Black Mirror / Series 2 / Episode 2

White Bear

A woman wakes up with no memory. Outside, strangers silently film her on their phones while masked hunters chase her. Nobody will help, and nobody will say why.

  • Aired Feb 18, 2013 · Channel 4
  • Directed by Carl Tibbetts
  • Written by Charlie Brooker
  • Starring Lenora Crichlow, Tuppence Middleton and Michael Smiley
Still from Black Mirror, "White Bear"
Still from Black Mirror, "White Bear"
Image via TMDB · 1 of 4
Black Mirror, "White Bear" (Channel 4, 2013). Image via TMDB.

More from the episode

The story in 5 beats

  1. Waking

    Victoria comes to in a strange house with no memory. Every screen shows the same strange symbol.

  2. The onlookers

    People in the street film her on their phones and say nothing, while a masked hunter shoots at her.

  3. Jem and Baxter

    Jem says a signal has turned most people into watchers. A man named Baxter offers them a lift, and it goes badly.

  4. The transmitterSpoiler · tap to reveal

    At White Bear, Victoria grabs a shotgun and fires. Confetti comes out. The walls open onto an audience.

  5. TomorrowSpoiler · tap to reveal

    She learns what she did. Then they wipe her memory so the show can run again.

Why it still matters

For half an hour, "White Bear" plays like a zombie film where the zombies only watch. Victoria wakes in a strange house, a symbol flickers on every screen, and the people in the street hold up their phones and record her while a masked man with a shotgun gives chase. A woman named Jem explains that a signal has turned most people into onlookers. They have to reach a transmitter called White Bear.

Then the episode turns on you, and on itself. Brooker called it the show's first major twist, and he rebuilt the script around it in two days. What it leaves you with isn't a puzzle solved. It's an uncomfortable question about who in the story is really cruel, and whether you, watching at home, are one of the crowd.

Spoilers from here on. The last ten minutes recast everything before them, including your own part in it.

White Bear Justice Park

It's all staged. Jem is an actress, Baxter is alive and runs the show, and the silent crowd are paying visitors. Strapped to a chair, Victoria is told who she is: she and her fiancé, Iain Rannoch, abducted and murdered a little girl, Jemima Sykes, and filmed it. After their arrest, Iain killed himself in his cell. Victoria's sentence is White Bear Justice Park, named after Jemima's white teddy bear. Every day she's hunted and humiliated in front of a crowd, and every night her memory of it is erased so she can live it all again.

Over the end credits we watch the next day being set up from the staff's side. Brooker had considered making Victoria innocent and chose to make her guilty and unable to remember it instead, which is far harder to sit with. Reviewers saw the Moors murders behind it, and Brooker pointed to the public appetite for watching figures like Myra Hindley. The episode never tells you what she deserves. It just shows you the people who bought tickets.

The Question Underneath

Why do people film something terrible instead of helping?

The crowd's silent filming is the first clue and the last word. Victoria may have done something unforgivable, but what the park offers its visitors is a show, repeated daily, with a gift shop. The episode leaves you uneasy on both sides. Whether she deserves it matters less to the story than what it does to the people who buy a ticket.

Challenge the DNA

Is White Bear Justice Park justice, or just cruelty with a ticket booth?

Is White Bear Justice Park justice, or just cruelty with a ticket booth?
Or skip ahead to our reading

We lean cruelty. A punishment she forgets every night can't teach her anything. It only teaches the visitors to enjoy it.

Behind the scenes

  • Brooker's first draft was a global apocalypse story with a journalist, inspired by Quatermass and the Pit. A second draft, with a psychiatrist and the glyph, leaned toward The Wicker Man.
  • After "Be Right Back" and "The Waldo Moment," there wasn't much budget left. The episode was shot at RAF Daws Hill, a former US Air Force base with an abandoned housing estate and a chicken-wire fence, which Brooker thought suited a world that isn't real.
  • Brooker rewrote the script in two days, which he described as a "fever dream." The main change was the twist.
  • Victoria's scenes were shot handheld; the credits sequence uses static shots, like a watcher's view.
  • The hunters' look was inspired by the video game Manhunt. Brooker described the episode as a Wicker Man-style horror.
  • The A.V. Club's David Sims called it, by a significant margin, the most disturbing episode of the show, and also the most Twilight Zone-like.
  • About 1.2 million people watched it on Channel 4.

The thread

Crowds that watch, punishments staged as entertainment, and the horror stories Brooker grew it from.

Came before

Shares DNA with

Left its mark on

DNA strand

The Cruel Twist

A cruel twist usually lands on the main character. This one lands on the audience. Once you know what Victoria did, you have to decide how you feel about the crowd, and the episode has quietly made you part of it for half an hour.

Every great sci-fi story is built from a handful of strands like this one. Each strand page explains how it works and traces it across shows, books and films.

Also in this strand:"Black Museum"The Wicker ManExplore this strand →

If this one stayed with you

Where to go next, and why.

Watch · Black Mirror

"Black Museum"

Brooker comes back to punishment as a show, with a museum's worth of horrors.

Watch · Film

The Wicker Man (1973)

The folk-horror classic Brooker had in mind. A stranger, a village that knows something, and an ending you can't shake.

Read · Short story

"The Lottery" — Shirley Jackson

The original story about a crowd that gathers for something terrible and treats it as routine.

Your next episode

Three directions to go from here, all on Sci-Fi DNA.

Still from Black Mirror, "Black Museum"

More of this feeling

Black Museum

Black Mirror

Another Black Mirror where punishment becomes a show, and the visitors are part of it.

Still from Black Mirror, "Hang the DJ"

Something completely different

Hang the DJ

Black Mirror

You'll want something kinder after that. A dating app with a heart.

Sources