Red Dwarf / Series II / Episode 3

Thanks for the Memory

After a drunken party for the anniversary of Rimmer's death, the crew wake up four days later with two broken legs, a finished jigsaw and no idea what happened.

  • Aired Sep 20, 1988 · BBC2
  • Directed by Ed Bye
  • Written by Rob Grant and Doug Naylor
  • Starring Craig Charles and Chris Barrie
Still from Red Dwarf, "Thanks for the Memory"
Still from Red Dwarf, "Thanks for the Memory"
Image via TMDB · 1 of 4
Red Dwarf, "Thanks for the Memory" (BBC2, 1988). Image via TMDB.

More from the episode

The story in 5 beats

  1. Deathday party

    The crew celebrate the anniversary of Rimmer's death. He gets drunk and tells Lister he has never really been loved.

  2. Missing days

    They wake on Thursday, not Sunday. Two broken legs, a finished jigsaw, torn-out diary pages and no black box.

  3. A grave on the moon

    They follow the black box to a barren moon and find it buried under a headstone with a strange inscription.

  4. The black boxSpoiler · tap to reveal

    The recording shows what Lister did for Rimmer, and what happened when Rimmer found out.

  5. Wipe it againSpoiler · tap to reveal

    Lister decides they should all forget, and tidies up the evidence first.

Why it still matters

Half of this episode is a mystery story, and a good one. The crew go to bed on Saturday and wake up on Thursday. Lister and the Cat each have a leg in plaster, Lister's jigsaw has been finished, pages are missing from his diary, Holly's star charts have changed and the ship's black box has gone. The clues lead to a moon, a grave and a giant footprint, and the answer is funnier and sadder than any alien.

The other half is the best argument yet that Rimmer is worth caring about. Drunk at his own deathday party, he tells Lister about the one time he slept with anyone, and admits he'd trade his whole career to be loved and to have been in love. Lister's response sets everything else in motion. Director Ed Bye has called it a standout of the series.

Spoilers from here on. What Lister gave Rimmer.

To the memory of the memory of Lise Yates

Feeling sorry for Rimmer, Lister gave him eight months of his own memories of an old girlfriend, Lise Yates, as a present. Then Rimmer found Lise's letters to Lister, decided she must have dated them both, and worked out the truth from one detail that didn't fit: he remembered having his appendix out twice.

A love he had only borrowed was no good to him. The black box that recorded it all ended up buried on the moon, under a headstone reading "To the memory of the memory of Lise Yates." Having found all this out for a second time, Lister decides they should all erase the last few days again. Before they do, he finishes the jigsaw and tears out the diary pages, so the clues they spent the episode puzzling over were left by the crew themselves.

Behind the scenes

  • Craig Charles shot his scenes in a hurry because his son Jack was being born. He still arrived about twenty minutes late for the birth.
  • Mike Agnew, who stood in for Charles in the spacesuit shots, had bigger feet, and the plaster cast made for Charles didn't fit him. That is why, in some frames, neither Lister nor the Cat is wearing a cast.
  • Sabra Williams, as Lise Yates, is the episode's only guest star. The song Rimmer sings in his dream is the Gershwins' "Someone to Watch Over Me," from the 1926 musical Oh, Kay!
  • The model team used wires to give Blue Midget the jerky motion of Lister flying home drunk.
  • The late-1990s remaster swapped a Felicity Kendal reference for Marilyn Monroe because it had dated. A Jimmy Osmond joke was supposed to go too, but it stayed.
  • The Red Dwarf Programme Guide points out how much "Clues," a Star Trek: The Next Generation episode from about two and a half years later, has in common with it, starting with a crew who wake to lost time and a broken limb.

The thread

Stolen time, borrowed memories and the people who want them gone.

Came before

Shares DNA with

DNA strand

Memory & Identity

The science is one throwaway gadget, a way to move memories from one head to another. The episode uses it to ask whether a love you remember counts if it never happened to you, and Rimmer's answer is no. That's why the ending works as both a punchline and a kindness.

Every great sci-fi story is built from a handful of strands like this one. Each strand page explains how it works and traces it across shows, books and films.

Also in this strand:"The Entire History of You""Lessons"Explore this strand →

If this one stayed with you

Where to go next, and why.

Watch · Film

Eternal Sunshine of the Spotless Mind

A couple who have each other erased. If the headstone on the moon got to you, this is the full-length heartbreak.

Watch · Red Dwarf

"Marooned"

Lister and Rimmer stuck together a year later, swapping stories about their love lives. It picks up the thread this episode starts.

Read · Short story

We Can Remember It for You Wholesale — Philip K. Dick

A man buys memories of a trip he never took. Dick follows the idea somewhere far stranger than a deathday party.

Watch · TNG S4

"Clues"

Watch it after this one and play spot the difference: the Enterprise crew lose a day and start finding things that don't add up.

Sources