every possible way as a villain."
The thread
A monster made of everything a species threw away, and a member of the crew who doesn't come home.
Came before
Shares DNA with
Left its mark on
DNA strand
The Cruel Twist
The cruelty is that there's no reason. The show takes away a regular, and Armus has no plan and gets nothing from it. That emptiness is what Yar's death means, and the memorial is the episode's real ending.
Every great sci-fi story is built from a handful of strands like this one. Each strand page explains how it works and traces it across shows, books and films.
If this one stayed with you
Where to go next, and why.
Watch · Star Trek: TNG
"Yesterday's Enterprise"
Crosby's first return to the show, and a very different chance for Yar.
Watch · Film
Psycho (1960)
Joseph Stefano's screenplay. If Armus felt like a horror movie that wandered onto the Enterprise, this is where its writer came from.
Watch · Star Trek
"The Devil in the Dark"
Original-series Trek meets its own monster in the ground and handles it very differently.
Read · Novel
Psycho — Robert Bloch
The novel Stefano adapted for Hitchcock, for anyone who wants to see how he works with someone else's monster.
