Red Dwarf / Series II / Episode 2

Better Than Life

Three million years late, the mail arrives, and in it is a game that builds you a world from your deepest wishes. It works beautifully for everyone except Rimmer.

  • Aired Sep 13, 1988 · BBC2
  • Directed by Ed Bye
  • Written by Rob Grant and Doug Naylor
  • Starring Craig Charles and Chris Barrie
Still from Red Dwarf, "Better Than Life"
Still from Red Dwarf, "Better Than Life"
Image via TMDB · 1 of 4
Red Dwarf, "Better Than Life" (BBC2, 1988). Image via TMDB.

More from the episode

The story in 5 beats

  1. The post pod

    Letters, films and newsreels finally reach Red Dwarf, three million years after they were sent.

  2. Bad news from home

    One letter tells Rimmer his father has died. He can't decide what he feels about the man.

  3. Into the game

    Lister and the Cat cheer him up with the pod's best find, a total-immersion game, and the three of them step into paradise.

  4. Rimmer's subconsciousSpoiler · tap to reveal

    Rimmer's mind can't accept good fortune. His dream fills up with debts, a taxman and worse, and it spreads to the others.

  5. Home again?Spoiler · tap to reveal

    They seem to get out. Then the taxman turns up on Red Dwarf.

Why it still matters

Years before anyone owned a VR headset, Red Dwarf imagined a game you play by dreaming. "Better Than Life" reads your brainwaves and builds whatever you want most. For the Cat that's Marilyn Monroe, for Lister it's money, golf and a guitar-shaped waterbed, and for Rimmer it's a real body and an admiral's uniform. The idea proved so useful to the writers that they built most of their second novel around it.

The episode is also where Rimmer gets a family. After the first series, Rob Grant and Doug Naylor decided to fill in his background: three high-flying brothers, a distant mother and a father who drove him hard. The mail brings news about that father, and Rimmer's quiet scene on the observation deck with Lister is one of the first times the show lets him be sad without making it a punchline. Then he carries all of that into a game that runs on whatever is in your head.

Spoilers from here on. Where the game really ends.

Still playing

The game gives Rimmer everything, including a visit from his father, and the old man's insults are enough. Rimmer's sense that he doesn't deserve any of it takes over, and his perfect life collapses into a wrecked one, with a tax collector chasing a huge debt. Because they're all in one shared game, his misery spreads, until the others are in danger too.

They seem to escape, back to Red Dwarf, where Rimmer is told his brain is "messed up" and then gets a letter saying he has passed his astro-navigation exam at last. That's the giveaway: something good has happened to Rimmer. The taxman walks in, and they realise they never left the game. The episode ends there, with all three still trapped; by the next episode they're out.

Behind the scenes

  • It was the first episode of Series II to be recorded, on May 29, 1988 at BBC Manchester, though it went out second.
  • It was also the first time the show filmed several scenes on location: a seaside stretch in Rhyl and Sacha's Hotel in Manchester.
  • The beach was meant to look tropical. It was so cold that the scenes were rewritten and partly reshot on a golf course, which looked just as grey. Ed Bye said the sunshine could be added later; it finally appeared in the late-1990s remaster.
  • John Abineri plays Rimmer's father, Debbie Ash is Marilyn Monroe, Ron Pember is the Taxman and Tony Hawks is the game's guide. Gordon Salkilld plays Gordon, the computer Holly has been playing postal chess with.
  • The Holly and Gordon chess scene was refilmed with a different actor for the remaster. That version wasn't used, and first came out on a later DVD collection.
  • Grant and Naylor built their first two novels on this plot: Infinity Welcomes Careful Drivers ends as the crew enter the game, and most of Better Than Life takes place inside it.

The thread

Perfect worlds that read your mind, and why they go wrong.

Came before

Shares DNA with

Left its mark on

DNA strand

Is Any of This Real?

A shared dream that bends to whoever is most miserable is a neat sci-fi rule, and the episode uses it to show who Rimmer is: a man who can't even enjoy a fantasy. The last scene adds a second layer, the trap of a game that looks exactly like home.

Every great sci-fi story is built from a handful of strands like this one. Each strand page explains how it works and traces it across shows, books and films.

Also in this strand:"Back to Reality""Playtest"Explore this strand →

If this one stayed with you

Where to go next, and why.

Read · Novel

Better Than Life — Grant Naylor

The writers went back to the game and spent most of a novel inside it. If the half hour left you wanting more of the idea, this is the long version.

Watch · Red Dwarf

"Back to Reality"

Four years later the show came back to Rimmer's deepest insecurities, and many fans think it never did it better.

Watch · Film

Inception

Worlds built to order inside sleeping minds, where whatever you're carrying around in your head gets in the way. Rimmer would not do well.

Read · Short story

The Veldt — Ray Bradbury

A nursery that makes whatever the children imagine real. Like Rimmer's game, it shows more about its users than they'd like.

Sources