The Twilight Zone / Season 1 / Episode 12

What You Need

A little old peddler drifts through a bar handing out small items, and each one turns out to be needed within minutes. A bitter regular decides the old man is his ticket out.

  • First aired Dec 25, 1959 · CBS
  • Directed by Alvin Ganzer
  • Teleplay by Rod Serling, from the story by Lewis Padgett (Henry Kuttner and C. L. Moore)
  • Starring Steve Cochran and Ernest Truex
Still from The Twilight Zone, "What You Need"
Still from The Twilight Zone, "What You Need"
Image via TMDB · 1 of 3
The Twilight Zone, "What You Need" (CBS, 1959). Image via TMDB.

More from the episode

The story in 5 beats

  1. A peddler in the bar

    Pedott works the room, giving a woman a bottle of cleaning fluid and an out-of-work ex-ballplayer a bus ticket to Scranton.

  2. The phone rings

    Moments later the ballplayer gets a call offering him a coaching job in Scranton. The peddler's gift looks real.

  3. Renard wants his share

    Renard demands what he needs. Pedott reluctantly hands him a pair of scissors, and they prove useful sooner than Renard expects.

  4. More, and then moreSpoiler · tap to reveal

    Renard wants a steady supply, not a one-off. When Pedott glances at his case, Renard grabs a pair of shoes from it and puts them on.

  5. Wet pavementSpoiler · tap to reveal

    The shoes are too tight, with slippery soles. Renard goes for Pedott, slips on wet pavement and is hit by a car. Pedott had foreseen his own death and let Renard take the shoes to stop it.

Why it still matters

Most Twilight Zone episodes hand you a stranger and ask what you'd do in their place. This one hands you two, and they're built as opposites. Pedott (Ernest Truex) is a meek peddler who seems to know what people will need before they do. Fred Renard (Steve Cochran) is a hard-eyed bar regular. Serling's opening narration introduces him as a man with a chip on his shoulder the size of the national debt, thirty-six years old and looking for any way out.

It aired on Christmas Day 1959, which was also Serling's birthday. The small miracles early on are charming, but the pull comes from how far Renard is willing to push them. Watch Truex's face when Renard starts making demands. A lot of the story is in how carefully Pedott chooses what to say and what to hand over.

It's also a good case study in how Serling adapted other writers. The source is a 1945 story by Lewis Padgett, the shared pen name of Henry Kuttner and C. L. Moore, and it runs on a machine. Serling dropped the machine and gave the gift to an unexplained little man, which moves the story from science fiction toward folk tale. That swap is why it still plays as a fable and not a gadget plot.

Spoilers from here on. Pedott's gifts turn out to be for himself as well as his customers.

What the shoes were for

When Renard demands another thing he needs, Pedott glances nervously at his case. Renard takes the glance as a hint and grabs the shoes inside. Pedott insists they really are what Renard needs. Renard advances on him, slips on wet pavement and is killed by a car. Pedott then explains that he had foreseen his own death and let Renard take the shoes to prevent it, so the one who needed the gift most was the giver.

Padgett's story gets there by a different route. The seer, Talley, looks into his machine and sees Carmichael, the man who wants his services, eventually shooting him. He hands Carmichael plastic-soled shoes, and Carmichael slips off a subway platform in front of a train. Serling trades the subway for a car, the machine for a peddler, and the long-range plot for a single night. The result is cleaner and more fable-like.

That leaves a question the episode doesn't settle. Pedott gave Renard exactly what he needed to survive, and also exactly what he needed to die, and he knew both. Whether that's kindness, self-defense or something colder is up to you. Renard is a bully, so it's easy to shrug, but the same kind of gift that saved a ballplayer's career has just been used to end a man's life on purpose.

Behind the scenes

  • The story first ran in the October 1945 issue of Astounding Science Fiction under the Lewis Padgett byline, the joint pen name of Henry Kuttner and C. L. Moore.
  • Padgett's story had already been adapted for television once, as an episode of the anthology series Tales of Tomorrow. Serling's version removes the science-fiction device in favor of a street peddler.
  • Alvin Ganzer directed four Twilight Zone episodes, including "The Hitch-Hiker."
  • Van Cleave composed the music and George T. Clemens was director of photography.
  • Arline Sax, who plays the girl in the bar, was later known by the stage name Arlene Martel.

The thread

A seer who sees too much, from a 1945 pulp story to an earlier TV version and a Twilight Zone neighbor.

Came before

"What You Need" (short story)Lewis Padgett (Henry Kuttner and C. L. Moore) · story in Astounding Science Fiction · 1945 · the direct source, with a prediction machine in place of Pedott
"What You Need" (Tales of Tomorrow)Tales of Tomorrow · TV anthology episode · 1952 · an earlier television adaptation of the same story

Shares DNA with

DNA strand

The Cruel Twist

The set-up promises a kind fable about a man who gives people what they need. The twist turns the same gift into a trap, and it works because Renard builds it himself by grabbing at things he hasn't been offered. The ending only seems cruel until you notice who was holding the case.

Every great sci-fi story is built from a handful of strands like this one. Each strand page explains how it works and traces it across shows, books and films.

Also in this strand:"Escape Clause"Explore this strand →

If this one stayed with you

Where to go next, and why.

Watch · The Twilight Zone

"One for the Angels"

If you liked Truex's gentle old man, here's another street salesman with a talent and a little more at stake than he lets on. It's from the same first season and has the same fable shape.

Read · Short story

"What You Need" — Lewis Padgett

Read the source and see what Serling kept and what he changed. The set-up will feel familiar, but the machinery and the cast around it differ.

Read · Short story

"Mimsy Were the Borogoves" — Lewis Padgett

If you want more from the Kuttner and Moore pen name, this is a classic of theirs. It's a stranger, more tender kind of science fiction.

Sources