
More from the episode
The story in 5 beats
- Abandon ship
Holly detects five black holes ahead. The crew splits up, and Lister gets stuck in Starbug with Rimmer and his lecture on military history.
- Crash
A meteor hits Starbug, and they come down on a frozen planet. Rimmer feels nothing. Lister is freezing and starving.
- Confessions
To take Lister's mind off food, they tell each other how they lost their virginity. Rimmer learns something about Lister he didn't expect.
The guitarSpoiler · tap to reveal
The fire is dying. Rimmer refuses to burn his toy soldiers or his father's wooden chest, and points at Lister's guitar.
GritSpoiler · tap to reveal
The rescue arrives, along with the news that the black holes were never there. Rimmer opens a locker.
Why it still matters
Red Dwarf at its simplest: two men who can't stand each other, one location and a problem. Holly orders everyone off the ship because of approaching black holes. Kryten and the Cat get one shuttle; Lister and Rimmer get Starbug, which promptly crashes on an ice planet. Rimmer is a hologram, so he's fine. Lister has to survive on canned dog food and whatever he can set on fire, and Rimmer's belongings are the best fuel around.
What makes it a favorite is the middle stretch, where the jokes slow down and the two of them actually talk. To get Lister's mind off his stomach, Rimmer gets them swapping stories about losing their virginity, and he learns a side of Lister he never knew. For a few minutes the most annoying man in space is almost kind. Then the episode reminds you exactly who both of them are, with one of the show's great last-minute turns.
The guitar in the locker
When Rimmer suggests burning Lister's guitar, Lister agrees with surprising grace and asks for a minute alone. He cuts a guitar shape out of Rimmer's camphor-wood chest, throws that in the stove and hides the real guitar in a locker. Rimmer, moved by the sacrifice, tells him the chest was the only thing his father ever gave him, and insists on burning his beloved model soldiers in return.
Kryten and the Cat find them after two days. Holly, it turns out, mistook some grit on the scanner for five black holes. As they pack up, Rimmer opens the locker and finds the guitar. The last line is Rimmer asking Kryten for a hacksaw, so he can do to Lister what Alexander the Great once did to him: earlier, Rimmer claimed that in a past life he was Alexander's chief eunuch.
The Question Underneath
What would you be willing to burn to stay alive?
Lister and Rimmer spend the night burning what they say they love and lying about what they've saved. The comedy is in the cheating, and the warmth is in how much of themselves they show while they're at it. Two men who drive each other mad end up swapping their most embarrassing memories, and it's the closest they ever get.
Challenge the DNA
Who made the bigger sacrifice?
Or skip ahead to our reading
Rimmer, without knowing it. Lister's trick is funny, but it's Rimmer's gesture that turns two men who can't stand each other into friends for one night.
Behind the scenes
- The working title was "Men of Honour," for the sacrifices both men make, or seem to.
- The crash used a miniature ice planet filmed on 35mm so the footage could be slowed down. Lister's snowstorm was a real set, with soap powder blown across it by big fans; Kryten and the Cat's icy scenes were done with bluescreen.
- The dog food Craig Charles eats was tuna mixed with meat jelly.
- A strip poker opening was cut and later turned up on the Smeg Outs video.
- The original video release got a 15 certificate because of the virginity story. Chris Barrie has called it one of his all-time favorite episodes, and Grant and Naylor reused part of the plot in their second Red Dwarf novel, Better Than Life.
The thread
Odd couples stranded together, before and after.
Came before
Shares DNA with
Left its mark on
DNA strand
Sci-Fi Played for Laughs
The science fiction here is just the trap: a hologram who can't feel cold and a human who can, on a planet with nothing on it. Everything funny comes from the two people inside the trap, which is why the episode can afford to go quiet in the middle and let the jokes wait.
Every great sci-fi story is built from a handful of strands like this one. Each strand page explains how it works and traces it across shows, books and films.
If this one stayed with you
Where to go next, and why.
Watch · Red Dwarf
"Dimension Jump"
Rimmer again, this time meeting the version of himself everyone loves. If the virginity story made you feel for him, this one finishes the job.
Read · Novel
Better Than Life — Grant Naylor
The second Red Dwarf novel, where the writers folded part of this story into something longer and stranger.
Read · Novel
The Martian — Andy Weir
One man stranded on Mars with limited food and a lot of jokes. Lister would have liked him.
Your next episode
Three directions to go from here, all on Sci-Fi DNA.

More of this feeling
Dimension Jump
Red Dwarf
More Rimmer, more Lister, and a version of Rimmer everyone actually likes.

Same question, different answer
Darmok
Star Trek: The Next Generation
Two people stuck on a planet who have to learn to understand each other, played straight.

Something completely different
The Shelter
The Twilight Zone
From one kind of shelter to another: no jokes, and the neighbors get nasty.

