The Twilight Zone / Season 1 / Episode 13

The Four of Us are Dying

A con man who can wear any face he's seen goes looking for an easy payday. Four actors share the one role, and the casting was nearly as much trouble as the plot.

  • First aired Jan 1, 1960 · CBS
  • Directed by John Brahm
  • Teleplay by Rod Serling, from the story by George Clayton Johnson
  • Starring Harry Townes, Ross Martin, Phillip Pine and Don Gordon, with Beverly Garland
Still from The Twilight Zone, "The Four of Us are Dying"
Still from The Twilight Zone, "The Four of Us are Dying"
Image via TMDB
The Twilight Zone, "The Four of Us are Dying" (CBS, 1960). Image via TMDB.

The story in 5 beats

  1. A cheap hotel room

    Arch Hammer checks in with two bags, some newspaper clippings and an odd talent: with concentration, he can take on anyone's face.

  2. The jazz club

    As dead trumpeter Johnny Foster, he walks in on Foster's grieving girlfriend, the singer Maggie, and arranges to meet her at the train station.

  3. The mob boss

    In the face of a murdered gangster, Virgil Sterig, he leans on Mr. Penell for money, then has to run when Penell's men get suspicious.

  4. The alley

    Cornered, he copies a boxer from a poster, Andy Marshak, and slips past the goons. Then an old man on the street starts shouting at the boxer's face.

  5. The revolving doorSpoiler · tap to reveal

    A detective closes in on Hammer. He slips out of the hotel as Marshak, and the boxer's father is waiting outside with a gun.

Why it still matters

Most Twilight Zone stories hand someone a strange gift and wait to see what it costs. Arch Hammer's gift is that, with enough concentration, he can take the face of anyone he sees. He is a con man working from newspaper clippings, and the first two faces he picks belong to men who just died and left people behind: a trumpeter and a gangster. The third, a boxer, he takes off a poster.

The episode's big production problem is also its hook. One character is played by four actors, so the audience has to believe the same man is behind every face. They cast four men of similar build and coloring and tested them in groups. The story also came from George Clayton Johnson, who went on to write "A Game of Pool" and "Kick the Can" for the series.

Watch for John Brahm's camera work and for Jerry Goldsmith's score.

Spoilers from here on. The ending is a shooting on a hotel sidewalk, and the faces that come with it.

Whose face is it?

Hammer's last face is the one he borrowed on the spur of the moment, and it's the only one he didn't research. He has no idea that the old man who rants at him by the newsstand is Marshak's father, or how badly the son treated his family. When Hammer comes out of the hotel as Marshak again, the old man is waiting with a gun. Hammer can't concentrate with a gun on him, so he can't change back, and he can't talk the old man out of it. He is shot, and as he lies dying his face cycles through the faces he has worn until it settles on his own.

Hammer takes other men's faces for what they can give him: a woman's love, a stack of cash, an escape route. The last face comes with a debt, and Hammer pays it with his life. Serling's closing narration lists each of the four men by name and what he stood for.

Hammer's ending turns on whether he can focus. That leaves a fair argument: is Hammer undone by bad luck, or by never bothering to learn whose life he was wearing?

Behind the scenes

  • Producer Buck Houghton recalled that finding four look-alikes was a nightmare, in Marc Scott Zicree's The Twilight Zone Companion. At one point the team had three blond candidates and couldn't find a fourth.
  • The team switched to dark hair and brown eyes. Actors were grouped into quartets in similar dark suits and allowed only to ask questions about the story, so the producers could compare how they spoke and moved.
  • Casting director Mildred Gusse's plan, according to one episode writeup, was to call in men of a similar type: around five feet ten inches tall, with brown hair and dark eyes.
  • Johnson says his agent, Jay, crossed out the story's title and wrote in "Rubberface!" before sending it to Serling.
  • The city streets were sound-stage constructions on the MGM lot.
  • Jerry Goldsmith wrote the score. In 2005 the episode was produced for the stage by 4 Letter Entertainment.

DNA strand

Memory & Identity

Hammer can look like anyone, and he treats that as freedom. The episode asks what's left of a man who keeps borrowing other people's lives. The borrowed life that kills him is the one he knew least about.

Every great sci-fi story is built from a handful of strands like this one. Each strand page explains how it works and traces it across shows, books and films.

Also in this strand:"Polymorph"Explore this strand →

If this one stayed with you

Where to go next, and why.

Watch · Star Trek

"The Man Trap"

George Clayton Johnson, who wrote the story behind this episode, also wrote the first episode of Star Trek to air. It's a tense story about people who can't be sure who they're looking at.

Sources